Direct enrollment (DE) study abroad programs offer linguistic and cultural immersion by allowing students to enroll in coursework at partner universities worldwide. However, there is limited research on students’ perspectives of such programs and the necessary measures for success. This study uses unique multi-site survey data and a mixed-method approach to examine 91 US students’ perspectives in five Spanish cities. It explores the impact of pre-departure support, language proficiency, and assistance while abroad on program recommendations and Spanish proficiency improvement. Logistic regression analysis reveals that pre-departure support and higher proficiency increase program recommendation, while more support from professors throughout the semester of direct enroll decreases it. Qualitative analysis highlights the challenging yet rewarding nature of these experiences, providing insights for study abroad (SA) program development, such as social relationship development, immersion experiences, perceptions of teaching styles, and educational environment. The findings also provide insights for faculty and administrators involved in study abroad programming.