BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSIS OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN FAMILY OWNERSHIP, FAMILY GOVERNANCE, CLAN GOVERNANCE, AND TRIBAL GOVERNANCE: A FUTURE RESEARCH AGENDA

This article aims to fill the gap in the literature related to clan and tribal governance which has not been studied much, by looking at previous literature studies and linking to literature studies discussing family ownership, family business, and family governance based on searches in Scopus reputable journals assisted with tools Publish or Pearish, VOSviewer, and Blibliomagika software that is linked and developed for future research topics. Using a literature review, assisted by Publish or Pearish (POP) software, VOSviewer To estimate the model and analyze data collected from the Scopus database. The data is then broken down based on the annual document, subject area, search keywords, authors, published journals, affiliations, the country of origin of the publication, and clarifying the future research agenda. The results of the study show that the terms clan, tribal and family governance have not been disclosed much in previous research even though these topics can be studied more broadly than the concepts of family ownership and family business. From this concept, it can be directed and connected to the concept of entrepreneurship, SMEs family, CSR, financial reporting, family shareholders, cash flow, non-family firms, and many more. The practical implications of the results of this research are to fill the gap in the literature on clan/tribal governance, which is still interesting to develop. The originality of the study provides clarity on the relationship between family ownership, family business, and its developments that lead to family governance.