Characterizing traces of processes defined by precedence and response constraints: An order theory approach

Abstract

In this paper we consider a general system of activities that can, but do not have to, occur. This system is governed by a set containing two types of constraints: precedence and response. A precedence constraint dictates that an activity can only occur if it has been preceded by some other specified activity. Response constraints are similarly defined. An execution of the system is a listing of activities in the order they occur and which satisfies all constraints. These listings are known as traces. Such systems naturally arise in areas of theoretical computer science and decision science. An outcome of the freedom with which activities can occur is that there are many different possible executions, and gaining a combinatorial insight into these is a non-trivial problem.

We characterize all of the ways in which such a system can be executed. Our approach uses order theory to provide a classification in terms of the linear extensions of posets constructed from the constraint sets. This characterization is essential in calculating the stakeholder utility metrics that have been developed by the first author that allow for quantitative comparisons of such systems/processes. It also allows for a better understanding of the theoretical backbone to these processes.