Biogeochemistry of carbonates: recorders of past oceans and climate.

Abstract

Trace metal proxies bound within the calcium carbonate tests of oceanic organisms provide a unique insight into how the climate system works on timescales which span eight orders of magnitude, from annual to hundreds of millions of years. Whilst the motivation for developing these proxies was the idea that thermodynamic equilibria control the chemistry during precipitation, in reality the application of trace metal proxies relies upon empirical calibration. Such calibration can be applied to a wide range of environmental reconstructions, but more accurate application of proxies requires a mechanistic understanding of the biomineralization process. The partitioning of trace metals into biogenic carbonates reflects to some extent the same pattern as an inorganic crystal, but there is an additional selectivity and differing environmental sensitivity to, e.g., temperature, which confirms that biochemical processes also play a role in the uptake and assembly of ions into a crystal. Different organisms display differing degrees of biological control on their carbonate chemistry. Aragonitic coral chemistry is most similar to inorganic precipitation from seawater whilst coccolithophores are most different, and these contrasts correlate with the degree of control of the organism over its biomineralization. Selectivity between Ca and trace metals during biomineralization arises during transport by pumps, channels, or nucleation upon an organic matrix. The biological selectivity of the transporters and matrix is strikingly similar in its base chemistry to the selective assembly of ions into a crystal. In each case, the selectivity between Ca2+ and trace metals derives from the balance between the energy required for dehydration of the hexaaqua complex of the cation, and the energy released from the new coordination geometry of binding with either carbonyl oxygen from polysaccharides or amino acids, or carbonate oxygen in the crystal. This is a speculative idea, but with some careful chemical calculations based on the energy of binding of Ca2+ or the trace metal ions to these macromolecular structures, it provides an alternative thermodynamic framework within which to consider the application of trace metal proxies.