Exploring optimal features and image analysis methods for crop type classification from the perspective of crop landscape heterogeneity

Agricultural landscape structure (e.g., the shape of fields, crop diversity, and landscape heterogeneity) greatly influences the selection of methods for large-scale crop mapping using remote sensing data. However, in-depth assessments of its impacts on crop mapping remain infrequent in the existing literature. This study investigated the optimal crop identification features and image analysis methods including pixel- and object-based approaches on crop classification, through the integration of spectral and textural features across various quantitative agricultural landscapes. In the experiments, crop fields were initially delineated into four distinct landscapes using the K-means clustering algorithm based on analyzing 13 selected landscape metrics such as PLAND, LSI and SHDI. Both pixel- and object-based approaches were then employed to conduct crop classification was then conducted using 48 selected features including 9 band reflectance, 23 vegetation indices (VIs), and 16 textures) and two image analysis methods. Specifically, five classification schemes for the different combinations of feature datasets and image analysis methods were explored to assess the impacts of crop heterogeneity on crop classification. Results indicated the five landscape metrics (e.g., SPLIT, SHEI, Average distance, etc.) performed best in assessing crop heterogeneity. In general, spectral bands and VIs had a higher contribution in the compositional heterogeneity, while textural features and VIs played a more important role in the configurational heterogeneity. VIs in the object-based approach and texture features in the pixel-based approach can improved crop classification accuracy in configurational landscapes. The findings provide a theoretical basis on selecting optimal features and image analysis methods for crop classification in complex agricultural landscapes.