We have prepared trityl radicals with protons at the positions of the -COOH group in the phenyl rings and examined their EPR spectra, which show large - hyperfine couplings, and their dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) Zeeman field profiles . By assessing these polarizing agents for high-field and Overhauser effect DNP, we gain insight into the roles that these hyperfine couplings and other molecular properties play in the DNP performance of these radicals. Interestingly, we do not observe OE DNP in any of the three molecules we examined. This suggests that hyperfine couplings by themselves are not sufficient to support OE DNP. In this case the electron spin density is ∼75 % localized on the central carbon atom rather than being distributed uniformly over the aromatic rings. This is in contrast to BDPA where the distribution is delocalized. Our findings do not suggest that any of these radicals are particularly well-suited to high-field DNP. Furthermore, we emphasize that polarizing agents can be extremely sensitive to their solvent environment, even obscuring the intrinsic magnetic properties of the radical.