欲望溶剂:米娜·洛伊如何超越乔治·巴塔耶

Sara Crangle
{"title":"欲望溶剂:米娜·洛伊如何超越乔治·巴塔耶","authors":"Sara Crangle","doi":"10.5840/JPHILNEPAL201061327","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"In a poem first published in 1923, Mina Loy describes the human ego as a \"carnose horologe\"--a fleshy, time--telling instrument. (1) While an ego is arguably circumscribed by flesh, it is not usually considered fleshy; Loy's use of \"carnose\" asks us to reconfigure the ego as inseparable from its body, and this demand jars against the definition of carnality as opposed to all things spiritual or intellectual. More specifically, carnality refers to the body as the seat of passions or appetites, proclivities sensual or sexual in nature. In Loy's writing, she frequently toys with the term carnality, its variants, and its extended meanings. \"Mass Production on 14th Street\" is a poem about the excesses of market capitalism; here Loy associates and aligns carnality with carnival, writing that the \"iris circus of Industry\" generates \"orgies of orchid\" among a foliage of mass-production: carnations tossed at a carnal caravan for Carnevale. (2) Loy employs a floral conceit that returns us repeatedly to the body: \"iris\" being both plant and centre of the eye, or locus of perception; \"carnation\" a crown-like flower whose name is associated with \"coronation\" and \"incarnation.\" \"Carnation\" thus connotes the revered-becoming sovereign--and one of the most celebrated acts of humility in Western culture: Christ's decision to take up human form. But Loy's poem exhibits no deference to the venerable flower; tossed at a carnal caravan, these carnations are sacrificed to Loy's carnivalesque diction (circus, orgy, carnevale) and syntax, her deliberate repetition of sounds and word play. As Loy writes in a poem on Joyce: \"The word made flesh\" can \"fee[d] on itself.\" (3) Loy does not associate the deific or sovereign with the act of communication; hers is a self-sufficient, secular view of the word. Loy's writing strives to embody language and explore the language of embodiment; the human subject frequently dissolves in the wake of her struggle with the physicalities of life and language. I am suggesting that Loy presents us with a dissolute self-a self disunited, unrestrained, and wanton--even as I am aware that there is a tacit, longstanding disagreement among critics as to whether Loy's writing articulates a self entire, one capable of transcendence, or a self mired in and sustained by the vicissitudes of the flesh. (4) My own sense is that Loy's presentation of the subject is fed by her fascination with human passions. This fascination underscores her understanding that the self is innately, endlessly divided--nothing akin to an inviolate whole. As such, Loy's alignment of carnality and the carnivalesque in \"Mass Production\" is not incidental, but integral to her oeuvre; for Loy, human appetites are often comical, even uproarious. In what follows, I will consider Loy's use of risibility--the desire to laugh--as it accompanies and extends her examinations of other desires such as sexuality and hunger. Like Loy, many modernist philosophers were preoccupied with laughter; its causes and effects earned the attention of Nietzsche, Bergson, and Freud, among others. Their discussion had a notable effect on Loy, and on the work of many of her peers, of which Wyndham Lewis's The Wild Body (1927) serves as a particularly cogent example. Loy can be seen responding to philosophies of laughter in her best-known poem sequence, \"Songs to Joannes\" (1917), where she portrays risibility and sexuality as conduits to ecstasy. In so doing, Loy foregrounds the precepts of one of Nietzsche's philosophical descendents, namely Georges Bataille. In the thirties, Loy writes Insel, a novel where her interest in carnality does not abate, but shifts direction. The book is about Mrs Jones, an artist and art dealer living in Paris who attempts to mentor the reclusive and impoverished artist Insel, a figure tangentially associated with the Surrealist movement. (5) The couple are described as clowns who talk, laugh, and eat together. …","PeriodicalId":288505,"journal":{"name":"Journal of Philosophy: A Cross-Disciplinary Inquiry","volume":"14 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2010-11-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Desires Dissolvent: How Mina Loy Exceeds George Bataille\",\"authors\":\"Sara Crangle\",\"doi\":\"10.5840/JPHILNEPAL201061327\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"In a poem first published in 1923, Mina Loy describes the human ego as a \\\"carnose horologe\\\"--a fleshy, time--telling instrument. (1) While an ego is arguably circumscribed by flesh, it is not usually considered fleshy; Loy's use of \\\"carnose\\\" asks us to reconfigure the ego as inseparable from its body, and this demand jars against the definition of carnality as opposed to all things spiritual or intellectual. More specifically, carnality refers to the body as the seat of passions or appetites, proclivities sensual or sexual in nature. In Loy's writing, she frequently toys with the term carnality, its variants, and its extended meanings. \\\"Mass Production on 14th Street\\\" is a poem about the excesses of market capitalism; here Loy associates and aligns carnality with carnival, writing that the \\\"iris circus of Industry\\\" generates \\\"orgies of orchid\\\" among a foliage of mass-production: carnations tossed at a carnal caravan for Carnevale. (2) Loy employs a floral conceit that returns us repeatedly to the body: \\\"iris\\\" being both plant and centre of the eye, or locus of perception; \\\"carnation\\\" a crown-like flower whose name is associated with \\\"coronation\\\" and \\\"incarnation.\\\" \\\"Carnation\\\" thus connotes the revered-becoming sovereign--and one of the most celebrated acts of humility in Western culture: Christ's decision to take up human form. But Loy's poem exhibits no deference to the venerable flower; tossed at a carnal caravan, these carnations are sacrificed to Loy's carnivalesque diction (circus, orgy, carnevale) and syntax, her deliberate repetition of sounds and word play. As Loy writes in a poem on Joyce: \\\"The word made flesh\\\" can \\\"fee[d] on itself.\\\" (3) Loy does not associate the deific or sovereign with the act of communication; hers is a self-sufficient, secular view of the word. Loy's writing strives to embody language and explore the language of embodiment; the human subject frequently dissolves in the wake of her struggle with the physicalities of life and language. I am suggesting that Loy presents us with a dissolute self-a self disunited, unrestrained, and wanton--even as I am aware that there is a tacit, longstanding disagreement among critics as to whether Loy's writing articulates a self entire, one capable of transcendence, or a self mired in and sustained by the vicissitudes of the flesh. (4) My own sense is that Loy's presentation of the subject is fed by her fascination with human passions. This fascination underscores her understanding that the self is innately, endlessly divided--nothing akin to an inviolate whole. As such, Loy's alignment of carnality and the carnivalesque in \\\"Mass Production\\\" is not incidental, but integral to her oeuvre; for Loy, human appetites are often comical, even uproarious. In what follows, I will consider Loy's use of risibility--the desire to laugh--as it accompanies and extends her examinations of other desires such as sexuality and hunger. Like Loy, many modernist philosophers were preoccupied with laughter; its causes and effects earned the attention of Nietzsche, Bergson, and Freud, among others. Their discussion had a notable effect on Loy, and on the work of many of her peers, of which Wyndham Lewis's The Wild Body (1927) serves as a particularly cogent example. Loy can be seen responding to philosophies of laughter in her best-known poem sequence, \\\"Songs to Joannes\\\" (1917), where she portrays risibility and sexuality as conduits to ecstasy. In so doing, Loy foregrounds the precepts of one of Nietzsche's philosophical descendents, namely Georges Bataille. In the thirties, Loy writes Insel, a novel where her interest in carnality does not abate, but shifts direction. The book is about Mrs Jones, an artist and art dealer living in Paris who attempts to mentor the reclusive and impoverished artist Insel, a figure tangentially associated with the Surrealist movement. (5) The couple are described as clowns who talk, laugh, and eat together. …\",\"PeriodicalId\":288505,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Journal of Philosophy: A Cross-Disciplinary Inquiry\",\"volume\":\"14 1\",\"pages\":\"0\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2010-11-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Journal of Philosophy: A Cross-Disciplinary Inquiry\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.5840/JPHILNEPAL201061327\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Journal of Philosophy: A Cross-Disciplinary Inquiry","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.5840/JPHILNEPAL201061327","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

米娜·洛伊(Mina Loy)在1923年首次发表的一首诗中,将人类的自我描述为“carnose horloge”——一种肉乎乎的计时仪器。(1)虽然可以说自我受到肉体的限制,但它通常不被认为是肉体的;洛伊对“肉体”的使用要求我们重新配置自我,使其与身体不可分割,而这种要求与肉体的定义相抵触,肉体的定义与所有精神或智力的事物相对立。更具体地说,肉欲指的是身体作为激情或欲望的所在地,本质上是感性或性的倾向。在洛伊的作品中,她经常玩弄肉体这个词,它的变体,以及它的延伸含义。《14街的大规模生产》(Mass Production on 14th Street)是一首关于市场资本主义过度行为的诗;在这里,洛伊将肉欲与狂欢节联系起来,并将其联系起来,他写道,“工业的鸢尾花马戏团”在大规模生产的树叶中产生了“兰花的狂欢”:康乃馨被扔在狂欢节的肉欲车队里。(2)洛伊运用了一种花卉的自负,使我们不断地回到身体上:“虹膜”既是植物,又是眼睛的中心,或者是感知的中心;康乃馨是一种皇冠状的花,它的名字与“加冕”和“化身”联系在一起。因此,“康乃馨”意味着受人尊敬的君主——以及西方文化中最著名的谦卑行为之一:基督决定以人的形式出现。但是洛伊的诗没有表现出对这朵可敬的花的尊敬;这些康乃馨被扔在肉欲的大篷车上,被洛伊狂欢式的措辞(circus, orgy, carnevale)和语法、她刻意重复的声音和文字游戏所牺牲。正如洛伊在一首关于乔伊斯的诗中所写的那样:“成为肉体”这个词可以“自食其力”。(3) Loy不将神灵或君主与沟通行为联系起来;她对世界的看法是自给自足的、世俗的。洛伊的写作力求体现语言,探索体现语言;在她与生命和语言的物质斗争中,人类主体经常消失。我想说的是,洛伊呈现给我们的是一个放荡的自我——一个分裂的、不受约束的、放荡的自我——尽管我意识到,批评家们长期以来对洛伊的作品是表达了一个完整的自我,一个能够超越的自我,还是一个深陷并被肉体的沧桑所维持的自我,存在着一种默契的分歧。(4)我个人的感觉是,洛伊对这一主题的呈现是由她对人类激情的迷恋所滋养的。这种迷恋强调了她的理解,即自我是天生的,无休止的分裂——没有什么类似于一个不可侵犯的整体。因此,洛伊在《大规模生产》中对肉欲和狂欢的结合不是偶然的,而是她作品中不可或缺的一部分;对洛伊来说,人类的胃口常常是滑稽的,甚至是滑稽的。在接下来的文章中,我将考虑洛伊对可见性——笑的欲望——的运用,因为它伴随着并扩展了她对其他欲望的考察,比如性和饥饿。像洛伊一样,许多现代主义哲学家都全神贯注于笑;它的因果关系引起了尼采、柏格森和弗洛伊德等人的注意。他们的讨论对洛伊和她的许多同行的作品产生了显著的影响,其中温德姆·刘易斯的《野体》(1927)就是一个特别令人信服的例子。在她最著名的诗作《致乔安娜之歌》(Songs to Joannes, 1917)中,我们可以看到洛伊对笑的哲学的回应。在诗中,她将可见性和性描绘成通往狂喜的管道。在这样做的过程中,洛伊强调了尼采的哲学后裔之一,即乔治·巴塔耶的戒律。三十多岁时,洛伊写了《因塞尔》,在这部小说中,她对肉欲的兴趣并没有减弱,而是转向了方向。这本书是关于琼斯夫人的,她是一位住在巴黎的艺术家和艺术品经销商,她试图指导隐居和贫困的艺术家因塞尔,一个与超现实主义运动有密切联系的人物。这对夫妇被形容为小丑,一起说话,一起笑,一起吃。…
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
查看原文
分享 分享
微信好友 朋友圈 QQ好友 复制链接
本刊更多论文
Desires Dissolvent: How Mina Loy Exceeds George Bataille
In a poem first published in 1923, Mina Loy describes the human ego as a "carnose horologe"--a fleshy, time--telling instrument. (1) While an ego is arguably circumscribed by flesh, it is not usually considered fleshy; Loy's use of "carnose" asks us to reconfigure the ego as inseparable from its body, and this demand jars against the definition of carnality as opposed to all things spiritual or intellectual. More specifically, carnality refers to the body as the seat of passions or appetites, proclivities sensual or sexual in nature. In Loy's writing, she frequently toys with the term carnality, its variants, and its extended meanings. "Mass Production on 14th Street" is a poem about the excesses of market capitalism; here Loy associates and aligns carnality with carnival, writing that the "iris circus of Industry" generates "orgies of orchid" among a foliage of mass-production: carnations tossed at a carnal caravan for Carnevale. (2) Loy employs a floral conceit that returns us repeatedly to the body: "iris" being both plant and centre of the eye, or locus of perception; "carnation" a crown-like flower whose name is associated with "coronation" and "incarnation." "Carnation" thus connotes the revered-becoming sovereign--and one of the most celebrated acts of humility in Western culture: Christ's decision to take up human form. But Loy's poem exhibits no deference to the venerable flower; tossed at a carnal caravan, these carnations are sacrificed to Loy's carnivalesque diction (circus, orgy, carnevale) and syntax, her deliberate repetition of sounds and word play. As Loy writes in a poem on Joyce: "The word made flesh" can "fee[d] on itself." (3) Loy does not associate the deific or sovereign with the act of communication; hers is a self-sufficient, secular view of the word. Loy's writing strives to embody language and explore the language of embodiment; the human subject frequently dissolves in the wake of her struggle with the physicalities of life and language. I am suggesting that Loy presents us with a dissolute self-a self disunited, unrestrained, and wanton--even as I am aware that there is a tacit, longstanding disagreement among critics as to whether Loy's writing articulates a self entire, one capable of transcendence, or a self mired in and sustained by the vicissitudes of the flesh. (4) My own sense is that Loy's presentation of the subject is fed by her fascination with human passions. This fascination underscores her understanding that the self is innately, endlessly divided--nothing akin to an inviolate whole. As such, Loy's alignment of carnality and the carnivalesque in "Mass Production" is not incidental, but integral to her oeuvre; for Loy, human appetites are often comical, even uproarious. In what follows, I will consider Loy's use of risibility--the desire to laugh--as it accompanies and extends her examinations of other desires such as sexuality and hunger. Like Loy, many modernist philosophers were preoccupied with laughter; its causes and effects earned the attention of Nietzsche, Bergson, and Freud, among others. Their discussion had a notable effect on Loy, and on the work of many of her peers, of which Wyndham Lewis's The Wild Body (1927) serves as a particularly cogent example. Loy can be seen responding to philosophies of laughter in her best-known poem sequence, "Songs to Joannes" (1917), where she portrays risibility and sexuality as conduits to ecstasy. In so doing, Loy foregrounds the precepts of one of Nietzsche's philosophical descendents, namely Georges Bataille. In the thirties, Loy writes Insel, a novel where her interest in carnality does not abate, but shifts direction. The book is about Mrs Jones, an artist and art dealer living in Paris who attempts to mentor the reclusive and impoverished artist Insel, a figure tangentially associated with the Surrealist movement. (5) The couple are described as clowns who talk, laugh, and eat together. …
求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
自引率
0.00%
发文量
0
期刊最新文献
Emily Dickinson: What Is Called Thinking at the Edge of Chaos? Relational Selves: Gender and Cultural Differences in Moral Reasoning Late Pound: The Case of Canto CVII The Reproduction of Subjectivity and the Turnover-time of Ideology: Speculating with German Idealism, Marx, and Adorno Toward an Ethics of Speculative Design
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
现在去查看 取消
×
提示
确定
0
微信
客服QQ
Book学术公众号 扫码关注我们
反馈
×
意见反馈
请填写您的意见或建议
请填写您的手机或邮箱
已复制链接
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
×
扫码分享
扫码分享
Book学术官方微信
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术
文献互助 智能选刊 最新文献 互助须知 联系我们:info@booksci.cn
Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。
Copyright © 2023 Book学术 All rights reserved.
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号 京ICP备2023020795号-1