Inter-observer variation in gross tumour volume delineation of oesophageal cancer on MR, CT and PET/CT.

Abstract

Background: The aim of our study was to assess the inter-observer variability in delineation of the gross tumour volume (GTV) of oesophageal cancer on magnetic resonance (MR) in comparison to computed tomography (CT) and positron emission tomography and CT (PET/CT).

Patients and methods: Twenty-three consecutive patients with oesophageal cancer treated with chemo-radiotherapy were enrolled. All patients had PET/CT and MR imaging in treatment position. Five observers independently delineated the GTV on CT alone, MR alone, CT with co-registered MR, PET/CT alone and MR with co-registered PET/CT. Volumes of GTV were measured per patient and imaging modality. Inter-observer agreement, expressed in generalized conformity index (CIgen), volumetric conformity index (VCI), planar conformity index (PCI) and inter-delineation distance (IDD) were calculated per patient and imaging modality. Linear mixed models were used for statistical analysis.

Results: GTV volume was significantly lower on MR (33.03 cm³) compared to CT (37.1 cm³; p = 0.002) and on PET/CT MR (35.2 cm³; p = 0.018) compared to PET/CT (39.1 cm³). The CIgen was lowest on CT (0.56) and highest on PET/CT MR (0.67). The difference in CIgen between MR (0.61) and CT was borderline significant (p = 0.048). The VCI was significantly higher on MR (0.71; p = 0.007) and on CT MR (0.71; p = 0.004) compared to CT (0.67). The PCI was significantly higher on CT MR (0.67; p = 0.031) compared to CT (0.64). The largest differences were observed in the cranio-caudal direction.

Conclusions: The highest inter-observer agreement was found for PET/CT MR and the lowest for CT. MR could reduce the difference in delineation between observers and provide additional information about the local extent of the tumour.