{"title":"Kállai Ernő, György Majtényi, Zsuzsanna Mikó and Péter Tóth. 2022. The Hungarian Gypsies/ Roma I–II. Budapest: National Archives of Hungary.","authors":"Burak Akın","doi":"10.29098/crs.v6i1.190","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Unlike many other nations, the Roma lacked their own written historical records; thus, our understanding of their history is exclusively derived from the documents of the communities and societal settings they interacted with. This interaction rarely yielded substantial documentary evidence about the Roma. When records did emerge, they were often in the context of criminal activities, employment, and more commonly, due to the policies of sovereigns regulating their settlement and everyday life throughout various historical periods. Consequently, analysing these records on a singular, individual basis can lead to a skewed perception, thereby failing to provide a comprehensive understanding of Roma history. The book under review, “A magyarországi cigányok/romák I-II,” offers an extensive collection of sources, contributing significantly to the understanding of the Roma past within Hungarian historiography. This work is part of the “Minorities in Hungary: National, Ethnic, and Religious Communities” (Magyarországi kisebbségek: nemzeti, nemzetiségi és vallási közösségek) series. The selection of sources, editing, and preparation were undertaken by Ernő Kállai, György Majtényi, Zsuzsanna Mikó, Péter Tóth, and organized by the National Archives of Hungary.","PeriodicalId":32956,"journal":{"name":"Critical Romani Studies","volume":"91 23","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2024-05-24","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Critical Romani Studies","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.29098/crs.v6i1.190","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Unlike many other nations, the Roma lacked their own written historical records; thus, our understanding of their history is exclusively derived from the documents of the communities and societal settings they interacted with. This interaction rarely yielded substantial documentary evidence about the Roma. When records did emerge, they were often in the context of criminal activities, employment, and more commonly, due to the policies of sovereigns regulating their settlement and everyday life throughout various historical periods. Consequently, analysing these records on a singular, individual basis can lead to a skewed perception, thereby failing to provide a comprehensive understanding of Roma history. The book under review, “A magyarországi cigányok/romák I-II,” offers an extensive collection of sources, contributing significantly to the understanding of the Roma past within Hungarian historiography. This work is part of the “Minorities in Hungary: National, Ethnic, and Religious Communities” (Magyarországi kisebbségek: nemzeti, nemzetiségi és vallási közösségek) series. The selection of sources, editing, and preparation were undertaken by Ernő Kállai, György Majtényi, Zsuzsanna Mikó, Péter Tóth, and organized by the National Archives of Hungary.
Kállai Ernő、György Majtényi、Zsuzsanna Mikó 和 Péter Tóth,2022 年。 匈牙利吉普赛人/罗姆人 I-II》,布达佩斯:匈牙利国家档案馆。
与许多其他民族不同,罗姆人没有自己的书面历史记录;因此,我们对其历史的了解完全来自于他们交往的社区和社会环境的文献。这种互动很少产生有关罗姆人的大量文献证据。即使有记录,也往往是在犯罪活动、就业的背景下出现的,更常见的是在各个历史时期,由于君主的政策对罗姆人的定居和日常生活进行管理而出现的。因此,对这些记录进行单一、个别的分析可能会导致认识上的偏差,从而无法全面了解罗姆人的历史。本次评述的《A magyarországi cigányok/romák I-II》一书收集了大量资料,为匈牙利历史学界了解罗姆人的过去做出了重要贡献。这部作品是 "匈牙利少数民族 "的一部分:Magyarországi kisebbségek: nemzeti, nemzetiségi és vallási közösségek)丛书的一部分。资料的选择、编辑和准备工作由 Ernő Kállai、György Majtényi、Zsuzsanna Mikó、Péter Tóth 负责,并由匈牙利国家档案馆组织。