Xu Cong, Hao Huaying, Wang Yang, Ma Yuhui, Yan Qifeng, Chen Bang, Ma Shaodong, Wang Xiaogui, Zhao Yitian
{"title":"基于潜在向量对齐和swin Transformer的OCTA图像血管分割","authors":"Xu Cong, Hao Huaying, Wang Yang, Ma Yuhui, Yan Qifeng, Chen Bang, Ma Shaodong, Wang Xiaogui, Zhao Yitian","doi":"10.11834/jig.220482","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"目的 光学相干断层扫描血管造影(optical coherence tomography angiography,OCTA)是一种非侵入式的新兴技术,越来越多地应用于视网膜血管成像。与传统眼底彩照相比,OCTA 技术能够显示黄斑周围的微血管信息,在视网膜血管成像邻域具有显著优势。临床实践中,医生可以通过 OCTA 图像观察不同层的血管结构,并通过分析血管结构的变化来判断是否存在相关疾病。大量研究表明,血管结构的任何异常变化通常都意味着存在某种眼科疾病。因此,对 OCTA 图像中的视网膜血管结构进行自动分割提取,对众多眼部相关疾病量化分析和临床决策具有重大意义。然而,OCTA 图像存在视网膜血管结构复杂、图像整体对比度低等问题,给自动分割带来极大挑战。为此,提出了一种新颖的融合隐向量对齐和 Swin Transformer 的视网膜血管结构的分割方法,能够实现血管结构的精准分割。方法 以 ResU-Net 为主干网络,通过 Swin Transformer 编码器获取丰富的血管特征信息。此外,设计了一种基于隐向量的特征对齐损失函数,能够在隐空间层次对网络进行优化,提升分割性能。结果 在 3 个 OCTA 图像数据集上的实验结果表明,本文方法的 AUC(area under curce)分别为 94.15%,94.87% 和 97.63%,ACC(accuracy)分别为 91.57%,90.03% 和 91.06%,领先其他对比方法,并且整体分割性能达到最佳。结论 本文提出的视网膜血管分割网络,在 3 个 OCTA 图像数据集上均取得了最佳的分割性能,优于对比方法。;Objective Optical coherence tomography angiography(OCTA)is a noninvasive, emerging technique that has been increasingly used for images of the retinal vasculature at the capillary-level resolution.OCTA technology can demonstrate the microvascular information around the macula and has significant remarkable advantages in retinal vascular imaging.Fundus fluorescence angiography can visualize the retinal vascular system, including capillaries.However, the technique requires intravenous injection of contrast.This process is relatively time-consuming and may have serious side effects.In clinical practice, doctors can look at different layers of vascular structures through OCTA images and analyze changes in vascular structures to determine the presence of related diseases.In particular, any abnormality in the microvasculature distributed in the macula often indicates the presence of some diseases, such as early-stage glaucomatous optic neuropathy, diabetic retinopathy, and age-related macular degeneration.Therefore, the automatic segmentation and extraction of retinal vascular structure in OCTA are vital for the quantitative analysis and clinical decision-making of many ocular diseases.However, the OCTA imaging process usually produces images with a low signal-to-noise ratio, thereby posing a great challenge for the automatic segmentation of vascular structures.Moreover, variations in vessel appearance, motion, and shadowing artifacts in different depth layers and underlying pathological structures significantly remarkably increase the difficulty in accurately segmenting retinal vessels.Therefore, this study proposes a novel segmentation method of retinal vascular structures by fusing hidden vector alignment and Swin Transformer to achieve the accurate segmentation of vascular structures.Method In this study, the ResU-Net network is used as the base network(the encoder and decoder layers consist of residual blocks and pooling layers), and the Swin Transformer is introduced into ResU-Net to form a new encoder structure.The encoding step of the feature encoder consists of four stages.Each stage comprises two layers:the Transformer layer consisting of several Swin Transformer blocks stacked together and the residual structure.The Swin Transformer encoder can acquire rich feature information, whereas the feature maps output from each Swin Transformer layer is combined with the feature maps sampled on the decoder via a jump connection.A feature alignment loss function based on hidden vectors is also designed in this study.This feature alignment loss function is different from the classical pixel-level loss function.Feature alignment loss can optimize segmentation results in terms of feature dimensions.It can also enhance the encoder's ability to extract the structural features of OCTA image vessels and optimize the network at the hidden space level by constraining the consistency of labels and images in the hidden space to improve the segmentation performance.Result Experimental results on three OCTA datasets(including two public datasets and one private dataset) show that our method is ahead of other comparative methods and has the best overall segmentation performance.In particular, the area under the curves(AUCs)of this method reaches 94.15%, 94.87%, and 97.63%, whereas the accuracy (ACCs)reaches 91.57%, 90.03%, and 91.06%, respectively.Compared with the classical medical image segmentation network U-Net, the proposed method improves the AUC, Kappa, false discovery rate(FDR), and Dice by approximately 4.06%, 10.18%, 23.16%, and 7.87%, respectively, on the OCTA-O dataset.In addition, ablation experiments are conducted for each component in this study to verify the validity of each component of the proposed model.The results show that each component can play a positive role.Conclusion An end-to-end vascular segmentation network is proposed in this study to address the challenges of complex retinal vascular structures and low overall image contrast present in OCTA.In this study, ResU-Net is used as the backbone network to mitigate the interference of scattering noise and artifacts on segmentation through image multifusion input.Moreover, the Swin Transformer module is used as the coding structure to obtain rich features.A novel hidden vector alignment loss function that can optimize the network at the hidden space level is also designed in this study.Thus, the gap between segmentation results and labels is reduced, and the segmentation performance is improved.The experimental results demonstrate that the method in this study achieves the best segmentation performance on all three OCTA datasets, and it outperforms other comparative methods.","PeriodicalId":36336,"journal":{"name":"中国图象图形学报","volume":"32 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2023-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Vessel segmentation of OCTA images based on latent vector alignment and swin Transformer\",\"authors\":\"Xu Cong, Hao Huaying, Wang Yang, Ma Yuhui, Yan Qifeng, Chen Bang, Ma Shaodong, Wang Xiaogui, Zhao Yitian\",\"doi\":\"10.11834/jig.220482\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"目的 光学相干断层扫描血管造影(optical coherence tomography angiography,OCTA)是一种非侵入式的新兴技术,越来越多地应用于视网膜血管成像。与传统眼底彩照相比,OCTA 技术能够显示黄斑周围的微血管信息,在视网膜血管成像邻域具有显著优势。临床实践中,医生可以通过 OCTA 图像观察不同层的血管结构,并通过分析血管结构的变化来判断是否存在相关疾病。大量研究表明,血管结构的任何异常变化通常都意味着存在某种眼科疾病。因此,对 OCTA 图像中的视网膜血管结构进行自动分割提取,对众多眼部相关疾病量化分析和临床决策具有重大意义。然而,OCTA 图像存在视网膜血管结构复杂、图像整体对比度低等问题,给自动分割带来极大挑战。为此,提出了一种新颖的融合隐向量对齐和 Swin Transformer 的视网膜血管结构的分割方法,能够实现血管结构的精准分割。方法 以 ResU-Net 为主干网络,通过 Swin Transformer 编码器获取丰富的血管特征信息。此外,设计了一种基于隐向量的特征对齐损失函数,能够在隐空间层次对网络进行优化,提升分割性能。结果 在 3 个 OCTA 图像数据集上的实验结果表明,本文方法的 AUC(area under curce)分别为 94.15%,94.87% 和 97.63%,ACC(accuracy)分别为 91.57%,90.03% 和 91.06%,领先其他对比方法,并且整体分割性能达到最佳。结论 本文提出的视网膜血管分割网络,在 3 个 OCTA 图像数据集上均取得了最佳的分割性能,优于对比方法。;Objective Optical coherence tomography angiography(OCTA)is a noninvasive, emerging technique that has been increasingly used for images of the retinal vasculature at the capillary-level resolution.OCTA technology can demonstrate the microvascular information around the macula and has significant remarkable advantages in retinal vascular imaging.Fundus fluorescence angiography can visualize the retinal vascular system, including capillaries.However, the technique requires intravenous injection of contrast.This process is relatively time-consuming and may have serious side effects.In clinical practice, doctors can look at different layers of vascular structures through OCTA images and analyze changes in vascular structures to determine the presence of related diseases.In particular, any abnormality in the microvasculature distributed in the macula often indicates the presence of some diseases, such as early-stage glaucomatous optic neuropathy, diabetic retinopathy, and age-related macular degeneration.Therefore, the automatic segmentation and extraction of retinal vascular structure in OCTA are vital for the quantitative analysis and clinical decision-making of many ocular diseases.However, the OCTA imaging process usually produces images with a low signal-to-noise ratio, thereby posing a great challenge for the automatic segmentation of vascular structures.Moreover, variations in vessel appearance, motion, and shadowing artifacts in different depth layers and underlying pathological structures significantly remarkably increase the difficulty in accurately segmenting retinal vessels.Therefore, this study proposes a novel segmentation method of retinal vascular structures by fusing hidden vector alignment and Swin Transformer to achieve the accurate segmentation of vascular structures.Method In this study, the ResU-Net network is used as the base network(the encoder and decoder layers consist of residual blocks and pooling layers), and the Swin Transformer is introduced into ResU-Net to form a new encoder structure.The encoding step of the feature encoder consists of four stages.Each stage comprises two layers:the Transformer layer consisting of several Swin Transformer blocks stacked together and the residual structure.The Swin Transformer encoder can acquire rich feature information, whereas the feature maps output from each Swin Transformer layer is combined with the feature maps sampled on the decoder via a jump connection.A feature alignment loss function based on hidden vectors is also designed in this study.This feature alignment loss function is different from the classical pixel-level loss function.Feature alignment loss can optimize segmentation results in terms of feature dimensions.It can also enhance the encoder's ability to extract the structural features of OCTA image vessels and optimize the network at the hidden space level by constraining the consistency of labels and images in the hidden space to improve the segmentation performance.Result Experimental results on three OCTA datasets(including two public datasets and one private dataset) show that our method is ahead of other comparative methods and has the best overall segmentation performance.In particular, the area under the curves(AUCs)of this method reaches 94.15%, 94.87%, and 97.63%, whereas the accuracy (ACCs)reaches 91.57%, 90.03%, and 91.06%, respectively.Compared with the classical medical image segmentation network U-Net, the proposed method improves the AUC, Kappa, false discovery rate(FDR), and Dice by approximately 4.06%, 10.18%, 23.16%, and 7.87%, respectively, on the OCTA-O dataset.In addition, ablation experiments are conducted for each component in this study to verify the validity of each component of the proposed model.The results show that each component can play a positive role.Conclusion An end-to-end vascular segmentation network is proposed in this study to address the challenges of complex retinal vascular structures and low overall image contrast present in OCTA.In this study, ResU-Net is used as the backbone network to mitigate the interference of scattering noise and artifacts on segmentation through image multifusion input.Moreover, the Swin Transformer module is used as the coding structure to obtain rich features.A novel hidden vector alignment loss function that can optimize the network at the hidden space level is also designed in this study.Thus, the gap between segmentation results and labels is reduced, and the segmentation performance is improved.The experimental results demonstrate that the method in this study achieves the best segmentation performance on all three OCTA datasets, and it outperforms other comparative methods.\",\"PeriodicalId\":36336,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"中国图象图形学报\",\"volume\":\"32 1\",\"pages\":\"0\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2023-01-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"中国图象图形学报\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.11834/jig.220482\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q3\",\"JCRName\":\"Computer Science\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"中国图象图形学报","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.11834/jig.220482","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q3","JCRName":"Computer Science","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
目的 光学相干断层扫描血管造影(optical coherence tomography angiography,OCTA)是一种非侵入式的新兴技术,越来越多地应用于视网膜血管成像。与传统眼底彩照相比,OCTA 技术能够显示黄斑周围的微血管信息,在视网膜血管成像邻域具有显著优势。临床实践中,医生可以通过 OCTA 图像观察不同层的血管结构,并通过分析血管结构的变化来判断是否存在相关疾病。大量研究表明,血管结构的任何异常变化通常都意味着存在某种眼科疾病。因此,对 OCTA 图像中的视网膜血管结构进行自动分割提取,对众多眼部相关疾病量化分析和临床决策具有重大意义。然而,OCTA 图像存在视网膜血管结构复杂、图像整体对比度低等问题,给自动分割带来极大挑战。为此,提出了一种新颖的融合隐向量对齐和 Swin Transformer 的视网膜血管结构的分割方法,能够实现血管结构的精准分割。方法 以 ResU-Net 为主干网络,通过 Swin Transformer 编码器获取丰富的血管特征信息。此外,设计了一种基于隐向量的特征对齐损失函数,能够在隐空间层次对网络进行优化,提升分割性能。结果 在 3 个 OCTA 图像数据集上的实验结果表明,本文方法的 AUC(area under curce)分别为 94.15%,94.87% 和 97.63%,ACC(accuracy)分别为 91.57%,90.03% 和 91.06%,领先其他对比方法,并且整体分割性能达到最佳。结论 本文提出的视网膜血管分割网络,在 3 个 OCTA 图像数据集上均取得了最佳的分割性能,优于对比方法。;Objective Optical coherence tomography angiography(OCTA)is a noninvasive, emerging technique that has been increasingly used for images of the retinal vasculature at the capillary-level resolution.OCTA technology can demonstrate the microvascular information around the macula and has significant remarkable advantages in retinal vascular imaging.Fundus fluorescence angiography can visualize the retinal vascular system, including capillaries.However, the technique requires intravenous injection of contrast.This process is relatively time-consuming and may have serious side effects.In clinical practice, doctors can look at different layers of vascular structures through OCTA images and analyze changes in vascular structures to determine the presence of related diseases.In particular, any abnormality in the microvasculature distributed in the macula often indicates the presence of some diseases, such as early-stage glaucomatous optic neuropathy, diabetic retinopathy, and age-related macular degeneration.Therefore, the automatic segmentation and extraction of retinal vascular structure in OCTA are vital for the quantitative analysis and clinical decision-making of many ocular diseases.However, the OCTA imaging process usually produces images with a low signal-to-noise ratio, thereby posing a great challenge for the automatic segmentation of vascular structures.Moreover, variations in vessel appearance, motion, and shadowing artifacts in different depth layers and underlying pathological structures significantly remarkably increase the difficulty in accurately segmenting retinal vessels.Therefore, this study proposes a novel segmentation method of retinal vascular structures by fusing hidden vector alignment and Swin Transformer to achieve the accurate segmentation of vascular structures.Method In this study, the ResU-Net network is used as the base network(the encoder and decoder layers consist of residual blocks and pooling layers), and the Swin Transformer is introduced into ResU-Net to form a new encoder structure.The encoding step of the feature encoder consists of four stages.Each stage comprises two layers:the Transformer layer consisting of several Swin Transformer blocks stacked together and the residual structure.The Swin Transformer encoder can acquire rich feature information, whereas the feature maps output from each Swin Transformer layer is combined with the feature maps sampled on the decoder via a jump connection.A feature alignment loss function based on hidden vectors is also designed in this study.This feature alignment loss function is different from the classical pixel-level loss function.Feature alignment loss can optimize segmentation results in terms of feature dimensions.It can also enhance the encoder's ability to extract the structural features of OCTA image vessels and optimize the network at the hidden space level by constraining the consistency of labels and images in the hidden space to improve the segmentation performance.Result Experimental results on three OCTA datasets(including two public datasets and one private dataset) show that our method is ahead of other comparative methods and has the best overall segmentation performance.In particular, the area under the curves(AUCs)of this method reaches 94.15%, 94.87%, and 97.63%, whereas the accuracy (ACCs)reaches 91.57%, 90.03%, and 91.06%, respectively.Compared with the classical medical image segmentation network U-Net, the proposed method improves the AUC, Kappa, false discovery rate(FDR), and Dice by approximately 4.06%, 10.18%, 23.16%, and 7.87%, respectively, on the OCTA-O dataset.In addition, ablation experiments are conducted for each component in this study to verify the validity of each component of the proposed model.The results show that each component can play a positive role.Conclusion An end-to-end vascular segmentation network is proposed in this study to address the challenges of complex retinal vascular structures and low overall image contrast present in OCTA.In this study, ResU-Net is used as the backbone network to mitigate the interference of scattering noise and artifacts on segmentation through image multifusion input.Moreover, the Swin Transformer module is used as the coding structure to obtain rich features. 本文还设计了一种新的隐藏向量对齐损失函数,可以在隐藏空间层面对网络进行优化。从而减少了分割结果与标签之间的差距,提高了分割性能。实验结果表明,本方法在三种OCTA数据集上均取得了最佳的分割性能,并且优于其他比较方法。
Vessel segmentation of OCTA images based on latent vector alignment and swin Transformer
目的 光学相干断层扫描血管造影(optical coherence tomography angiography,OCTA)是一种非侵入式的新兴技术,越来越多地应用于视网膜血管成像。与传统眼底彩照相比,OCTA 技术能够显示黄斑周围的微血管信息,在视网膜血管成像邻域具有显著优势。临床实践中,医生可以通过 OCTA 图像观察不同层的血管结构,并通过分析血管结构的变化来判断是否存在相关疾病。大量研究表明,血管结构的任何异常变化通常都意味着存在某种眼科疾病。因此,对 OCTA 图像中的视网膜血管结构进行自动分割提取,对众多眼部相关疾病量化分析和临床决策具有重大意义。然而,OCTA 图像存在视网膜血管结构复杂、图像整体对比度低等问题,给自动分割带来极大挑战。为此,提出了一种新颖的融合隐向量对齐和 Swin Transformer 的视网膜血管结构的分割方法,能够实现血管结构的精准分割。方法 以 ResU-Net 为主干网络,通过 Swin Transformer 编码器获取丰富的血管特征信息。此外,设计了一种基于隐向量的特征对齐损失函数,能够在隐空间层次对网络进行优化,提升分割性能。结果 在 3 个 OCTA 图像数据集上的实验结果表明,本文方法的 AUC(area under curce)分别为 94.15%,94.87% 和 97.63%,ACC(accuracy)分别为 91.57%,90.03% 和 91.06%,领先其他对比方法,并且整体分割性能达到最佳。结论 本文提出的视网膜血管分割网络,在 3 个 OCTA 图像数据集上均取得了最佳的分割性能,优于对比方法。;Objective Optical coherence tomography angiography(OCTA)is a noninvasive, emerging technique that has been increasingly used for images of the retinal vasculature at the capillary-level resolution.OCTA technology can demonstrate the microvascular information around the macula and has significant remarkable advantages in retinal vascular imaging.Fundus fluorescence angiography can visualize the retinal vascular system, including capillaries.However, the technique requires intravenous injection of contrast.This process is relatively time-consuming and may have serious side effects.In clinical practice, doctors can look at different layers of vascular structures through OCTA images and analyze changes in vascular structures to determine the presence of related diseases.In particular, any abnormality in the microvasculature distributed in the macula often indicates the presence of some diseases, such as early-stage glaucomatous optic neuropathy, diabetic retinopathy, and age-related macular degeneration.Therefore, the automatic segmentation and extraction of retinal vascular structure in OCTA are vital for the quantitative analysis and clinical decision-making of many ocular diseases.However, the OCTA imaging process usually produces images with a low signal-to-noise ratio, thereby posing a great challenge for the automatic segmentation of vascular structures.Moreover, variations in vessel appearance, motion, and shadowing artifacts in different depth layers and underlying pathological structures significantly remarkably increase the difficulty in accurately segmenting retinal vessels.Therefore, this study proposes a novel segmentation method of retinal vascular structures by fusing hidden vector alignment and Swin Transformer to achieve the accurate segmentation of vascular structures.Method In this study, the ResU-Net network is used as the base network(the encoder and decoder layers consist of residual blocks and pooling layers), and the Swin Transformer is introduced into ResU-Net to form a new encoder structure.The encoding step of the feature encoder consists of four stages.Each stage comprises two layers:the Transformer layer consisting of several Swin Transformer blocks stacked together and the residual structure.The Swin Transformer encoder can acquire rich feature information, whereas the feature maps output from each Swin Transformer layer is combined with the feature maps sampled on the decoder via a jump connection.A feature alignment loss function based on hidden vectors is also designed in this study.This feature alignment loss function is different from the classical pixel-level loss function.Feature alignment loss can optimize segmentation results in terms of feature dimensions.It can also enhance the encoder's ability to extract the structural features of OCTA image vessels and optimize the network at the hidden space level by constraining the consistency of labels and images in the hidden space to improve the segmentation performance.Result Experimental results on three OCTA datasets(including two public datasets and one private dataset) show that our method is ahead of other comparative methods and has the best overall segmentation performance.In particular, the area under the curves(AUCs)of this method reaches 94.15%, 94.87%, and 97.63%, whereas the accuracy (ACCs)reaches 91.57%, 90.03%, and 91.06%, respectively.Compared with the classical medical image segmentation network U-Net, the proposed method improves the AUC, Kappa, false discovery rate(FDR), and Dice by approximately 4.06%, 10.18%, 23.16%, and 7.87%, respectively, on the OCTA-O dataset.In addition, ablation experiments are conducted for each component in this study to verify the validity of each component of the proposed model.The results show that each component can play a positive role.Conclusion An end-to-end vascular segmentation network is proposed in this study to address the challenges of complex retinal vascular structures and low overall image contrast present in OCTA.In this study, ResU-Net is used as the backbone network to mitigate the interference of scattering noise and artifacts on segmentation through image multifusion input.Moreover, the Swin Transformer module is used as the coding structure to obtain rich features.A novel hidden vector alignment loss function that can optimize the network at the hidden space level is also designed in this study.Thus, the gap between segmentation results and labels is reduced, and the segmentation performance is improved.The experimental results demonstrate that the method in this study achieves the best segmentation performance on all three OCTA datasets, and it outperforms other comparative methods.
中国图象图形学报Computer Science-Computer Graphics and Computer-Aided Design
CiteScore
1.20
自引率
0.00%
发文量
6776
期刊介绍:
Journal of Image and Graphics (ISSN 1006-8961, CN 11-3758/TB, CODEN ZTTXFZ) is an authoritative academic journal supervised by the Chinese Academy of Sciences and co-sponsored by the Institute of Space and Astronautical Information Innovation of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (ISIAS), the Chinese Society of Image and Graphics (CSIG), and the Beijing Institute of Applied Physics and Computational Mathematics (BIAPM). The journal integrates high-tech theories, technical methods and industrialisation of applied research results in computer image graphics, and mainly publishes innovative and high-level scientific research papers on basic and applied research in image graphics science and its closely related fields. The form of papers includes reviews, technical reports, project progress, academic news, new technology reviews, new product introduction and industrialisation research. The content covers a wide range of fields such as image analysis and recognition, image understanding and computer vision, computer graphics, virtual reality and augmented reality, system simulation, animation, etc., and theme columns are opened according to the research hotspots and cutting-edge topics.
Journal of Image and Graphics reaches a wide range of readers, including scientific and technical personnel, enterprise supervisors, and postgraduates and college students of colleges and universities engaged in the fields of national defence, military, aviation, aerospace, communications, electronics, automotive, agriculture, meteorology, environmental protection, remote sensing, mapping, oil field, construction, transportation, finance, telecommunications, education, medical care, film and television, and art.
Journal of Image and Graphics is included in many important domestic and international scientific literature database systems, including EBSCO database in the United States, JST database in Japan, Scopus database in the Netherlands, China Science and Technology Thesis Statistics and Analysis (Annual Research Report), China Science Citation Database (CSCD), China Academic Journal Network Publishing Database (CAJD), and China Academic Journal Network Publishing Database (CAJD). China Science Citation Database (CSCD), China Academic Journals Network Publishing Database (CAJD), China Academic Journal Abstracts, Chinese Science Abstracts (Series A), China Electronic Science Abstracts, Chinese Core Journals Abstracts, Chinese Academic Journals on CD-ROM, and China Academic Journals Comprehensive Evaluation Database.