Reply to Bosi et al. (2023)

Abstract

to XXII meeting of the IMA, Melbourne, Australia, 2018, 354. Bosi F., Hatert F, Hålenius U., Pasero M., Miyawaki R. and Mills S.J. (2019a) On the application of the IMA−CNMNC dominant-valency rule to complex mineral compositions. Mineralogical Magazine, 83, 627–632. Bosi F., Biagioni C. and Oberti R. (2019b) On the chemical identification and classification of minerals. Minerals, 9, 591–603. Bosi F., Hatert F., Pasero M., Mills S.J., Miyawaki R. and Halenius U. (2023) A brief comment on Hawthorne (2023): “On the definition of distinct mineral species: A critique of current IMA-CNMNC procedures”.Mineralogical Magazine, 87, 505–507, doi:10.1180/mgm.2023.33 Gagné O. and Hawthorne F.C. (2016) Chemographic exploration of the milarite-type structure. The Canadian Mineralogist, 54, 1229–1247. Hatert F. and Burke E.A.J. (2008) The IMA–CNMNC dominant-constituent rule revisited and extended. The Canadian Mineralogist, 46, 717–728. Hawthorne F.C. (2002) The use of end-member charge-arrangements in defining new mineral species and heterovalent substitutions in complex minerals. The Canadian Mineralogist, 40, 699–710. Hawthorne F.C. (2021) Proof that a dominant endmember formula can always be written for a mineral or a crystal structure. The Canadian Mineralogist, 59, 159–167. Hawthorne F.C. (2023) On the definition of distinct mineral species: A critique of current IMA-CNMNC procedures. Mineralogical Magazine, 87, 494– 504, doi:10.1180/mgm.2023.8 Hawthorne F.C., Sokolova E., Agakhanov A.A., Pautov L.A., Karpenko V.Yu. and Grew E.S. (2018) Chemographic exploration of the hyalotekite structure-type. Mineralogical Magazine, 82, 929–937. Hawthorne F.C., Mills S.J., Hatert F. and Rumsey M.S. (2021) Ontology, archetypes and the definition of “mineral species”. Mineralogical Magazine, 85, 125–131; erratum, 85, 830. Nickel E.H. (1992) Solid solutions in mineral nomenclature. The Canadian Mineralogist, 30, 231–234. Nickel E.H. and Grice J.D. (1998) The IMA commission on new minerals and mineral names: procedures and guidelines on mineral nomenclature. The Canadian Mineralogist, 36, 913–926. 510 Frank C. Hawthorne