Moral Elevation Online Intervention for Veterans Experiencing Distress Related to Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and Moral Injury (MOVED): Pilot Trial of a 4-Week Positive Psychology Web-Based Intervention.
Adam P McGuire, Binh An Nguyen Howard, Thane M Erickson, Suzannah K Creech
{"title":"Moral Elevation Online Intervention for Veterans Experiencing Distress Related to Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and Moral Injury (MOVED): Pilot Trial of a 4-Week Positive Psychology Web-Based Intervention.","authors":"Adam P McGuire, Binh An Nguyen Howard, Thane M Erickson, Suzannah K Creech","doi":"10.2196/39894","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p><strong>Background: </strong>Veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and moral injury can encounter several barriers to treatment, including limited access to care and low engagement with therapy. Furthermore, most treatment approaches focus on alleviating distress rather than cultivating positive experiences that could facilitate trauma recovery. A potential way to address these issues is through moral elevation: feeling uplifted and inspired by others' virtuous actions.</p><p><strong>Objective: </strong>This study aimed to examine the feasibility and acceptability of a novel, web-based moral elevation intervention for veterans with PTSD symptoms and moral injury distress (Moral Elevation Online Intervention for Veterans Experiencing Distress Related to PTSD and Moral Injury [MOVED]). This mixed methods study also examined potential changes in PTSD symptoms, moral injury distress, quality of life, and prosocial behavior.</p><p><strong>Methods: </strong>In this pilot trial, 48 participants were randomized to a MOVED or control condition (24 participants per condition). Both conditions included 8 sessions and lasted 1 month. The MOVED intervention and all survey components across both conditions were administered online. Participants completed self-report measures that assessed PTSD symptoms, moral injury distress, quality of life, and prosocial behavior at baseline and follow-up. Veterans in the MOVED condition also completed individual qualitative interviews at follow-up. We coded qualitative responses to interviews and identified emergent themes.</p><p><strong>Results: </strong>Findings suggest the MOVED intervention was largely feasible, with evidence for moderate-to-high levels of participation, engagement, and retention in MOVED sessions. Both quantitative and qualitative results suggest veterans found MOVED to be acceptable and satisfactory at the overall treatment level. Furthermore, participants reported high scores for helpfulness and engagement at the session level. Veterans who completed MOVED reported large within-person decreases in PTSD symptoms (Cohen d=1.44), approximately twice that of veterans in the control condition (Cohen d=0.78). Those in MOVED also reported medium-sized increases in physical (Cohen d=0.71) and psychological domains of quality of life (Cohen d=0.74), compared with no meaningful changes in the control condition. Unexpectedly, MOVED veterans reported no decrease in moral injury distress, whereas veterans in the control condition endorsed a medium-sized decrease in the total score. There were no changes in prosociality for either condition. Qualitative feedback further supported high levels of perceived acceptability and satisfaction and positive treatment outcomes across a range of domains, including behaviors, cognitions, emotions, and social functioning. Veterans also recommended adaptations to enhance engagement and maximize the impact of intervention content.</p><p><strong>Conclusions: </strong>Overall, findings indicate that veterans with PTSD and moral injury distress were interested in an intervention based on exposure to and engagement with experiences of moral elevation. After further research and refinement guided by future trials, veterans may benefit from this novel approach, which may enhance treatment outcomes and increase treatment accessibility for those in need of additional trauma-focused care.</p>","PeriodicalId":14841,"journal":{"name":"JMIR Formative Research","volume":"7 ","pages":"e39894"},"PeriodicalIF":2.0000,"publicationDate":"2023-03-24","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10131687/pdf/","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"JMIR Formative Research","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.2196/39894","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q3","JCRName":"HEALTH CARE SCIENCES & SERVICES","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Background: Veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and moral injury can encounter several barriers to treatment, including limited access to care and low engagement with therapy. Furthermore, most treatment approaches focus on alleviating distress rather than cultivating positive experiences that could facilitate trauma recovery. A potential way to address these issues is through moral elevation: feeling uplifted and inspired by others' virtuous actions.
Objective: This study aimed to examine the feasibility and acceptability of a novel, web-based moral elevation intervention for veterans with PTSD symptoms and moral injury distress (Moral Elevation Online Intervention for Veterans Experiencing Distress Related to PTSD and Moral Injury [MOVED]). This mixed methods study also examined potential changes in PTSD symptoms, moral injury distress, quality of life, and prosocial behavior.
Methods: In this pilot trial, 48 participants were randomized to a MOVED or control condition (24 participants per condition). Both conditions included 8 sessions and lasted 1 month. The MOVED intervention and all survey components across both conditions were administered online. Participants completed self-report measures that assessed PTSD symptoms, moral injury distress, quality of life, and prosocial behavior at baseline and follow-up. Veterans in the MOVED condition also completed individual qualitative interviews at follow-up. We coded qualitative responses to interviews and identified emergent themes.
Results: Findings suggest the MOVED intervention was largely feasible, with evidence for moderate-to-high levels of participation, engagement, and retention in MOVED sessions. Both quantitative and qualitative results suggest veterans found MOVED to be acceptable and satisfactory at the overall treatment level. Furthermore, participants reported high scores for helpfulness and engagement at the session level. Veterans who completed MOVED reported large within-person decreases in PTSD symptoms (Cohen d=1.44), approximately twice that of veterans in the control condition (Cohen d=0.78). Those in MOVED also reported medium-sized increases in physical (Cohen d=0.71) and psychological domains of quality of life (Cohen d=0.74), compared with no meaningful changes in the control condition. Unexpectedly, MOVED veterans reported no decrease in moral injury distress, whereas veterans in the control condition endorsed a medium-sized decrease in the total score. There were no changes in prosociality for either condition. Qualitative feedback further supported high levels of perceived acceptability and satisfaction and positive treatment outcomes across a range of domains, including behaviors, cognitions, emotions, and social functioning. Veterans also recommended adaptations to enhance engagement and maximize the impact of intervention content.
Conclusions: Overall, findings indicate that veterans with PTSD and moral injury distress were interested in an intervention based on exposure to and engagement with experiences of moral elevation. After further research and refinement guided by future trials, veterans may benefit from this novel approach, which may enhance treatment outcomes and increase treatment accessibility for those in need of additional trauma-focused care.
背景:患有创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)和精神创伤的退伍军人在接受治疗时可能会遇到一些障碍,包括获得治疗的机会有限和治疗参与度低。此外,大多数治疗方法都侧重于减轻痛苦,而不是培养可促进创伤恢复的积极体验。解决这些问题的一个潜在方法是道德提升:从他人的美德行为中感到振奋和鼓舞:本研究旨在考察一种新颖的、基于网络的道德提升干预(Moral Elevation Online Intervention for Veterans Experencing Distress Related to PTSD and Moral Injury [MOVED])的可行性和可接受性,该干预针对有创伤后应激障碍症状和道德伤害困扰的退伍军人。这项混合方法研究还考察了创伤后应激障碍症状、道德伤害困扰、生活质量和亲社会行为的潜在变化:在这项试点试验中,48 名参与者被随机分配到 MOVED 或对照组(每组 24 人)。两种情况都包括 8 个疗程,持续 1 个月。两种条件下的 MOVED 干预和所有调查内容均在网上进行。参与者在基线和随访期间完成自我报告测量,评估创伤后应激障碍症状、精神伤害困扰、生活质量和亲社会行为。MOVED 条件下的退伍军人还在随访时完成了个人定性访谈。我们对访谈的定性回答进行了编码,并确定了新出现的主题:结果:研究结果表明,MOVED 干预在很大程度上是可行的,有证据表明,MOVED 课程的参与度、投入度和保持度都达到了中高水平。定量和定性结果都表明,退伍军人认为 MOVED 在整体治疗水平上是可以接受和令人满意的。此外,参与者还报告说,在疗程层面上,他们对帮助性和参与度的评分都很高。完成 MOVED 治疗的退伍军人报告说,他们的创伤后应激障碍症状在个人范围内有很大程度的减轻(Cohen d=1.44),大约是对照组退伍军人的两倍(Cohen d=0.78)。参加 MOVED 的退伍军人还报告了身体(Cohen d=0.71)和生活质量心理领域(Cohen d=0.74)的中等程度增长,而对照组退伍军人则没有明显变化。出乎意料的是,MOVED 退伍军人报告的精神伤害痛苦没有减少,而对照组退伍军人则表示总分有中等程度的减少。两种情况下的亲社会性都没有变化。定性反馈进一步证明,在行为、认知、情绪和社会功能等一系列领域,退伍军人的可接受性和满意度较高,治疗效果积极。退伍军人还建议进行调整,以提高参与度并最大限度地发挥干预内容的影响:总体而言,研究结果表明,患有创伤后应激障碍和道德伤害困扰的退伍军人对基于接触和参与道德提升体验的干预很感兴趣。在未来试验的指导下进行进一步研究和改进后,退伍军人可能会从这种新方法中受益,这种方法可能会提高治疗效果,并增加需要额外创伤护理的人获得治疗的机会。