Gone with the tides? Reassessing possible eolian strata in the Paleoarchean Moodies Group in the context of the Archean eolian record

It is unresolved when eolian processes began to significantly affect global mean sand composition and texture through abrasion and enhanced sorting. Reports of Proterozoic eolian textures and sedimentary structures are common, in particular from 1.8 Ga on, but the Archean (4.0–2.5 Ga) geologic record possesses only seven reported eolian occurrences which generally do not manifest more than a few diagnostic features of eolian transport. We investigate in detail sandstone units within the Moodies Group (ca. 3.22 Ga) of the Barberton Greenstone Belt, South Africa, one of the oldest well-preserved terrestrial–marine sandy successions. Eight examined locations show terrestrial facies associations, high degrees of compositional and textural maturity, and large-scale foresets; however, none show convincing evidence of eolian transport but several can be excluded with confidence. In comparison to recent eolian strata, grains are generally slightly too coarse-grained, too angular, and mostly too poorly sorted. The common presence of shale laminations, granules, rare pebbles, and shale rip-up clasts demonstrates that the investigated strata were either of aqueous origin or had been formed by eolian processes but were subsequently aqueously reworked. This is vexing because the sandy-gravelly fluvial, coastal floodplain, and estuarine depositional environments of Moodies Group strata may have been hospitable to potentially powerful and long-lasting Archean eolian processes. Early Archean eolian strata may have had a limited depositional area, may have been extensively reworked, or formed under non-actualistic conditions. Thus, the significance of eolian processes on early Earth and their potential contribution to the high degree of textural and compositional maturity of Archean quartzarenites remains poorly constrained.