A treatment of the all-clear problem for solar energetic particle events and subsequent decision making

We discuss the relatively overlooked problem of All Clear in Solar Energetic Particle (SEP) event prediction. These proton and heavier ion events are injected in major solar eruptions, propagate directionally into the heliosphere at relativistic speeds and threaten equipment and personnel at low-Earth orbit and beyond. SEPs are rare to extreme events associated with solar flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs), with one SEP event detected in-situ every several hundreds of flares and CMEs observed remotely. This abysmal overall association improves drastically to below 1:2 for fast (i.e., shock-fronted) and halo (i.e., propagating mainly along the Sun–Earth line) CMEs. All Clear implies an assessment of tolerable conditions within a preset prediction window. Relying on one of the most comprehensive data sets for SEP events, we implement a methodology that provides an All Clear for events of NOAA severity S1 and above (S1+) and identify the minimal eruption attributes (flare size and CME speed) that could give rise to such SEP events from source locations in the Sun. The results correspond to and reflect settings of minimum complexity, giving rise to different attributes for different longitudinal zones in the earthward solar hemisphere. This work presents proof of concept; complexity can be increased at will for more demanding All Clear definitions, subject only to sufficient statistics due to the scarcity of the phenomenon. At this point, feedback is desired from stakeholders on what fits their definition of All Clear (we expect different definitions from different operators), so that to define the precise settings on which to run this and similar exercises.