An exploration of potentially reversible controls on millennial-scale variations in the slip rate of seismogenic faults: Linking structural observations with variable earthquake recurrence patterns

Paleoseismic studies show that faults within a fault system may trade off slip over time, with mechanically complementary faults displaying alternating fast- and slow periods. Each of these periods spans multiple seismic cycles, and typically involves ~20-25m of slip. This suggests that the relative strength (or tendency to slip) of individual faults varies, over time and displacement scales larger than those of individual seismic cycles. The mechanisms responsible for these strength variations must: affect rocks in the strongest portion of the fault (the brittle-ductile transition) as this likely controls the overall slip rate of the fault; be reversible (or able to be counteracted) on a cyclical basis; provide a negative feedback that operates to change the fault from its current state; and have a measurable effect on fault strength over a time or length scale that corresponds to the observed fast and slow periods of fault slip. In this paper, we systematically explore 19 potentially weakening and 11 potential strengthening mechanisms and evaluate them in light of these criteria. This analysis reveals a relatively small subset of mechanisms that could account for the observed behavior, leading us to suggest a possible model for fault strength evolution.