The level of expression of HPV16 early transcripts is not associated with the natural history of cervical lesions

The natural history of cervical cancer is closely linked to that of high-risk human papillomaviruses (HPV) infection. It is recognized that upon HPV DNA integration, partial or complete loss of the E2 open reading frame precludes expression of the corresponding protein, resulting in upregulation of the E6 and E7 viral oncoproteins. To better characterize HPV16 infection at the cervical level, viral load, viral DNA integration, and viral early transcript expression (E2, E5, and E6) were analyzed in a series of 158 cervical specimens representative of the full spectrum of cervical disease. Overall, the frequency of early transcript detection varied from 45% to 90% and tended to increase with lesion severity. In addition, the levels of E2, E5, and E6 transcript expression were slightly higher in high-grade lesions than in cervical specimens without abnormalities. Notably, early transcript expression was clearly associated with viral load, and no inverse correlation was found between the expression of E2 and E6 transcripts. No clear association was found between early transcript expression and HPV16 DNA integration, with the exception that samples with a fully integrated HPV16 genome did not harbor E2 or E5 transcripts. In conclusion, early HPV16 transcript expression appears to be associated with viral load rather than lesion grade. From a practical point of view, quantification of HPV16 early transcripts is difficult to translate into a relevant biomarker for cervical cancer screening.