Hemoglobin (Hb) Malay is a common β hemoglobinopathy in Malaysia caused by A > G mutation in codon 19 leading to β+-thalassemia phenotype. However, screening for Hb Malay is challenging as it is undetectable by routine capillary electrophoresis (CE) or high-performance liquid chromatograpy (HPLC) methods. This study aimed to determine the Hb Malay phenotypes. The study was done on 521 cases with presumed β thalassemia from UKMMC and Hospital Selayang as well as confirmed Hb Malay cases from Hospital Sultanah Bahiyah, Kedah in over a 5-year period. Hb analysis using CE or HPLC followed by multiplex amplification refractory mutation system polymerase chain reaction and DNA sequencing were performed. Significant differences in mean values of haematological parameters among Hb Malay carriers against β thalassemia carriers were determined using one-way ANOVA and ROC analysis. A total of 482/521 cases of β globin mutations were identified. Among these, 54 Hb Malay cases were identified whereby 21 Hb Malay cases were from UKMMC and Hospital Selayang whilst 33 Hb Malay cases were from Hospital Sultanah Bahiyah, Kedah. Fifty-two were Hb Malay carriers whereas two cases were compound heterozygotes. The mean hemoglobin, mean cell volume, mean cell hemoglobin, and HbA of Hb Malay carriers were significantly higher than β° thalassemia carriers. The HbA2 range of Hb Malay carriers was wider (3.5-5.5%) with median value of 3.9%. A new HbA2 cutoff value ≤4.6% (AUC 0.717, p < 0.001) was proposed. Compound heterozygous Hb Malay/IVS1-5(G > C) showed transfusion-dependent thalassemia phenotype. Hb Malay carriers have different red cell and electrophoretic parameters than classical β° thalassemia carriers with wider HbA2 range. HbA2 of ≤4.6% should prompt a molecular confirmation for Hb Malay carrier status.