Roundtable on Bhakti Shringapure’s Cold War Assemblages: Decolonization to Digital (New York and London, Routledge, 2020, 218 pages, ISBN 9780367670900)
{"title":"Roundtable on Bhakti Shringapure’s Cold War Assemblages: Decolonization to Digital (New York and London, Routledge, 2020, 218 pages, ISBN 9780367670900)","authors":"G. Musila","doi":"10.1080/02533952.2021.1960127","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Cold War Assemblages: Decolonisation to Digital (Shringarpure 2020) is an incisive response to the paucity of sustained engagement with the legacies of the Cold War in postcolonial literary and cultural studies despite the stark historical reality that the iron curtain was partly sustained by turning the Third World into a battlefield where “proxy wars, coups, assassinations, weapons flooding, installation of dictators, and massive cultural interventions became commonplace” (110). This richly textured intervention insists that, contrary to perceptions of European colonialism and the Cold War as disparate epochs in postcolonial experience, the Cold War overlapped with the decolonisation project in the Third World, plunging these nations into cycles of chaos that persist to date, conventionally described in the short-hand of endemic violence, fallen revolutionaries and failed states. Temporality has been a highly charged vector in postcolonial studies, as exemplified by works such as David Scott’s (2013) rethinking of the Grenada revolution; Keguro Macharia’s (2020) notion of belatedness as a discursive frame that maps colonial modernity’s delegitimisations of Africans; and Andrew van der Vlies’ (2017) reflection on the ostensible collapse of time in post-apartheid South Africa; or, to paraphrase Scott (2004), what happens when the futures once imagined now lie behind us, with their promises undelivered. Cold War Assemblages extends these explorations, by asking: “how does one theorise the ontology of a nation from whom time itself was stolen?” (17). The book is framed in two parts: the first explores the question of violence through leader-thinker figures of revolution – Frantz Fanon, Mahatma Gandhi, Thomas Sankara, Amilcar Cabral and Patrice Lumumba – each of whom variously grappled with colonial violence and the challenge of nation formation in the era of decolonisation. On Fanon and Gandhi, Shringarpure is interested in the challenges emerging from their attempts to simultaneously theorise and lead anticolonial movements in their respective contexts of India and Algeria; and the contradictions resulting from these competing demands for objective theorisation and pragmatic interventions in anticolonial revolutions. In its discussion of the systematic assassinations of three major revolutionary leaders in Africa – Sankara, Lumumba and Cabral – Cold War Assemblages contests arguments about the failures of the postcolonial Marxist left, by excavating the Cold War’s","PeriodicalId":51765,"journal":{"name":"Social Dynamics-A Journal of African Studies","volume":"47 1","pages":"329 - 331"},"PeriodicalIF":0.5000,"publicationDate":"2021-05-04","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://sci-hub-pdf.com/10.1080/02533952.2021.1960127","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Social Dynamics-A Journal of African Studies","FirstCategoryId":"90","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1080/02533952.2021.1960127","RegionNum":3,"RegionCategory":"社会学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q3","JCRName":"AREA STUDIES","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Cold War Assemblages: Decolonisation to Digital (Shringarpure 2020) is an incisive response to the paucity of sustained engagement with the legacies of the Cold War in postcolonial literary and cultural studies despite the stark historical reality that the iron curtain was partly sustained by turning the Third World into a battlefield where “proxy wars, coups, assassinations, weapons flooding, installation of dictators, and massive cultural interventions became commonplace” (110). This richly textured intervention insists that, contrary to perceptions of European colonialism and the Cold War as disparate epochs in postcolonial experience, the Cold War overlapped with the decolonisation project in the Third World, plunging these nations into cycles of chaos that persist to date, conventionally described in the short-hand of endemic violence, fallen revolutionaries and failed states. Temporality has been a highly charged vector in postcolonial studies, as exemplified by works such as David Scott’s (2013) rethinking of the Grenada revolution; Keguro Macharia’s (2020) notion of belatedness as a discursive frame that maps colonial modernity’s delegitimisations of Africans; and Andrew van der Vlies’ (2017) reflection on the ostensible collapse of time in post-apartheid South Africa; or, to paraphrase Scott (2004), what happens when the futures once imagined now lie behind us, with their promises undelivered. Cold War Assemblages extends these explorations, by asking: “how does one theorise the ontology of a nation from whom time itself was stolen?” (17). The book is framed in two parts: the first explores the question of violence through leader-thinker figures of revolution – Frantz Fanon, Mahatma Gandhi, Thomas Sankara, Amilcar Cabral and Patrice Lumumba – each of whom variously grappled with colonial violence and the challenge of nation formation in the era of decolonisation. On Fanon and Gandhi, Shringarpure is interested in the challenges emerging from their attempts to simultaneously theorise and lead anticolonial movements in their respective contexts of India and Algeria; and the contradictions resulting from these competing demands for objective theorisation and pragmatic interventions in anticolonial revolutions. In its discussion of the systematic assassinations of three major revolutionary leaders in Africa – Sankara, Lumumba and Cabral – Cold War Assemblages contests arguments about the failures of the postcolonial Marxist left, by excavating the Cold War’s
《冷战组合:从去殖民化到数字化》(Shringarpure, 2020)是对后殖民文学和文化研究中缺乏与冷战遗产持续接触的深刻回应,尽管严酷的历史现实是,铁幕在一定程度上是通过将第三世界变成“代理人战争、政变、暗杀、武器泛滥、独裁者的安装和大规模文化干预变得司空见惯”的战场而维持的(110)。与欧洲殖民主义和冷战是后殖民时期不同时代的看法相反,这本内容丰富的干预书坚持认为,冷战与第三世界的非殖民化项目重叠,使这些国家陷入持续至今的混乱循环,通常用当地暴力、堕落的革命者和失败国家的简称来描述。在后殖民研究中,时间性一直是一个高度敏感的载体,例如大卫·斯科特(2013)对格林纳达革命的反思;Keguro Macharia(2020)的迟来性概念作为一种话语框架,描绘了殖民现代性对非洲人的非合法性;安德鲁·范德弗利斯(Andrew van der Vlies, 2017)对后种族隔离时代南非表面上的时间崩溃的反思;或者,用斯科特(Scott, 2004)的话来说,当我们曾经想象的未来已经离我们而去,而承诺却没有兑现时,会发生什么。《冷战汇编》扩展了这些探索,提出了这样的问题:“一个人如何将一个时间本身被偷走的国家的本体论理论化?””(17)。本书分为两部分:第一部分通过革命思想家领袖人物——弗朗茨·法农、圣雄甘地、托马斯·桑卡拉、阿米尔卡·卡布拉尔和帕特里斯·卢蒙巴——探讨暴力问题,他们每个人都以不同的方式应对殖民暴力和非殖民化时代国家形成的挑战。关于法农和甘地,施林加pure对他们在印度和阿尔及利亚各自背景下试图同时提出理论并领导反殖民运动所带来的挑战感兴趣;在反殖民革命中,客观理论化和实用主义干预的竞争需求导致了矛盾。在讨论有系统地暗杀非洲三位主要革命领导人——桑卡拉、卢蒙巴和卡布拉尔的过程中,《冷战汇编》通过挖掘冷战的失败,对后殖民马克思主义左翼的失败进行了争论
期刊介绍:
Social Dynamics is the journal of the Centre for African Studies at the University of Cape Town, South Africa. It has been published since 1975, and is committed to advancing interdisciplinary academic research, fostering debate and addressing current issues pertaining to the African continent. Articles cover the full range of humanities and social sciences including anthropology, archaeology, economics, education, history, literary and language studies, music, politics, psychology and sociology.