Solid phase extraction (SPE) of a variety of diverse dissolved organic matter (DOM) endmembers through eight commercially available sorbents was examined (ENV, PLEXA, PPL, HLB, Isolute 101, C18/ENV+, C18, Envirelut) representing styrene divinylbenzene polymer (SDVB) and silica-based sorbents. We assessed dissolved organic carbon (DOC) recovery and DOM composition via 21 T Fourier transform-ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS). DOC recoveries and SPE-DOM composition differed more by endmember type than by sorbent. Silica-based sorbents retained DOM with many N-containing formulae, while SDVB-based sorbents retained DOM with more S-containing formulae. Extraction pH exerted a greater influence on DOM composition, notably through the presence of strong groupings composed of saturated and lowly oxygenated formulae at basic pH, and of aromatic and highly oxygenated formulae at pH 2, irrespective of endmember or sorbent. There was above 25% DOC recovery, regardless of sorbent or endmember; >90% of the relative abundance (RA) of molecular formulae were shared with PPL, which is currently the most commonly utilized sorbent for DOM. This clearly highlights the ability of the selected sorbents to retain representative DOM across diverse endmembers. Such findings may be useful for future targeted DOM studies (e.g., bioincubations, wastewater and drinking water applications) interested in focusing on specific compositional changes and will provide a better understanding of how organic carbon cycling is impacted by anthropogenic processes.