Toxicity and efficacy of azadirachtin, and oxymatrine-based biopesticides against cabbage aphid and their impacts on predator insects

The aphidicidal activity and efficacy of azadirachtin- and oxymatrine-based biopesticides on the cabbage aphid Brevicoryne brassicae (Linnaeus, 1758) (Hemiptera: Aphididae), and their impacts on the main insect predators of this aphid were assessed under laboratory, semi-field, or field conditions. Laboratory results showed that azadirachtin- and oxymatrine-based biopesticides provided high acute toxicity against B. brassicae nymphs and adult females, in a manner dependent on the concentration, developmental stage, and exposure time of insects to residues. Among the insect's developmental stages, B. brassicae nymphs were more susceptible to biopesticides than adult females. In addition to acute toxicity, the biopesticides reduced the number of offspring and the amount of honeydew excreted by B. brassicae adult females. Furthermore, the biopesticides induced a repellent effect on B. brassicae adult females. Despite their high toxicity, in semi-field conditions, the azadirachtin- and oxymatrine-based biopesticides showed low biological persistence [mortality >80% up to 3 and 1 day after spraying (DAS), respectively] in comparison to the synthetic insecticide flupyradifurone (mortality >80% up to 7 DAS), which was used as a positive control. However, in the field, the biopesticides demonstrated high efficacy in controlling the B. brassicae population, with no significant impact on the population levels of different species of lacewings, ladybugs, and syrphids, which are considered the main insect predators of the cabbage aphid in agroecosystems. Therefore, azadirachtin- and oxymatrine-based biopesticides constitute an important management measure for B. brassicae in agroecosystems, including those with an ecological basis where management tools are limited, and effective control tactics must be incorporated.