Michael Stedman, Peter Taylor, Ian Halsall, David Halsall, Buchi Okosieme, Suhani Bahl, Lakdasa Premawardhana, Colin Dayan, Anthony A. Fryer, Adrian Heald
<p>There continues to be much discussion around optimization of thyroid hormone status in hypothyroid individuals. The ideal therapeutic goal in hypothyroidism would be to restore clinical and biochemical euthyroidism via physiologic thyroid hormone replacement. The relation between circulating thyroid hormone levels (FreeT4 [fT4] and FreeT3) and thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) is integral to this. This concept may seem straightforward, but there are subtleties that have only recently been recognized [<span>1</span>].</p><p>Over 10 million thyroid function tests (TFT) are undertaken in England annually. To reduce test numbers, laboratories very often measure TSH and then only reflex measure fT4 if TSH results fall outside the reference range (RR) [<span>2</span>].</p><p>We analysed the relation between fT4 and TSH results for patients both on and off thyroid medication using a city-wide population database.</p><p>Simultaneous TSH and fT4 results from 47,869 diagnosed hypothyroid individuals (including information on dose) and 393,101 untreated/euthyroid individuals who had been tested once or twice were included. Data were extracted from the Greater Manchester Care Record (GMCR) [<span>3</span>].</p><p>The data used in the analyses presented was obtained with the permission of the Greater Manchester Care Record Board (reference number R 2023 065) and was fully anonymised before being made available to the investigators.</p><p>Diagnostic data were validated and cleaned before analysis. Only patients with a coded diagnosis of primary hypothyroidism were included.</p><p>Our findings showed:</p><p><b><i>Untreated individuals</i></b> (Table 1)</p><p>Of the 452,463 results in the untreated/euthyroid population (<i>n</i> = 393,101 people), 89.9% (406,700) were within the TSH-RR and 99.1% (448,171) were within the fT4-RR.</p><p>Of those 406,700 with a TSH within the RR, 3319 (0.82%) had a fT4 < 9 and 175 (0.043%) had a fT4 > 25. These account for 83.1% of all results with a fT4 < 9 and 58.3% of all those with a fT4 > 25.</p><p><b>Both these groups might not receive a reflex fT4 result if REFLEX testing were applied.</b></p><p><b><i>Treated individuals</i></b> (Table 1)</p><p>Of 407,075 results in the treated population (<i>n</i> = 47,869 people), 176,833 (43.4%) were in TSH-RR.</p><p>Of those 176,833 with a TSH within the RR, 1368 (0.77%) had a fT4 < 9 and 3065 (1.73%) had a fT4 > 25. These account for 15.1% of all results with a fT4 < 9 and 21.7% of all those with a fT4 > 25.</p><p><b>Both these groups might not receive a reflex fT4 result if REFLEX testing was applied.</b></p><p>These effects were more prevalent in people taking a higher dose of levothyroxine.</p><p>When only those with normal TSH results were considered, we found that in the untreated cohort, 0.043% had an FT4 > 25 pmol/L. However, within the population being treated with levothyroxine, this was 1.73%, showing that the relative risk of high FT4 in treated
{"title":"Evaluation of Thyroid Hormone Status: Are Simultaneous TSH and FT4 Tests Necessary? Analysis of Thyroid Function Test Results Taken From the Greater Manchester Care Record 2010–2023","authors":"Michael Stedman, Peter Taylor, Ian Halsall, David Halsall, Buchi Okosieme, Suhani Bahl, Lakdasa Premawardhana, Colin Dayan, Anthony A. Fryer, Adrian Heald","doi":"10.1111/cen.70012","DOIUrl":"10.1111/cen.70012","url":null,"abstract":"<p>There continues to be much discussion around optimization of thyroid hormone status in hypothyroid individuals. The ideal therapeutic goal in hypothyroidism would be to restore clinical and biochemical euthyroidism via physiologic thyroid hormone replacement. The relation between circulating thyroid hormone levels (FreeT4 [fT4] and FreeT3) and thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) is integral to this. This concept may seem straightforward, but there are subtleties that have only recently been recognized [<span>1</span>].</p><p>Over 10 million thyroid function tests (TFT) are undertaken in England annually. To reduce test numbers, laboratories very often measure TSH and then only reflex measure fT4 if TSH results fall outside the reference range (RR) [<span>2</span>].</p><p>We analysed the relation between fT4 and TSH results for patients both on and off thyroid medication using a city-wide population database.</p><p>Simultaneous TSH and fT4 results from 47,869 diagnosed hypothyroid individuals (including information on dose) and 393,101 untreated/euthyroid individuals who had been tested once or twice were included. Data were extracted from the Greater Manchester Care Record (GMCR) [<span>3</span>].</p><p>The data used in the analyses presented was obtained with the permission of the Greater Manchester Care Record Board (reference number R 2023 065) and was fully anonymised before being made available to the investigators.</p><p>Diagnostic data were validated and cleaned before analysis. Only patients with a coded diagnosis of primary hypothyroidism were included.</p><p>Our findings showed:</p><p><b><i>Untreated individuals</i></b> (Table 1)</p><p>Of the 452,463 results in the untreated/euthyroid population (<i>n</i> = 393,101 people), 89.9% (406,700) were within the TSH-RR and 99.1% (448,171) were within the fT4-RR.</p><p>Of those 406,700 with a TSH within the RR, 3319 (0.82%) had a fT4 < 9 and 175 (0.043%) had a fT4 > 25. These account for 83.1% of all results with a fT4 < 9 and 58.3% of all those with a fT4 > 25.</p><p><b>Both these groups might not receive a reflex fT4 result if REFLEX testing were applied.</b></p><p><b><i>Treated individuals</i></b> (Table 1)</p><p>Of 407,075 results in the treated population (<i>n</i> = 47,869 people), 176,833 (43.4%) were in TSH-RR.</p><p>Of those 176,833 with a TSH within the RR, 1368 (0.77%) had a fT4 < 9 and 3065 (1.73%) had a fT4 > 25. These account for 15.1% of all results with a fT4 < 9 and 21.7% of all those with a fT4 > 25.</p><p><b>Both these groups might not receive a reflex fT4 result if REFLEX testing was applied.</b></p><p>These effects were more prevalent in people taking a higher dose of levothyroxine.</p><p>When only those with normal TSH results were considered, we found that in the untreated cohort, 0.043% had an FT4 > 25 pmol/L. However, within the population being treated with levothyroxine, this was 1.73%, showing that the relative risk of high FT4 in treated ","PeriodicalId":10346,"journal":{"name":"Clinical Endocrinology","volume":"103 6","pages":"906-908"},"PeriodicalIF":2.4,"publicationDate":"2025-08-19","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/cen.70012","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"144871718","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":3,"RegionCategory":"医学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"OA","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}