Effect of 1.5 mm biter-width meniscectomy on cadaveric knee pressure, peak pressure, force, and contact area

Abstract

This study investigated the immediate biomechanical effects of a biter-width partial medial meniscectomy. Small tears on the free edge of the meniscus are occasionally discovered during arthroscopic knee procedures. Removal of these tears often requires no more width than that of a biter from the edge. While past cadaveric partial meniscectomy studies have reported on the effects of meniscectomies from resection of one-third to three-quarters of meniscal width, the biomechanical sequelae of substantially smaller meniscectomies remain unknown. This study was performed to determine how single-biter-width meniscectomies affect the pressure distribution and peak pressure on the tibial plateau, as these parameters are correlated with increased likelihood of development of osteoarthritis. Eight cadaveric knees were instrumented with a thin-film pressure sensor underneath the menisci while retaining the major ligaments and most of the capsule. Knees were loaded to 1000 N at angles of flexion of 0, 15, 30, and 45 in normal tibio-femoral angles and in 7° of varus. Pressure, peak pressure, force and contact area were recorded. Afterwards, biter-width meniscectomies were performed, and measures repeated. There were significant changes in contact area at most flexion and tibio-femoral angles. There were no changes in the amount of force that was transmitted through the medial compartment. The overall pressure on the tibial plateau did not change in most knee conditions and peak pressure did not change significantly in any condition. The changes in contact area were consistent with our expectations. Similarly, the lack of change in force was also expected. However, the lack of significant changes in pressure and peak pressure represent findings indicating that a biter sized meniscectomy may have clinically insignificant effects on biomechanics.