Katyuscia Araujo-Vieira, Pedro Henrique Dos Santos Dias, Martín O Pereyra, Boris L Blotto, Ulisses Caramaschi, Célio F B Haddad, Julián Faivovich, Taran Grant
Sphaenorhynchini comprises 15 species of small, greenish treefrogs from cis-Andean South America. Araujo-Vieira et al. (2019, A total evidence analysis of the phylogeny of hatch-faced treefrogs [Anura: Hylidae: Sphaenorhynchus], Cladistics 35, 469-486) conducted a total evidence parsimony analysis of DNA sequences and phenotypic data, corroborating the monophyly of Sphaenorhynchus, identifying three species groups, and placing the unusual species S. pauloalvini as sister to all other species. On this basis and numerous phenotypic differences, Araujo-Vieira et al. (2020, A new genus of lime treefrogs [Anura: Hylidae: Sphaenorhynchini], Zool. Anz. 286, 81-89) erected the genus Gabohyla for S. pauloalvini. Subsequently, Pereira et al. (2022, The dispersal between Amazonia and Atlantic Forest during the Early Neogene revealed by the biogeography of the treefrog tribe Sphaenorhynchini [Anura, Hylidae], Ecol. Evol. 12, e8754) performed a Bayesian analysis of a subset of Araujo-Vieira et al.'s (2019) molecular data and found G. pauloalvini to be nested within Sphaenorhynchus, which they attributed exclusively to choice of analytical method. To test this claim, we performed parsimony and Bayesian analyses of the total evidence dataset and the complete and partial molecular datasets with either the entire outgroup sample or a single terminal. The topology from the Bayesian analysis of the complete dataset is almost identical to that of Araujo-Vieira et al. (2019), with G. pauloalvini sister to Sphaenorhynchus, thereby refuting Pereira et al.'s claim. Moreover, the monophyly of Sphaenorhynchus sensu stricto was remarkably robust, being recovered in all analyses except the Bayesian analysis of the partial molecular dataset with a single outgroup terminal (i.e., the analysis performed by Pereira et al.). In addition to supporting the continued recognition of Gabohyla, our results underscore the importance of considering not only the choice of analytical method, but also character and taxon sampling-including outgroup sampling-before rejecting prior findings.
Sphaenorhynchini包括15种来自南美洲安第斯山脉的小型绿色树蛙。arauho - vieira et al. (2019, A total evidence analysis of hatchfaced tree - frogs [Anura: Hylidae: Sphaenorhynchus], Cladistics 35, 469-486])对DNA序列和表型数据进行了总证据简化分析,证实了Sphaenorhynchus的单系性,确定了三个物种群,并将不寻常的物种S. pauloalvini作为所有其他物种的姐妹物种。在此基础上和众多表型差异,Araujo-Vieira et al.(2020,一种新的酸橙树蛙属[无尾目:水螅科:Sphaenorhynchini], Zool。Anz. 286, 81-89)为S. pauloalvini建立了Gabohyla属。随后,Pereira et al.(2022),由树蛙部落Sphaenorhynchini [Anura, Hylidae]的生物地理学揭示的早新近世亚马逊河和大西洋森林之间的分散,Ecol。Evol. 12, e8754)对Araujo-Vieira等人(2019)的分子数据进行了贝叶斯分析,发现G. pauloalvini嵌套在Sphaenorhynchus中,他们将其完全归因于分析方法的选择。为了验证这一说法,我们使用整个外群样本或单个终端对全部证据数据集以及完整和部分分子数据集进行了简约和贝叶斯分析。对完整数据集进行贝叶斯分析得到的拓扑与Araujo-Vieira等人(2019)的拓扑几乎相同,G. pauloalvini是Sphaenorhynchus的姐妹,从而反驳了Pereira等人的说法。此外,Sphaenorhynchus sensu stricto的单系性非常稳健,除了对具有单个外群末端的部分分子数据集的贝叶斯分析(即Pereira等人进行的分析)外,所有分析都恢复了单系性。除了支持对Gabohyla的持续认可外,我们的结果强调了在拒绝先前的发现之前,不仅要考虑分析方法的选择,还要考虑特征和分类单元采样(包括外群采样)的重要性。
{"title":"On a recent phylogenetic reanalysis of Sphaenorhynchini (Anura: Hylidae: Hylinae): Does it all come down to the method?","authors":"Katyuscia Araujo-Vieira, Pedro Henrique Dos Santos Dias, Martín O Pereyra, Boris L Blotto, Ulisses Caramaschi, Célio F B Haddad, Julián Faivovich, Taran Grant","doi":"10.1111/cla.70018","DOIUrl":"https://doi.org/10.1111/cla.70018","url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>Sphaenorhynchini comprises 15 species of small, greenish treefrogs from cis-Andean South America. Araujo-Vieira et al. (2019, A total evidence analysis of the phylogeny of hatch-faced treefrogs [Anura: Hylidae: Sphaenorhynchus], Cladistics 35, 469-486) conducted a total evidence parsimony analysis of DNA sequences and phenotypic data, corroborating the monophyly of Sphaenorhynchus, identifying three species groups, and placing the unusual species S. pauloalvini as sister to all other species. On this basis and numerous phenotypic differences, Araujo-Vieira et al. (2020, A new genus of lime treefrogs [Anura: Hylidae: Sphaenorhynchini], Zool. Anz. 286, 81-89) erected the genus Gabohyla for S. pauloalvini. Subsequently, Pereira et al. (2022, The dispersal between Amazonia and Atlantic Forest during the Early Neogene revealed by the biogeography of the treefrog tribe Sphaenorhynchini [Anura, Hylidae], Ecol. Evol. 12, e8754) performed a Bayesian analysis of a subset of Araujo-Vieira et al.'s (2019) molecular data and found G. pauloalvini to be nested within Sphaenorhynchus, which they attributed exclusively to choice of analytical method. To test this claim, we performed parsimony and Bayesian analyses of the total evidence dataset and the complete and partial molecular datasets with either the entire outgroup sample or a single terminal. The topology from the Bayesian analysis of the complete dataset is almost identical to that of Araujo-Vieira et al. (2019), with G. pauloalvini sister to Sphaenorhynchus, thereby refuting Pereira et al.'s claim. Moreover, the monophyly of Sphaenorhynchus sensu stricto was remarkably robust, being recovered in all analyses except the Bayesian analysis of the partial molecular dataset with a single outgroup terminal (i.e., the analysis performed by Pereira et al.). In addition to supporting the continued recognition of Gabohyla, our results underscore the importance of considering not only the choice of analytical method, but also character and taxon sampling-including outgroup sampling-before rejecting prior findings.</p>","PeriodicalId":50688,"journal":{"name":"Cladistics","volume":" ","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":6.2,"publicationDate":"2025-11-16","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145535058","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":2,"RegionCategory":"生物学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}