Intra-operative pain during Caesarean delivery (PDCD) is the leading cause of successful litigation against obstetric anaesthesiologists. PDCD may require conversion to general anaesthesia (GA). The aim of this analysis is to assess our incidence of PDCD and associated GA conversion.
Data were collected from electronic patient records. Data included baseline demographics, incidence of PDCD and rates of GA conversion, proportion of PDCD cases attributable to failed epidural (EA) or spinal anaesthesia (SA), and level of sensory and motor blockade in cases of PDCD. Results were audited against current standards set by the Royal College of Anaesthetists ‘rates of PDCD should be <5% for category 4, <15% for categories 2-3, and <20 % for category 1 CD ’ and that ‘rates of conversion to GA due to neuraxial complications should be <1% for category 4, <5% for categories 2-3 and <15% for category 1 patients’.
During the 12-month study period, 2,429 patients underwent CD, of whom 52 (2.1%) experienced PDCD. The incidence of PDCD was 3.1% (41/1,309) for category 1-3 patients, while 1% (11/1,120) of category 4 patients experienced PDS. Of the 52 patients with PDCD, 17 patients required GA (33%). SA was used in 24/52 (47%) cases and EA in 28/52 (53%) cases. The median level of sensory block in patients with PDCD was located at the T4 dermatome, the median level of motor block was Bromage level 2.
PDCD occurred in 2.1% of CD, one-third required conversion to GA. Most patients experiencing PDCD met current motor and sensory blockade criteria.
The peripartum management of obstetric patients with Chiari type I malformation remains a challenge due to the degree of cerebellar tonsillar herniation and a paucity of published evidence. There is concern about neuraxial anaesthetic blocks and uncertainty regarding the optimum mode of delivery.
We systematically searched the literature for the obstetric management of patients with Chiari type I malformation, independent of publication date and language. We also searched our local hospital database from December 2009 to December 2022 for all deliveries to patients with this condition. We identified 137 cases comprising 103 deliveries described in 40 publications that met our inclusion criteria; 34 deliveries were identified in our local database. There were 84 spontaneous vaginal deliveries, 52 caesarean deliveries, and one delivery by unknown modality. Sixty neuraxial blocks were performed; approximately half of these were epidural procedures for labour analgesia. Six patients had new or worsened symptoms following delivery, but it is unclear whether these were related to their Chiari malformation. We identified no cases with brainstem herniation or severe symptoms.
We discuss our findings in relation to other published literature and address the concerns described. Our review reveals the use of a variety of modes of delivery and anaesthetic techniques and that most patients suffered no neurological complication. We conclude there is no of evidence to avoid any one approach to labour analgesia, delivery and anaesthesia. We propose a holistic, individualised and patient-centred approach with an appraisal of the risks and benefits to support shared-decision making.