Microbial community and network differently reshaped by crushed straw or biochar incorporation and associated with nitrogen fertilizer level

Abstract

Straw returning has been demonstrated as a beneficial approach for the utilization of renewable biomass source, which contributes to reducing environmental pollution and strengthening the sustainability of agriculture. However, information on how microorganisms respond to different straw return modes (SRMs) at varying nitrogen fertilizer levels (NFLs) in the black soil is still limited. The community composition, network pattern, and modular function of bacteria and fungi are investigated under three SRMs, including straw removal (CK), crushed straw incorporation (SD), and biochar incorporation (BC) at three NFLs (0, 144, and 240 kg N ha⁻¹, respectively) mainly using Illumina MiSeq technique based on a long-term maize field experiment. Results showed that bacterial richness, diversity, and fungal richness decreased with NFL reduction. However, these decreases can be compensated by SD and BC, demonstrating superiority for BC at reduced NFLs. SD and BC differed in their effects on the bacterial and fungal abundances (showing increments only in SD) and fungal Shannon diversity (remaining stable only in BC irrespective of NFLs). Microbial communities were substantially affected by SRMs and interacted with NFLs, which were driven by soil NH₄⁺-N, available potassium, total nitrogen, and pH. In addition, SD induced a network characterized by its highly complex (average degree 10.259 vs. 3.364) and stable structure (average clustering coefficient 0.503 vs. 0.239), Ascomycota as predominating keystone taxa, and abundant N-cycling related bacteria, while BC formed a network comprising a superior modular structure (modularity 2.599 vs. 0.912), dominant symbiotic fungi, and soil bulk density as specific shaping factor, indicating that network pattern, keystone taxa, modular function, and determining factors shifted between SD and BC co-occurrence networks. These results deepen insights into the response divergence of bacteria and fungi to SRMs and NFLs, providing a scientific basis for selecting the suitable strategy for sustainable straw utilization in the black soil area.