Interindividual variability in metabolic adaptation of non-exercise activity thermogenesis after a 1-year weight loss intervention in former elite athletes.

Abstract

Lack of efficacy of weight loss(WL) interventions is attributed in-part to low adherence to dietary/physical activity(PA) recommendations. However, some compensation may occur in PA as a response to energy restriction such as a decrease in non-exercise PA(NEPA) or non-exercise activity thermogenesis(NEAT). The current study aim was (1) to investigate whether adaptive thermogenesis(AT) in NEAT occurs after WL, and (2) to understand the associations of these compensations with WL. Ninety-four former athletes [mean±SD, age: 43.0±9.4y, BMI: 31.1±4.3 kg/m², 34.0% female] were recruited and randomly assigned to intervention or control groups (IG, CG). The IG underwent a one-year lifestyle WL-intervention; no treatments were administered to the CG. PA was measured using accelerometery and NEAT was predicted with a model including sample baseline characteristics. AT was calculated as _measuredNEAT^4mo/12mo_(kcal/d)-_predictedNEAT^4mo/12mo_(kcal/d)-_measuredNEAT^baseline_(kcal/d)-_predictedNEAT^baseline_(kcal/d). Dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry was used to assess fat-free mass and fat mass. No differences were found in the IG for NEAT or NEPA after WL. Considering mean values, AT was not found for either group. The SD of individual response (SD_IR) for AT was -2(4-months) and 24(12-months) (smallest worthwhile change = 87kcal/d), suggesting that the interindividual variability regarding AT in NEAT is not relevant and the variability in this outcome might reflect a large within-subject variability and/or a large degree of random measurement error. No associations were found between AT in NEAT and changes in body composition. Further studies are needed to clarify the mechanisms behind the large variability in AT observed in NEAT and related changes in NEPA to better implement lifestyle-induced WL interventions.HighlightsNo significant differences were found for non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT) or non-exercise physical activity (NEPA) after the weight loss (WL) intervention;Although a large variability was found for NEAT and NEPA, the interindividual variability regarding these outcomes is not relevant. The variability in these outcomes might reflect a large within-subject variability and/or a large degree of random measurement error;Although no energy conservation was observed in NEAT after moderate WL (mean values), further studies are needed to clarify the mechanisms behind the large variability in adaptive thermogenesis observed in NEAT and related changes in NEPA to better implement lifestyle-induced WL interventions.Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT03031951.