Numerical evaluation of the ductile fracture for AA6101-T4 and AISI 4340 alloys using the Lemaitre and Gurson models

Abstract

This paper provides a numerical assessment of the ductile fracture of the AA6101 and AISI 4340 alloys using the Lemaitre and Gurson models.The simulations were carried out to verify the evolution of the accumulated plastic strain at fracture, assuming the high range of the triaxiality ratio, applying monotonic tensile loads on smooth and notched cylindrical specimens. The numerical strategy was structured for the Lemaitre and Gurson models, from establishing a non-linear system of equations using an implicit integration algorithm and solving the non-linear equation system using the Newton-Raphson method. When assessing the numerical and experimental results, it was observed that the cumulative plastic strain at the fracture decreases with the increasing levels of the triaxiality ratio for both alloys and models. On the one hand, the Lemaitre model was more optimistic than the experimental results. On the other hand, Gurson’s model proved to be more conservative in its prediction of ductile fracture. Regarding determining the fracture onset, in general, both models showed good predictive capacity. However, the numerical results for the aluminum alloy presented more in agreement with experimental data than for the AISI 4340 alloy. In the end, assuming the determination of the level of displacement at fracture, the Gurson’s model has the best performance. In this sense, for a high level of triaxiality ratio, the Gurson porous material can be recommended to describe the mechanical behavior of the material at fracture.