We present the case of a patient who came to the emergency department with a significant decrease in vision and dilated pupil in the left eye. Since neurological pathologies were primarily considered, diffusion brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and brain computed tomography (CT) were requested. After the results were reported as normal, we were consulted. On examination, the anterior segment was normal but we detected shiny pearl-like formations in the anterior vitreous, condensation at the inferior of the posterior vitreous, and a scar in the macula. When we evaluated the orbital section of the current brain CT, we detected an intraocular foreign body (IOFB). On the brain MRI, we saw a large artifact that obscured the left orbit and surrounding anatomical structures. When we questioned again, we learned that he had been admitted to another emergency department two months prior due to an object hitting his left eye, where the eye was only washed with saline. Our case emphasizes that ocular siderosis caused by IOFBs should be kept in mind in the differential diagnosis of anisocoria, especially before MRI. Because metallic objects may move during MRI, undiagnosed IOFBs can cause serious ocular side effects.