Comparison between back-to-back MMC and M3C as high power AC/AC converters

Fractional frequency transmission system (FFTS) is a promising solution to offshore wind power integration. The back-to-back modular multilevel converter (MMC) and modular multilevel matrix converter (M3C) are universally regarded as two promising ac/ac converter candidates of the next generation. This paper performs a detailed comparison between back-to-back MMC and M3C with special emphasis on their total capacitor and semiconductor ratings. The arm current and capacitor ripples are first analyzed, then comparison results of a 220 kV, 500 MW case is given. In terms of peak-current-based and RMS-current-based total semiconductor ratings the M3C is 42.56 % and 22.97 % larger respectively, while its total capacitor rating is merely 33.15% of the back-to-back MMC. The better candidate can be determined according to the quantitative comparison results and the latest prices of semiconductors and capacitors.