Barefoot walking is beneficial for individuals with persistent plantar heel pain: A single-blind randomized controlled trial

Background

A lack of data exist about the effectiveness of active treatments for persistent plantar heel pain (PPHP).

Objectives

To compare short-term functional and clinical effects of a 4-week barefoot or shod treadmill walking program for people with PPHP.

Methods

A single-blinded clinical trial randomized 52 participants with PPHP into either a barefoot walking group (BWG), or a shod walking group (SWG). All participants received therapeutic ultrasound. Outcomes were measured at baseline (t₀), following 4 weeks of treatment (t₁), and at 1-month follow-up (t₂). The SF-36 functional questionnaire score was the main outcome. Secondary outcomes were self-reported and clinically-assessed pain provocation levels, pressure pain thresholds and pain tolerance. Treadmill walking time and speed were measured at t₀ and t₁; people also recorded the time spent walking each day in a diary.

Results

The BWG exhibited significant improvements in all SF-36 items (except “emotional well-being”) (P < 0.05), whereas the SWG exhibited improvements only in “pain” and “health change” items (P = 0.0001; effect size 0.13–0.94). Greater improvements were observed in the BWG than the SWG for “physical function” (P = 0.019) and “role limitations due to physical health” items (P = 0.035). Both groups demonstrated significant improvements in pain, with greater improvements in the BWG (P = 0.0001; effect size 0.89). Only the BWG showed significant improvements in pain pressure thresholds (P < 0.05; effect size 0.70) and pain tolerance (P < 0.001; effect size 0.67). Both groups significantly increased their speed and time spent walking on the treadmill (BWG Δ=19.7 min and Δ=1.7 km/h; SWG Δ=16.7 min and Δ=1.1 km/h) and time outdoors (SWG ∆=38.2 min/week; BWG mean ∆=48.5 min/week) (P < 0.001). All clinical tests of pain were significantly less positive in the BWG at all time points (P < 0.05).

Conclusions

Both walking programs benefited people with PPHP by alleviating pain and improving function and quality of life. Greater improvements were observed in the BWG than the SWG overall.