{"title":"互视教学:利用电子学习克服学生的抵触情绪。","authors":"Richta C. IJntema, Nicole J. J. M. Mastenbroek","doi":"10.1111/medu.15502","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>Intervision, a peer-led group reflection method, is regarded as an important instrument for continuing professional development.<span><sup>1</sup></span> Therefore, students in all master programmes of the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine (FVM) at Utrecht University (UU) are taught how to conduct intervision in four 2-hour sessions during their outpatient clinic work. In teaching this method to students, we encountered two main problems: (1) students showing resistance to share personal issues with each other, and (2) some veterinary medicine staff being underqualified to teach intervision.</p><p>To address both problems at once, we decided to flip the classroom and develop an e-learning on the ULearning platform, made possible by an UU Education Innovation Grant. This e-learning consists of five modules explaining the why, what and how of intervision, and illustrating how to apply three different intervision models. Powerful learning activities in the e-learning are the many short videos in which veterinary medicine alumni explain why they participate in intervision, what they share and learn, and which pitfalls to avoid. Their testimonials clarify to students that intervision is a relevant and ordinary method for expertise development. Powerful are also the comprehensive examples of how to structure an intervision meeting and the actual practice with a virtual coach (DialogueTrainer tool). Due to this e-learning, students became less dependent of their teacher. They all received the same comprehensive explanation about the intervision method and knew what to do during meetings because they could immediately apply what they had learned online. Student resistance decreased as shown by teacher observations and student evaluations, and teachers felt more equipped for the job. Hence, the e-learning had the intended effect.</p><p>Although the e-learning was successful and can be used for years, even in master programmes outside FVM, it did not happen overnight. We started off enthusiastically, but soon discovered that we had been overly optimistic about the time and effort it would take to build the e-learning and naive about the skills required to successfully complete the project. An e-learning is like an interactive book. It not only requires good writing skills, but also software skills to design interactive content and multimedia skills, such as video production and infographic design. We learned that it is no unnecessary luxury to have such expertise in the design team. Thanks to student feedback, we also learned that less is more. Rather than providing the complete guide to intervision, we limited ourselves to information beginners need to start with intervision and added further reading tips for anyone interested. Although the e-learning turned-out to be concise and appealing, we still needed a student tracking system to motivate students to complete the e-learning in time. Apart from the e-learning, we learned that circumstances matter to reduce student resistance, i.e. to pay attention to group composition and not schedule meetings on Friday afternoons, when students are tired after a week of outpatient clinic work. Lastly, we still would like to employ more qualified teachers to further deepen students' learning.</p><p>Approved by Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Social and Behavioural Sciences of Utrecht University, number 24-0085.</p><p><b>Richta C. IJntema:</b> Writing—original draft; writing—review and editing. <b>Nicole J. J. M. Mastenbroek:</b> Writing—review and editing.</p><p>None.</p>","PeriodicalId":18370,"journal":{"name":"Medical Education","volume":"58 11","pages":"1404-1405"},"PeriodicalIF":4.9000,"publicationDate":"2024-08-30","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/medu.15502","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Teaching intervision: Overcoming student resistance by using e-learning\",\"authors\":\"Richta C. IJntema, Nicole J. J. M. Mastenbroek\",\"doi\":\"10.1111/medu.15502\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"<p>Intervision, a peer-led group reflection method, is regarded as an important instrument for continuing professional development.<span><sup>1</sup></span> Therefore, students in all master programmes of the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine (FVM) at Utrecht University (UU) are taught how to conduct intervision in four 2-hour sessions during their outpatient clinic work. In teaching this method to students, we encountered two main problems: (1) students showing resistance to share personal issues with each other, and (2) some veterinary medicine staff being underqualified to teach intervision.</p><p>To address both problems at once, we decided to flip the classroom and develop an e-learning on the ULearning platform, made possible by an UU Education Innovation Grant. This e-learning consists of five modules explaining the why, what and how of intervision, and illustrating how to apply three different intervision models. Powerful learning activities in the e-learning are the many short videos in which veterinary medicine alumni explain why they participate in intervision, what they share and learn, and which pitfalls to avoid. Their testimonials clarify to students that intervision is a relevant and ordinary method for expertise development. Powerful are also the comprehensive examples of how to structure an intervision meeting and the actual practice with a virtual coach (DialogueTrainer tool). Due to this e-learning, students became less dependent of their teacher. They all received the same comprehensive explanation about the intervision method and knew what to do during meetings because they could immediately apply what they had learned online. Student resistance decreased as shown by teacher observations and student evaluations, and teachers felt more equipped for the job. Hence, the e-learning had the intended effect.</p><p>Although the e-learning was successful and can be used for years, even in master programmes outside FVM, it did not happen overnight. We started off enthusiastically, but soon discovered that we had been overly optimistic about the time and effort it would take to build the e-learning and naive about the skills required to successfully complete the project. An e-learning is like an interactive book. It not only requires good writing skills, but also software skills to design interactive content and multimedia skills, such as video production and infographic design. We learned that it is no unnecessary luxury to have such expertise in the design team. Thanks to student feedback, we also learned that less is more. Rather than providing the complete guide to intervision, we limited ourselves to information beginners need to start with intervision and added further reading tips for anyone interested. Although the e-learning turned-out to be concise and appealing, we still needed a student tracking system to motivate students to complete the e-learning in time. Apart from the e-learning, we learned that circumstances matter to reduce student resistance, i.e. to pay attention to group composition and not schedule meetings on Friday afternoons, when students are tired after a week of outpatient clinic work. Lastly, we still would like to employ more qualified teachers to further deepen students' learning.</p><p>Approved by Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Social and Behavioural Sciences of Utrecht University, number 24-0085.</p><p><b>Richta C. IJntema:</b> Writing—original draft; writing—review and editing. <b>Nicole J. J. M. Mastenbroek:</b> Writing—review and editing.</p><p>None.</p>\",\"PeriodicalId\":18370,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Medical Education\",\"volume\":\"58 11\",\"pages\":\"1404-1405\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":4.9000,\"publicationDate\":\"2024-08-30\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/medu.15502\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Medical Education\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"95\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/medu.15502\",\"RegionNum\":1,\"RegionCategory\":\"教育学\",\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q1\",\"JCRName\":\"EDUCATION, SCIENTIFIC DISCIPLINES\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Medical Education","FirstCategoryId":"95","ListUrlMain":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/medu.15502","RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"教育学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"EDUCATION, SCIENTIFIC DISCIPLINES","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
1因此,乌特勒支大学(Utrecht University)兽医学院(FVM)所有硕士课程的学生都要在门诊工作期间学习如何进行4次2小时的小组互视。在向学生传授这种方法时,我们遇到了两个主要问题:(1) 学生对彼此分享个人问题表现出抵触情绪;(2) 一些兽医工作人员不具备教授间视学的资格。为了同时解决这两个问题,我们决定翻转课堂,在 ULearning 平台上开发一种电子学习方式。该电子学习包括五个模块,解释了为什么要进行互视、做什么和如何进行互视,并说明了如何应用三种不同的互视模式。在电子学习中,兽医学校友们通过许多视频短片解释了他们参与互视的原因、分享和学习的内容以及应避免的误区,这些视频短片都是很有影响力的学习活动。他们的感言向学生阐明了互视是一种相关的、普通的专业知识发展方法。关于如何组织互视会议以及与虚拟教练(DialogueTrainer 工具)进行实际操作的综合示例也很有说服力。通过这种在线学习,学生对教师的依赖性降低了。他们都得到了关于视间会议方法的同样全面的解释,并且知道在会议期间应该做什么,因为他们可以立即应用他们在网上学到的知识。从教师的观察和学生的评价中可以看出,学生的抵触情绪减少了,教师也感觉自己更有能力胜任工作了。虽然电子教学取得了成功,而且可以使用多年,甚至在弗拉芒大学以外的硕士课程中使用,但这并不是一蹴而就的。我们一开始充满热情,但很快就发现,我们对构建电子教学所需的时间和精力过于乐观,对成功完成项目所需的技能过于天真。电子学习就像一本互动书籍。它不仅需要良好的写作技巧,还需要设计互动内容的软件技能和多媒体技能,如视频制作和信息图表设计。我们了解到,在设计团队中拥有这些专业知识并非多余的奢望。通过学生的反馈,我们还认识到,少即是多。我们没有提供完整的互视指南,而是仅限于提供初学者开始使用互视所需的信息,并为有兴趣的人增加了进一步阅读的提示。虽然电子学习材料简明扼要,很有吸引力,但我们仍然需要一个学生跟踪系统,以激励学生及时完成电子学习材料。除了电子学习外,我们还了解到,要减少学生的抵触情绪,环境也很重要,即要注意小组的组成,不要把会议安排在周五下午,因为学生在一周的门诊工作后已经很疲惫了。最后,我们仍希望聘请更多合格的教师,以进一步深化学生的学习:写作-原稿;写作-审阅和编辑。Nicole J. J. M. Mastenbroek:撰写-审阅和编辑。
Teaching intervision: Overcoming student resistance by using e-learning
Intervision, a peer-led group reflection method, is regarded as an important instrument for continuing professional development.1 Therefore, students in all master programmes of the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine (FVM) at Utrecht University (UU) are taught how to conduct intervision in four 2-hour sessions during their outpatient clinic work. In teaching this method to students, we encountered two main problems: (1) students showing resistance to share personal issues with each other, and (2) some veterinary medicine staff being underqualified to teach intervision.
To address both problems at once, we decided to flip the classroom and develop an e-learning on the ULearning platform, made possible by an UU Education Innovation Grant. This e-learning consists of five modules explaining the why, what and how of intervision, and illustrating how to apply three different intervision models. Powerful learning activities in the e-learning are the many short videos in which veterinary medicine alumni explain why they participate in intervision, what they share and learn, and which pitfalls to avoid. Their testimonials clarify to students that intervision is a relevant and ordinary method for expertise development. Powerful are also the comprehensive examples of how to structure an intervision meeting and the actual practice with a virtual coach (DialogueTrainer tool). Due to this e-learning, students became less dependent of their teacher. They all received the same comprehensive explanation about the intervision method and knew what to do during meetings because they could immediately apply what they had learned online. Student resistance decreased as shown by teacher observations and student evaluations, and teachers felt more equipped for the job. Hence, the e-learning had the intended effect.
Although the e-learning was successful and can be used for years, even in master programmes outside FVM, it did not happen overnight. We started off enthusiastically, but soon discovered that we had been overly optimistic about the time and effort it would take to build the e-learning and naive about the skills required to successfully complete the project. An e-learning is like an interactive book. It not only requires good writing skills, but also software skills to design interactive content and multimedia skills, such as video production and infographic design. We learned that it is no unnecessary luxury to have such expertise in the design team. Thanks to student feedback, we also learned that less is more. Rather than providing the complete guide to intervision, we limited ourselves to information beginners need to start with intervision and added further reading tips for anyone interested. Although the e-learning turned-out to be concise and appealing, we still needed a student tracking system to motivate students to complete the e-learning in time. Apart from the e-learning, we learned that circumstances matter to reduce student resistance, i.e. to pay attention to group composition and not schedule meetings on Friday afternoons, when students are tired after a week of outpatient clinic work. Lastly, we still would like to employ more qualified teachers to further deepen students' learning.
Approved by Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Social and Behavioural Sciences of Utrecht University, number 24-0085.
Richta C. IJntema: Writing—original draft; writing—review and editing. Nicole J. J. M. Mastenbroek: Writing—review and editing.
期刊介绍:
Medical Education seeks to be the pre-eminent journal in the field of education for health care professionals, and publishes material of the highest quality, reflecting world wide or provocative issues and perspectives.
The journal welcomes high quality papers on all aspects of health professional education including;
-undergraduate education
-postgraduate training
-continuing professional development
-interprofessional education