{"title":"书评:《牛津启示录手册》,克雷格·r·科斯特著","authors":"Alexander E. Stewart","doi":"10.1177/01461079211016745","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"124 eight sections: Prologue: The Call of Jeremiah (1:1-19), The Personal Struggles of the Prophet (2:1-25:38), Increasing Unbelief and Opposition (26:1-29:32), The Restoration of Israel and Judah to the Land (30:1-33:26), The Call for Faithfulness (34:1-36:32), The Siege, Fall, and Aftermath in Jerusalem (37:1-45:5), Prophecies Against Nine Nations (46:1–51:64), and The Fall of Jerusalem (52:1-34). Each section has several subunits in which Kaiser translates the Masoretic Text, notes variants in the Septuagint, and provides verse-by-verse commentary on the passages. The commentary brings in a variety of Old and New Testament texts to elucidate aspects of Jeremiah and to show the book’s presence and influence within the Christian biblical canon. Four excurses appear at the end of the book: The Ark of the Covenant, The Queen of Heaven, Shub Shebut, and Topheth. Given their brevity, it might have been more helpful to include this content within the main text of the book. Moreover, the rationale for why each topic is given an excursus is unclear. The volume includes many assumptions and inferences on dating and interpreting Jeremiah’s prophecies without offering compelling evidence. Several sections contain snarky and judgmental remarks about people in antiquity and in the present. Countless exclamations (with ample exclamation points!), generalizations, and vague rants permeate the book. The synopsis claims: “Each section is followed by devotional and application insights that guide the reader in applying the text to their everyday lives.” It is difficult to determine where, if anywhere, these insights can be found. Interaction with more diverse and more recent scholarship might have enhanced this work. Studies in feminist criticism could have enriched the discussions of the human-divine marriage metaphor, references to daughter of my people and daughter Zion, and the Queen of Heaven excursus. Scholarship in literary criticism could have made the discussions of imagery and the mix of poetry and prose texts more interesting and informative. Studies on Jeremiah’s influence and reception in Jewish and Christian faith communities could have supported the theological aims of the work. Although some readers might appreciate its style and content, Walking the Ancient Paths leaves much to be desired. Jaime L. Waters DePaul University Chicago, IL 60614","PeriodicalId":41921,"journal":{"name":"Biblical Theology Bulletin","volume":"52 1","pages":"124 - 125"},"PeriodicalIF":0.1000,"publicationDate":"2021-07-05","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://sci-hub-pdf.com/10.1177/01461079211016745","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Book Review: The Oxford Handbook of the Book of Revelation, by Craig R. Koester\",\"authors\":\"Alexander E. Stewart\",\"doi\":\"10.1177/01461079211016745\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"124 eight sections: Prologue: The Call of Jeremiah (1:1-19), The Personal Struggles of the Prophet (2:1-25:38), Increasing Unbelief and Opposition (26:1-29:32), The Restoration of Israel and Judah to the Land (30:1-33:26), The Call for Faithfulness (34:1-36:32), The Siege, Fall, and Aftermath in Jerusalem (37:1-45:5), Prophecies Against Nine Nations (46:1–51:64), and The Fall of Jerusalem (52:1-34). Each section has several subunits in which Kaiser translates the Masoretic Text, notes variants in the Septuagint, and provides verse-by-verse commentary on the passages. The commentary brings in a variety of Old and New Testament texts to elucidate aspects of Jeremiah and to show the book’s presence and influence within the Christian biblical canon. Four excurses appear at the end of the book: The Ark of the Covenant, The Queen of Heaven, Shub Shebut, and Topheth. Given their brevity, it might have been more helpful to include this content within the main text of the book. Moreover, the rationale for why each topic is given an excursus is unclear. The volume includes many assumptions and inferences on dating and interpreting Jeremiah’s prophecies without offering compelling evidence. Several sections contain snarky and judgmental remarks about people in antiquity and in the present. Countless exclamations (with ample exclamation points!), generalizations, and vague rants permeate the book. The synopsis claims: “Each section is followed by devotional and application insights that guide the reader in applying the text to their everyday lives.” It is difficult to determine where, if anywhere, these insights can be found. Interaction with more diverse and more recent scholarship might have enhanced this work. Studies in feminist criticism could have enriched the discussions of the human-divine marriage metaphor, references to daughter of my people and daughter Zion, and the Queen of Heaven excursus. Scholarship in literary criticism could have made the discussions of imagery and the mix of poetry and prose texts more interesting and informative. Studies on Jeremiah’s influence and reception in Jewish and Christian faith communities could have supported the theological aims of the work. Although some readers might appreciate its style and content, Walking the Ancient Paths leaves much to be desired. Jaime L. Waters DePaul University Chicago, IL 60614\",\"PeriodicalId\":41921,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Biblical Theology Bulletin\",\"volume\":\"52 1\",\"pages\":\"124 - 125\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.1000,\"publicationDate\":\"2021-07-05\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"https://sci-hub-pdf.com/10.1177/01461079211016745\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Biblical Theology Bulletin\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.1177/01461079211016745\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"0\",\"JCRName\":\"RELIGION\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Biblical Theology Bulletin","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1177/01461079211016745","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"RELIGION","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
124八个部分:序言:耶利米的呼召(1:1-19),先知的个人斗争(2:1-25:38),增加不信和反对(26:1-29:32),以色列和犹大的土地恢复(30:1-33:26),忠诚的呼吁(34:1-36:32),耶路撒冷的围困,沦陷和后果(37:1-45:5),对九个国家的预言(46:1-51:64),和耶路撒冷的沦陷(52:1-34)。每一部分都有几个子单元,其中凯撒翻译马所拉文本,注意七十士译本的变体,并对段落进行逐句注释。评注引入了各种各样的旧约和新约文本,以阐明耶利米书的各个方面,并展示了这本书在基督教圣经正典中的存在和影响。在书的末尾出现了四个短途旅行:约柜,天堂女王,舒布·谢布特和陀斐特。考虑到它们的简短,将这些内容包含在书的正文中可能会更有帮助。此外,为什么每个主题都给出了一个附录的理由是不清楚的。卷包括许多假设和推断的日期和解释耶利米的预言没有提供令人信服的证据。有几个章节包含了对古代和现在的人的尖刻和评判性的评论。无数的感叹号(有很多感叹号!),概括和模糊的咆哮充斥着这本书。简介称:“每个部分之后都是虔诚和应用的见解,指导读者将文本应用到他们的日常生活中。”很难确定在哪里(如果有的话)可以找到这些见解。与更多样化和更近期的学者的互动可能会加强这项工作。对女权主义批评的研究本可以丰富对人神婚姻隐喻的讨论,对我的人民的女儿和女儿锡安的引用,以及天堂女王的短途旅行。文学批评方面的学术研究本可以使对意象的讨论以及诗歌和散文文本的混合更加有趣和有意义。研究耶利米在犹太教和基督教信仰团体中的影响和接受程度,可以支持这本书的神学目的。虽然有些读者可能会欣赏它的风格和内容,但《走古道》仍有很多不足之处。Jaime L. Waters德保罗大学芝加哥分校,伊利诺伊州60614
Book Review: The Oxford Handbook of the Book of Revelation, by Craig R. Koester
124 eight sections: Prologue: The Call of Jeremiah (1:1-19), The Personal Struggles of the Prophet (2:1-25:38), Increasing Unbelief and Opposition (26:1-29:32), The Restoration of Israel and Judah to the Land (30:1-33:26), The Call for Faithfulness (34:1-36:32), The Siege, Fall, and Aftermath in Jerusalem (37:1-45:5), Prophecies Against Nine Nations (46:1–51:64), and The Fall of Jerusalem (52:1-34). Each section has several subunits in which Kaiser translates the Masoretic Text, notes variants in the Septuagint, and provides verse-by-verse commentary on the passages. The commentary brings in a variety of Old and New Testament texts to elucidate aspects of Jeremiah and to show the book’s presence and influence within the Christian biblical canon. Four excurses appear at the end of the book: The Ark of the Covenant, The Queen of Heaven, Shub Shebut, and Topheth. Given their brevity, it might have been more helpful to include this content within the main text of the book. Moreover, the rationale for why each topic is given an excursus is unclear. The volume includes many assumptions and inferences on dating and interpreting Jeremiah’s prophecies without offering compelling evidence. Several sections contain snarky and judgmental remarks about people in antiquity and in the present. Countless exclamations (with ample exclamation points!), generalizations, and vague rants permeate the book. The synopsis claims: “Each section is followed by devotional and application insights that guide the reader in applying the text to their everyday lives.” It is difficult to determine where, if anywhere, these insights can be found. Interaction with more diverse and more recent scholarship might have enhanced this work. Studies in feminist criticism could have enriched the discussions of the human-divine marriage metaphor, references to daughter of my people and daughter Zion, and the Queen of Heaven excursus. Scholarship in literary criticism could have made the discussions of imagery and the mix of poetry and prose texts more interesting and informative. Studies on Jeremiah’s influence and reception in Jewish and Christian faith communities could have supported the theological aims of the work. Although some readers might appreciate its style and content, Walking the Ancient Paths leaves much to be desired. Jaime L. Waters DePaul University Chicago, IL 60614
期刊介绍:
Biblical Theology Bulletin is a distinctive, peer-reviewed, quarterly journal containing articles and reviews written by experts in biblical and theological studies. The editors select articles that provide insights derived from critical biblical scholarship, culture-awareness, and thoughtful reflection on meanings of import for scholars of Bible and religion, religious educators, clergy, and those engaged with social studies in religion, inter-religious studies, and the praxis of biblical religion today. The journal began publication in 1971. It has been distinguished for its early and continuing publication of articles using the social sciences in addition to other critical methods for interpreting the Bible for contemporary readers, teachers, and preachers across cultural and denominational lines.