Memory scheduling for modern microprocessors

Abstract

The need to carefully schedule memory operations has increased as memory performance has become increasingly important to overall system performance. This article describes the adaptive history-based (AHB) scheduler, which uses the history of recently scheduled operations to provide three conceptual benefits: (1) it allows the scheduler to better reason about the delays associated with its scheduling decisions, (2) it provides a mechanism for combining multiple constraints, which is important for increasingly complex DRAM structures, and (3) it allows the scheduler to select operations so that they match the program's mixture of Reads and Writes, thereby avoiding certain bottlenecks within the memory controller. We have previously evaluated this scheduler in the context of the IBM Power5. When compared with the state of the art, this scheduler improves performance by 15.6%, 9.9%, and 7.6% for the Stream, NAS, and commercial benchmarks, respectively. This article expands our understanding of the AHB scheduler in a variety of ways. Looking backwards, we describe the scheduler in the context of prior work that focused exclusively on avoiding bank conflicts, and we show that the AHB scheduler is superior for the IBM Power5, which we argue will be representative of future microprocessor memory controllers. Looking forwards, we evaluate this scheduler in the context of future systems by varying a number of microarchitectural features and hardware parameters. For example, we show that the benefit of this scheduler increases as we move to multithreaded environments.