In the present investigation, the wheel-and-axle compound 1,4-phenylene-bis(di-p-tolylmethanol) (H) was demonstrated to have efficient host ability for the saturated heterocyclic guest solvents dioxane, morpholine and piperidine (DIO, MOR and PIP), known toxins in wastewater. Host: guest (H: G) ratios varied, and from 1H-NMR experiments, were calculated to be 1:4, 1:1 and 1:2, respectively. Previously, H was reported to form a complex also with the unsaturated heterocyclic solvent pyridine (PYR, H:G 1:3). When H was crystallized from mixtures containing two or more of the four guests, MOR and PYR were found to be favoured solvents, with DIO and PIP being less likely to be selected by the host species. In order to understand these selectivity observations, single crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD) experiments were performed on each single solvent inclusion compound, as well as thermogravimetric (TG) and differential scanning calorimetric (DSC) analyses. These latter two analytical techniques provided an understanding for the host selectivity behaviour in mixed guest crystallization experiments in that the MOR- and PYR-containing complexes were significantly more stable than those with DIO and PIP, which were not stable even at ambient conditions. Furthermore, least favoured DIO formed crystals with the lowest density of the four, alluding to a looser molecular packing in the complex, explaining the low host selectivity for this guest species. A brief comparison of these results with earlier reports pertaining to related host compounds 1,4-phenylene-bis(diphenylmethanol) (H1) and 1,4-phenylene-bis(di-p-fluorophenylmethanol) (H2) in the same guest solvents was also undertaken and is reported upon here.