Improving material properties of a poloxamer P407 hydrogel-based hydroxyapatite bone substitute material by adding silica—A comparative in vivo study

The structure and handling properties of a P407 hydrogel-based bone substitute material (BSM) might be affected by different poloxamer P407 and silicon dioxide (SiO₂) concentrations. The study aimed to compare the mechanical properties and biological parameters (bone remodeling, BSM degradation) of a hydroxyapatite: silica (HA)-based BSM with various P407 hydrogels in vitro and in an in vivo rat model. Rheological analyses for mechanical properties were performed on one BSM with an SiO₂-enriched hydrogel (SPH25) as well on two BSMs with unaltered hydrogels in different gel concentrations (PH25 and PH30). Furthermore, the solubility of all BSMs were tested. In addition, 30 male Wistar rats underwent surgical creation of a well-defined bone defect in the tibia. Defects were filled randomly with PH30 (n = 15) or SPH25 (n = 15). Animals were sacrificed after 12 (n = 5 each), 21 (n = 5 each), and 63 days (n = 5 each). Histological evaluation and histomorphometrical quantification of new bone formation (NB;%), residual BSM (rBSM;%), and soft tissue (ST;%) was conducted. Rheological tests showed an increased viscosity and lower solubility of SPH when compared with the other hydrogels. Histomorphometric analyses in cancellous bone showed a decrease of ST in PH30 (p = .003) and an increase of NB (PH30: p = .001; SPH: p = .014) over time. A comparison of both BSMs revealed no significant differences. The addition of SiO₂ to a P407 hydrogel-based hydroxyapatite BSM improves its mechanical stability (viscosity, solubility) while showing similar in vivo healing properties compared to PH30. Additionally, the SiO₂-enrichment allows a reduction of poloxamer ratio in the hydrogel without impairing the material properties.