Assessing the ability of adaptive designs to capture trends in hard coral cover

Abstract

Coral reefs have become one of the most vulnerable ecosystems worldwide due to rising environmental and anthropogenic pressures. Methods from experimental design can be used to furnish our ability to monitor such ecosystems efficiently. Recently, adaptive design approaches have been proposed for monitoring coral reefs; however, questions have surfaced around the ability of such approaches to capture trends over time. The aim of this study was to develop an approach to assess trends in hard coral cover and evaluate the effectiveness of adaptive designs for estimating such trends in coral reef communities within a region of the Great Barrier Reef. Our approach was couched within a Bayesian design and inference framework such that uncertainty was captured rigorously and so that information from accumulating data can be incorporated straightforwardly to inform future data collection. The designs found under this approach were compared to historical non-adaptive designs which surveyed all locations over time. Through this comparison, we show that adaptive designs can maintain trends over time with little to no loss in information, even when sampling effort is substantially reduced. Accordingly, this research serves to further promote adaptive design methods for efficiently and effectively sampling in ecological monitoring.