《开放的伤口:大屠杀剧院和乔治·塔波里的遗产》,马丁·卡格尔、大卫·z·萨尔茨主编(书评)

IF 0.2 4区 社会学 Q4 AREA STUDIES German Studies Review Pub Date : 2023-10-01 DOI:10.1353/gsr.2023.a910208
{"title":"《开放的伤口:大屠杀剧院和乔治·塔波里的遗产》,马丁·卡格尔、大卫·z·萨尔茨主编(书评)","authors":"","doi":"10.1353/gsr.2023.a910208","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Reviewed by: Open Wounds: Holocaust Theater and the Legacy of George Tabori ed. by Martin Kagel and David Z. Saltz Michael Bachmann Open Wounds: Holocaust Theater and the Legacy of George Tabori. Edited by Martin Kagel and David Z. Saltz. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2022. Pp. vii + 200. Cloth $85.00. ISBN 9780472132843. Working tirelessly until his death at age 93, George Tabori (1914–2007) once claimed to be \"the longest-serving theater-maker in the world,\" adding that he had no other home than the stage. This not only speaks to an obsession with theater but also reflects the traumatic history of the twentieth century: Tabori's father was murdered in Auschwitz; his mother narrowly escaped deportation. Born in Budapest to a family of Jewish descent, Tabori spent much of his adult life in Britain and the United States before moving to Germany in 1969. It was there that he had his greatest successes as a playwright and director, most notably with productions of his Holocaust plays The Cannibals (1968/69), My Mother's Courage (1979), Jubilee (1983), and Mein Kampf (1987). As Martin Kagel writes in the insightful introduction to Open Wounds: Holocaust Theater and the Legacy of George Tabori, a collection co-edited with David Z. Saltz, these plays and productions introduced a new model of Holocaust theater. It was distinct from \"sentimental humanism,\" psychological realism, and documentary approaches. Instead, Tabori invested in transgressive humor, metatheatrical reflection, an unusual focus on the victim-perpetrator relationship, and \"the authenticity of the theatrical performance\" (14). This does not refer to a realistic mode of representing history but means an emphasis on the experiential dimension of performance, a disruption of representation through visceral moments of ritual, laughter, embarrassment, and shock. \"Memory? No! Experience\" is the apt title of Alice Le [End Page 505] Trionnaire-Bolterauer's chapter in the collection (50–64). For Tabori, \"true memory\" was only possible through reliving the past \"with skin, nose, tongue, buttocks, feet, and belly,\" as he wrote in his Shylock Improvisations (1978). In the eighties and nineties, Tabori was a towering figure in German theater. Academic studies of his work, such as Anat Feinberg's seminal Embodied Memory: The Theatre of George Tabori (1999), brought his unique memory theater to the attention of an international audience. In her opening chapter for Open Wounds, Feinberg revisits some of the material from the earlier book. Like Kagel's introduction, her contribution serves an important function for the collection. Tabori's work is less well known today than it was twenty years ago: many readers will need the overview given by Feinberg and Kagel, especially since the book's primary focus, as per its subtitle, is on \"the legacy of George Tabori.\" While it is easy to identify his influences—including Brecht, Beckett, Kafka, Open Theater, and Gestalt therapy—the question of Tabori's legacy is extremely complex. It would be difficult to list artists who have followed directly in his footsteps, and Open Wounds wisely makes no attempt to do so. It often seeks legacy, as Jack Davis writes in a chapter on post-dramatic theater, \"not through a direct line of influence but through a set of transposed and transformed concerns,\" in his case about \"animals, animality, and the victims and perpetrators of the Holocaust\" (127). Others focus on the \"legacy of the performative body\" (Johanna Öttl), \"pained laughter\" in Holocaust musicals (Barbara Wallace Grossman), and the question of \"ethical witnessing\" (Rebecca Rovit). This approach to legacy via thematic and conceptual concerns can lead to excellent insights. Peter Höyng's chapter, for instance, argues convincingly why Urs Odermatt's 2009 film adaptation of Mein Kampf fails Tabori's legacy. It \"voids\" the theater-maker's dramaturgical principles by attempting to reconcile the play's provocative and farcical plot—which imagines a friendship between the young Hitler and his Jewish roommate Shlomo Herzl—with a \"historically accurate narrative\" (162), thereby losing the transgressive potential of Tabori's taboo-breaking humor. Other chapters move further away from Tabori. Freddie Rokem provides an original and thought-provoking analysis of theater that self-reflexively recycles its own history, including—but by no means focused on...","PeriodicalId":43954,"journal":{"name":"German Studies Review","volume":"67 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.2000,"publicationDate":"2023-10-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Open Wounds: Holocaust Theater and the Legacy of George Tabori ed. by Martin Kagel and David Z. Saltz (review)\",\"authors\":\"\",\"doi\":\"10.1353/gsr.2023.a910208\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Reviewed by: Open Wounds: Holocaust Theater and the Legacy of George Tabori ed. by Martin Kagel and David Z. Saltz Michael Bachmann Open Wounds: Holocaust Theater and the Legacy of George Tabori. Edited by Martin Kagel and David Z. Saltz. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2022. Pp. vii + 200. Cloth $85.00. ISBN 9780472132843. Working tirelessly until his death at age 93, George Tabori (1914–2007) once claimed to be \\\"the longest-serving theater-maker in the world,\\\" adding that he had no other home than the stage. This not only speaks to an obsession with theater but also reflects the traumatic history of the twentieth century: Tabori's father was murdered in Auschwitz; his mother narrowly escaped deportation. Born in Budapest to a family of Jewish descent, Tabori spent much of his adult life in Britain and the United States before moving to Germany in 1969. It was there that he had his greatest successes as a playwright and director, most notably with productions of his Holocaust plays The Cannibals (1968/69), My Mother's Courage (1979), Jubilee (1983), and Mein Kampf (1987). As Martin Kagel writes in the insightful introduction to Open Wounds: Holocaust Theater and the Legacy of George Tabori, a collection co-edited with David Z. Saltz, these plays and productions introduced a new model of Holocaust theater. It was distinct from \\\"sentimental humanism,\\\" psychological realism, and documentary approaches. Instead, Tabori invested in transgressive humor, metatheatrical reflection, an unusual focus on the victim-perpetrator relationship, and \\\"the authenticity of the theatrical performance\\\" (14). This does not refer to a realistic mode of representing history but means an emphasis on the experiential dimension of performance, a disruption of representation through visceral moments of ritual, laughter, embarrassment, and shock. \\\"Memory? No! Experience\\\" is the apt title of Alice Le [End Page 505] Trionnaire-Bolterauer's chapter in the collection (50–64). For Tabori, \\\"true memory\\\" was only possible through reliving the past \\\"with skin, nose, tongue, buttocks, feet, and belly,\\\" as he wrote in his Shylock Improvisations (1978). In the eighties and nineties, Tabori was a towering figure in German theater. Academic studies of his work, such as Anat Feinberg's seminal Embodied Memory: The Theatre of George Tabori (1999), brought his unique memory theater to the attention of an international audience. In her opening chapter for Open Wounds, Feinberg revisits some of the material from the earlier book. Like Kagel's introduction, her contribution serves an important function for the collection. Tabori's work is less well known today than it was twenty years ago: many readers will need the overview given by Feinberg and Kagel, especially since the book's primary focus, as per its subtitle, is on \\\"the legacy of George Tabori.\\\" While it is easy to identify his influences—including Brecht, Beckett, Kafka, Open Theater, and Gestalt therapy—the question of Tabori's legacy is extremely complex. It would be difficult to list artists who have followed directly in his footsteps, and Open Wounds wisely makes no attempt to do so. It often seeks legacy, as Jack Davis writes in a chapter on post-dramatic theater, \\\"not through a direct line of influence but through a set of transposed and transformed concerns,\\\" in his case about \\\"animals, animality, and the victims and perpetrators of the Holocaust\\\" (127). Others focus on the \\\"legacy of the performative body\\\" (Johanna Öttl), \\\"pained laughter\\\" in Holocaust musicals (Barbara Wallace Grossman), and the question of \\\"ethical witnessing\\\" (Rebecca Rovit). This approach to legacy via thematic and conceptual concerns can lead to excellent insights. Peter Höyng's chapter, for instance, argues convincingly why Urs Odermatt's 2009 film adaptation of Mein Kampf fails Tabori's legacy. It \\\"voids\\\" the theater-maker's dramaturgical principles by attempting to reconcile the play's provocative and farcical plot—which imagines a friendship between the young Hitler and his Jewish roommate Shlomo Herzl—with a \\\"historically accurate narrative\\\" (162), thereby losing the transgressive potential of Tabori's taboo-breaking humor. Other chapters move further away from Tabori. Freddie Rokem provides an original and thought-provoking analysis of theater that self-reflexively recycles its own history, including—but by no means focused on...\",\"PeriodicalId\":43954,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"German Studies Review\",\"volume\":\"67 1\",\"pages\":\"0\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.2000,\"publicationDate\":\"2023-10-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"German Studies Review\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.1353/gsr.2023.a910208\",\"RegionNum\":4,\"RegionCategory\":\"社会学\",\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q4\",\"JCRName\":\"AREA STUDIES\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"German Studies Review","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1353/gsr.2023.a910208","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"社会学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q4","JCRName":"AREA STUDIES","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

书评:《开放的伤口:大屠杀剧院和乔治·塔波里的遗产》,作者:马丁·卡格尔和大卫·z·萨尔茨迈克尔·巴赫曼《开放的伤口:大屠杀剧院和乔治·塔波里的遗产》。马丁·卡格尔和大卫·z·萨尔茨编辑。安娜堡:密歇根大学出版社,2022。Pp. vii + 200。布85.00美元。ISBN 9780472132843。乔治·塔博里(1914-2007)在93岁去世之前,一直孜孜不倦地工作,他曾声称自己是“世界上工作时间最长的戏剧制作人”,并补充说,除了舞台,他没有其他的家。这不仅说明了他对戏剧的痴迷,也反映了20世纪的创伤历史:塔波里的父亲在奥斯维辛集中营被谋杀;他的母亲险些被驱逐出境。塔里出生于布达佩斯的一个犹太血统家庭,成年后的大部分时间在英国和美国度过,1969年移居德国。正是在那里,他作为剧作家和导演取得了最大的成功,最著名的作品是他的大屠杀戏剧《食人族》(1968/69)、《我母亲的勇气》(1979)、《禧年》(1983)和《我的奋斗》(1987)。正如马丁·卡格尔在与大卫·z·萨尔茨合编的《开放的伤口:大屠杀戏剧和乔治·塔博里的遗产》一书中所写的那样,这些戏剧和作品引入了一种新的大屠杀戏剧模式。它与“感伤的人文主义”、心理现实主义和纪实方法截然不同。相反,塔里投入了越界的幽默、超戏剧的反思、对受害者-加害者关系的不同寻常的关注,以及“戏剧表演的真实性”(14)。这并不是指一种表现历史的现实主义模式,而是指强调表演的经验维度,通过仪式、笑声、尴尬和震惊等发自内心的时刻来破坏表现。“记忆吗?不!“体验”是Alice Le Trionnaire-Bolterauer文集(50-64)中章节的恰当标题。对塔波里来说,“真正的记忆”只有通过“用皮肤、鼻子、舌头、臀部、脚和肚子”重温过去才有可能,正如他在《夏洛克即兴创作》(1978)中所写的那样。在八九十年代,塔波里是德国戏剧界的杰出人物。对他作品的学术研究,如阿纳特·范伯格开创性的《具身记忆:乔治·塔波里的戏剧》(1999),使他独特的记忆戏剧引起了国际观众的注意。在《敞开的伤口》的第一章中,范伯格回顾了早期书中的一些材料。就像凯格尔的介绍一样,她的贡献对这个系列起着重要的作用。塔波里的作品在今天不像20年前那么出名:许多读者需要Feinberg和Kagel给出的概述,特别是因为这本书的主要焦点,正如其副标题所示,是“乔治·塔波里的遗产”。虽然很容易确定他的影响——包括布莱希特、贝克特、卡夫卡、开放剧场和格式塔疗法——但塔波里的遗产问题却极其复杂。很难列出直接追随他脚步的艺术家,《开放的伤口》明智地没有尝试这样做。它经常寻求遗产,正如杰克·戴维斯(Jack Davis)在一个关于后戏剧戏剧的章节中所写的那样,“不是通过直接的影响,而是通过一系列调换和转化的关注”,在他的案例中,关于“动物、动物性、大屠杀的受害者和肇事者”(127)。其他人关注的是“表演身体的遗产”(约翰娜Öttl),大屠杀音乐剧中的“痛苦的笑声”(芭芭拉华莱士格罗斯曼),以及“道德见证”的问题(丽贝卡罗维特)。这种通过主题和概念关注来处理遗产的方法可以产生出色的见解。例如,彼得Höyng的章节令人信服地论证了为什么乌尔斯·奥德马特2009年改编自《我的奋斗》的电影没有继承塔博里的遗产。它试图调和戏剧的挑衅和滑稽的情节——想象年轻的希特勒和他的犹太室友什洛莫·赫茨之间的友谊——与“历史准确的叙述”(162),从而“无效”了戏剧制作人的戏剧原则,从而失去了塔波里打破禁忌的幽默的越界潜力。其他章节则远离大堀。弗雷迪·罗克姆对戏剧进行了原创性的、发人深省的分析,并自我反思地回顾了自己的历史,包括——但绝不是专注于……
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
查看原文
分享 分享
微信好友 朋友圈 QQ好友 复制链接
本刊更多论文
Open Wounds: Holocaust Theater and the Legacy of George Tabori ed. by Martin Kagel and David Z. Saltz (review)
Reviewed by: Open Wounds: Holocaust Theater and the Legacy of George Tabori ed. by Martin Kagel and David Z. Saltz Michael Bachmann Open Wounds: Holocaust Theater and the Legacy of George Tabori. Edited by Martin Kagel and David Z. Saltz. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2022. Pp. vii + 200. Cloth $85.00. ISBN 9780472132843. Working tirelessly until his death at age 93, George Tabori (1914–2007) once claimed to be "the longest-serving theater-maker in the world," adding that he had no other home than the stage. This not only speaks to an obsession with theater but also reflects the traumatic history of the twentieth century: Tabori's father was murdered in Auschwitz; his mother narrowly escaped deportation. Born in Budapest to a family of Jewish descent, Tabori spent much of his adult life in Britain and the United States before moving to Germany in 1969. It was there that he had his greatest successes as a playwright and director, most notably with productions of his Holocaust plays The Cannibals (1968/69), My Mother's Courage (1979), Jubilee (1983), and Mein Kampf (1987). As Martin Kagel writes in the insightful introduction to Open Wounds: Holocaust Theater and the Legacy of George Tabori, a collection co-edited with David Z. Saltz, these plays and productions introduced a new model of Holocaust theater. It was distinct from "sentimental humanism," psychological realism, and documentary approaches. Instead, Tabori invested in transgressive humor, metatheatrical reflection, an unusual focus on the victim-perpetrator relationship, and "the authenticity of the theatrical performance" (14). This does not refer to a realistic mode of representing history but means an emphasis on the experiential dimension of performance, a disruption of representation through visceral moments of ritual, laughter, embarrassment, and shock. "Memory? No! Experience" is the apt title of Alice Le [End Page 505] Trionnaire-Bolterauer's chapter in the collection (50–64). For Tabori, "true memory" was only possible through reliving the past "with skin, nose, tongue, buttocks, feet, and belly," as he wrote in his Shylock Improvisations (1978). In the eighties and nineties, Tabori was a towering figure in German theater. Academic studies of his work, such as Anat Feinberg's seminal Embodied Memory: The Theatre of George Tabori (1999), brought his unique memory theater to the attention of an international audience. In her opening chapter for Open Wounds, Feinberg revisits some of the material from the earlier book. Like Kagel's introduction, her contribution serves an important function for the collection. Tabori's work is less well known today than it was twenty years ago: many readers will need the overview given by Feinberg and Kagel, especially since the book's primary focus, as per its subtitle, is on "the legacy of George Tabori." While it is easy to identify his influences—including Brecht, Beckett, Kafka, Open Theater, and Gestalt therapy—the question of Tabori's legacy is extremely complex. It would be difficult to list artists who have followed directly in his footsteps, and Open Wounds wisely makes no attempt to do so. It often seeks legacy, as Jack Davis writes in a chapter on post-dramatic theater, "not through a direct line of influence but through a set of transposed and transformed concerns," in his case about "animals, animality, and the victims and perpetrators of the Holocaust" (127). Others focus on the "legacy of the performative body" (Johanna Öttl), "pained laughter" in Holocaust musicals (Barbara Wallace Grossman), and the question of "ethical witnessing" (Rebecca Rovit). This approach to legacy via thematic and conceptual concerns can lead to excellent insights. Peter Höyng's chapter, for instance, argues convincingly why Urs Odermatt's 2009 film adaptation of Mein Kampf fails Tabori's legacy. It "voids" the theater-maker's dramaturgical principles by attempting to reconcile the play's provocative and farcical plot—which imagines a friendship between the young Hitler and his Jewish roommate Shlomo Herzl—with a "historically accurate narrative" (162), thereby losing the transgressive potential of Tabori's taboo-breaking humor. Other chapters move further away from Tabori. Freddie Rokem provides an original and thought-provoking analysis of theater that self-reflexively recycles its own history, including—but by no means focused on...
求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
CiteScore
0.20
自引率
0.00%
发文量
71
期刊最新文献
Demokratisierung nach Auschwitz: Eine Geschichte der westdeutschen Sozialwissenschaften in der Nachkriegszeit by Fabian Link (review) Plants, Places, and Power: Toward Social and Ecological Justice in German Literature and Film by Maria Stehle (review) The Philology of Life: Walter Benjamin's Critical Program by Kevin McLaughlin (review) Vor hundert Jahren: Coudenhove-Kalergis Pan-Europa —der Traum von einer demokratischen Weltmacht als Friedensstifter Erasures and Eradications in Modern Viennese Art, Architecture and Design ed. by Megan Brandow-Faller and Laura Morowitz (review)
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
现在去查看 取消
×
提示
确定
0
微信
客服QQ
Book学术公众号 扫码关注我们
反馈
×
意见反馈
请填写您的意见或建议
请填写您的手机或邮箱
已复制链接
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
×
扫码分享
扫码分享
Book学术官方微信
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术
文献互助 智能选刊 最新文献 互助须知 联系我们:info@booksci.cn
Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。
Copyright © 2023 Book学术 All rights reserved.
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号 京ICP备2023020795号-1