{"title":"Limiter le temps d’écran pour la santé mentale : une approche clinique individualisée et socioculturelle.","authors":"Vincent Paquin","doi":"","DOIUrl":"","url":null,"abstract":"","PeriodicalId":44148,"journal":{"name":"Sante Mentale au Quebec","volume":"50 1","pages":"399-404"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3,"publicationDate":"2025-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145640605","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Context In France, both Return to Work (RTW) and sustained employment following extended medical leave are critical concerns, due to the substantial risk of professional disengagement after returning to work. Professional disengagement, influenced by a combination of work-related and health-related factors, necessitates proactive awareness, prevention, and adapted support to maintain employment. The involvement of diverse stakeholders in this process complicates access to available resources, highlighting the need for effective coordination. The occupational health law of August 2, 2021, mandates that Inter-Company Occupational Health Services (SPST) establish Professional Disengagement Prevention (PDP) units. These units are tasked with coordinating RTW support actions among the relevant stakeholders. Objective This exploratory research examines the collaborative process for RTW within a PDP unit at a rural SPST. It analyzes the development of a multi-partner collaborative process with the Health Insurance (Assurance Maladie) and a service provider specializing in maintaining the employment of workers with disabilities. The research aims to describe the development of this multi-partner collaboration and to elucidate the roles of organizational factors and the professionals' understandings of work disability in this process. Method A qualitative methodology was employed, involving the observation of meetings and a word association task with the stakeholders. This approach was used to identify both the facilitators and barriers to collaboration and to analyze the stakeholders' perceptions. Results The analysis identified several facilitators, including effective communication, coordination, and complementarity, as well as barriers, such as operational methods, role ambiguity, and workload. While facilitators enhanced communication and coordination, barriers were associated with limited availability and discrepancies between planned and actual work, intensified by administrative and human resource constraints. The co-construction of a collaborative tool facilitated interactions, decision-making, and improved the efficiency of RTW. Results indicate that sustained collaboration requires role clarification and aligned expectations over time. Perceptions of Professional Disengagement showed both commonalities and differences among the actors, with "support" being central but other elements revealing inter-professional variability. Conclusion In conclusion, the study emphasizes the importance of allowing sufficient time for the development of a shared understanding of roles and perspectives among stakeholders. This is crucial for fostering a robust work collective and ensuring the long-term success of multi-partner collaborations. The collaborative creation of a shared tool was shown to be a significant facilitator in establishing effective collaboration, built on shared, rather than entirely common, understandings.
{"title":"[Preventing occupational reintegration and return to work: An example of multi-partner collaboration in an inter-company occupational health prevention service in France].","authors":"Evelyne Auriac, Sandrine Croity-Belz, Isabelle Faurie","doi":"","DOIUrl":"","url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>Context In France, both Return to Work (RTW) and sustained employment following extended medical leave are critical concerns, due to the substantial risk of professional disengagement after returning to work. Professional disengagement, influenced by a combination of work-related and health-related factors, necessitates proactive awareness, prevention, and adapted support to maintain employment. The involvement of diverse stakeholders in this process complicates access to available resources, highlighting the need for effective coordination. The occupational health law of August 2, 2021, mandates that Inter-Company Occupational Health Services (SPST) establish Professional Disengagement Prevention (PDP) units. These units are tasked with coordinating RTW support actions among the relevant stakeholders. Objective This exploratory research examines the collaborative process for RTW within a PDP unit at a rural SPST. It analyzes the development of a multi-partner collaborative process with the Health Insurance (Assurance Maladie) and a service provider specializing in maintaining the employment of workers with disabilities. The research aims to describe the development of this multi-partner collaboration and to elucidate the roles of organizational factors and the professionals' understandings of work disability in this process. Method A qualitative methodology was employed, involving the observation of meetings and a word association task with the stakeholders. This approach was used to identify both the facilitators and barriers to collaboration and to analyze the stakeholders' perceptions. Results The analysis identified several facilitators, including effective communication, coordination, and complementarity, as well as barriers, such as operational methods, role ambiguity, and workload. While facilitators enhanced communication and coordination, barriers were associated with limited availability and discrepancies between planned and actual work, intensified by administrative and human resource constraints. The co-construction of a collaborative tool facilitated interactions, decision-making, and improved the efficiency of RTW. Results indicate that sustained collaboration requires role clarification and aligned expectations over time. Perceptions of Professional Disengagement showed both commonalities and differences among the actors, with \"support\" being central but other elements revealing inter-professional variability. Conclusion In conclusion, the study emphasizes the importance of allowing sufficient time for the development of a shared understanding of roles and perspectives among stakeholders. This is crucial for fostering a robust work collective and ensuring the long-term success of multi-partner collaborations. The collaborative creation of a shared tool was shown to be a significant facilitator in establishing effective collaboration, built on shared, rather than entirely common, understandings.</p>","PeriodicalId":44148,"journal":{"name":"Sante Mentale au Quebec","volume":"50 1","pages":"115-139"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3,"publicationDate":"2025-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145640916","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
The mental health of Quebec's student population appears to have been deteriorating for several years. Faced with these challenges, the ministère de l'Enseignement supérieur in Quebec has developed the Action plan on student mental health in higher education, which aims to support higher education institutions in implementing practices and measures that can contribute to the well-being and development of a flourishing mental health of the student population. The plan calls for the creation of service corridors between institutions and the health and social services network (HSSN). A number of other ministerial orientations also call for this approach. At present, information on these corridors remains limited, and they do not appear to be the subject of research anywhere in the world, particularly in Quebec. Objective The aim of this article is to document the state of service corridors between universities and the HSSN in Quebec. Method The data at the heart of this article comes from an inventory produced by 17 universities. A thematic analysis of the data was carried out using a deductive and inductive approach, with the aid of N'Vivo software. Results Five themes emerged from the analysis: 1) Issues related to current service corridors between universities and the HSSN; 2) Consequences of the absence of service corridors for students; 3) Consequences of the absence of service corridors for universities; 4) Main factors that could hinder the implementation of service corridors; 5) Proposed solutions. Conclusion Anticipated impact: This article highlights the absence of service corridors between universities and the HSSN, despite the many efforts made to create them and the ministerial orientations that encourage their creation. The article proposes a number of very concrete and actionable solutions that are perfectly aligned with ministerial orientations and that would help reduce emergency room use in Quebec. First priority could be given to students in need of specialized services who must be referred to the HSSN. The use of the mental health access mechanism, present in the HSSN, appears to be the simplest and most coherent approach, given that this mechanism aims to improve access to specific and specialized mental health care and services.
{"title":"[Mental health service corridors between universities and health and social services institutions in Quebec: Persistent challenges and potential solutions].","authors":"Julie Lane, Juliette St-Onge, Anne-Marie Auger, Bruno Collard, Ariane Girard, Jean-Daniel Carrier, François Lauzier-Jobin, Andrée-Anne Légaré, Marie-Ève Poitras, Marie-Ève Fortier, Lara Maillet, Magaly Brodeur","doi":"","DOIUrl":"","url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>The mental health of Quebec's student population appears to have been deteriorating for several years. Faced with these challenges, the ministère de l'Enseignement supérieur in Quebec has developed the Action plan on student mental health in higher education, which aims to support higher education institutions in implementing practices and measures that can contribute to the well-being and development of a flourishing mental health of the student population. The plan calls for the creation of service corridors between institutions and the health and social services network (HSSN). A number of other ministerial orientations also call for this approach. At present, information on these corridors remains limited, and they do not appear to be the subject of research anywhere in the world, particularly in Quebec. Objective The aim of this article is to document the state of service corridors between universities and the HSSN in Quebec. Method The data at the heart of this article comes from an inventory produced by 17 universities. A thematic analysis of the data was carried out using a deductive and inductive approach, with the aid of N'Vivo software. Results Five themes emerged from the analysis: 1) Issues related to current service corridors between universities and the HSSN; 2) Consequences of the absence of service corridors for students; 3) Consequences of the absence of service corridors for universities; 4) Main factors that could hinder the implementation of service corridors; 5) Proposed solutions. Conclusion Anticipated impact: This article highlights the absence of service corridors between universities and the HSSN, despite the many efforts made to create them and the ministerial orientations that encourage their creation. The article proposes a number of very concrete and actionable solutions that are perfectly aligned with ministerial orientations and that would help reduce emergency room use in Quebec. First priority could be given to students in need of specialized services who must be referred to the HSSN. The use of the mental health access mechanism, present in the HSSN, appears to be the simplest and most coherent approach, given that this mechanism aims to improve access to specific and specialized mental health care and services.</p>","PeriodicalId":44148,"journal":{"name":"Sante Mentale au Quebec","volume":"50 1","pages":"365-384"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3,"publicationDate":"2025-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145640919","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Objectives The study of mental health at work and return to work (RTW) in France shows by itself the subject is little developed in French labour and welfare legal doctrine. This study analyse how labour law in France is able-or not-to support the RTW of people who suffer or have suffered from a mental or psychic disorder. Method The method is in line with the usual practices of French legal doctrine, consisting of a study of existing legal regulations in France and an analysis of these. For example, legal standards specific to disability or chronic illness is used. Nevertheless, this subject requires us to explain the difference between "employment" and "work" within the French labour law approach-this chapter deals with "work." We also recall some fundamental legal standards. Results This study provides a dual analysis: that of labour law and that of welfare law, including social security law and employment law. The results takes into account the distinction between people suffering from chronic and non-chronic disorders, as well as disorders caused by work and those not caused by the performance of work, in order to highlight the appropriate legal regime, applied, existing or non-existent in France. Conclusion The approach of French labour and welfare law to issues relating to mental health and RTW presents real difficulties in terms of existing construction and implementation in practice. This obviously represents a limitation in dealing with the issue. Nevertheless, we explore the possibility of presenting the original concept of "préjudice d'anxiété", which strongly emphasizes the link between the social law approach to psychological suffering caused, according to the Cour de cassation, by the psychological disorders engendered by knowledge of the high risk of developing a serious pathology due to exposure to highly noxious or toxic materials or products during one's working career and due to maintaining at work despite these terrible conditions.
法国对工作和重返工作(RTW)中的心理健康的研究本身表明,这一主题在法国劳动和福利法律学说中很少得到发展。本研究分析了法国劳动法如何能够或不能够支持患有或曾经患有精神或精神障碍的人的RTW。方法该方法符合法国法律学说的通常做法,包括对法国现有法律法规的研究和分析。例如,使用针对残疾或慢性病的法律标准。然而,这个主题要求我们解释法国劳动法中“雇佣”和“工作”之间的区别——这一章讨论的是“工作”。我们还回顾一些基本的法律标准。结果本研究提供了劳动法和福利法的双重分析,包括社会保障法和就业法。结果考虑到慢性和非慢性疾病患者之间的区别,以及工作引起的疾病和非工作引起的疾病之间的区别,以便突出法国适用的、现有的或不存在的适当法律制度。结论:法国劳工和福利法处理与精神健康和再就业有关的问题的方法在现有的构建和实践中的执行方面存在真正的困难。这显然表明在处理这个问题时存在局限性。尽管如此,我们探讨了提出“pracry - judice d' anxianxest”这一原始概念的可能性,该概念强烈强调了社会法律方法与最高法院认为造成的心理痛苦之间的联系。由于在工作中暴露于剧毒物质或产品,以及在这些可怕的条件下仍坚持工作,而知道发展成严重病理的高风险而产生的心理障碍。
{"title":"[Return to work and employment: Also a question of mental health. A study through the prism of French labor law].","authors":"Loïc Lerouge","doi":"","DOIUrl":"","url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>Objectives The study of mental health at work and return to work (RTW) in France shows by itself the subject is little developed in French labour and welfare legal doctrine. This study analyse how labour law in France is able-or not-to support the RTW of people who suffer or have suffered from a mental or psychic disorder. Method The method is in line with the usual practices of French legal doctrine, consisting of a study of existing legal regulations in France and an analysis of these. For example, legal standards specific to disability or chronic illness is used. Nevertheless, this subject requires us to explain the difference between \"employment\" and \"work\" within the French labour law approach-this chapter deals with \"work.\" We also recall some fundamental legal standards. Results This study provides a dual analysis: that of labour law and that of welfare law, including social security law and employment law. The results takes into account the distinction between people suffering from chronic and non-chronic disorders, as well as disorders caused by work and those not caused by the performance of work, in order to highlight the appropriate legal regime, applied, existing or non-existent in France. Conclusion The approach of French labour and welfare law to issues relating to mental health and RTW presents real difficulties in terms of existing construction and implementation in practice. This obviously represents a limitation in dealing with the issue. Nevertheless, we explore the possibility of presenting the original concept of \"préjudice d'anxiété\", which strongly emphasizes the link between the social law approach to psychological suffering caused, according to the Cour de cassation, by the psychological disorders engendered by knowledge of the high risk of developing a serious pathology due to exposure to highly noxious or toxic materials or products during one's working career and due to maintaining at work despite these terrible conditions.</p>","PeriodicalId":44148,"journal":{"name":"Sante Mentale au Quebec","volume":"50 1","pages":"23-41"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3,"publicationDate":"2025-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145640900","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Mizué Frey, Benedetta Silva, Philippe Golay, Stéphane Morandi, Charles Bonsack, Aurore Chambaz
<p><p>The therapeutic alliance (TA) is considered one of the founding pillars of a therapeutic approach. Its breakdown is a complex phenomenon affecting both patients and therapists. The breakdown of a TA involves dynamics of withdrawal or confrontation, or both. This article focuses on patients' experiences of TA breakdown through interviews. What do patients have to say about behaviors that are antinomic to the therapeutic process? How do they understand the breakdown of TA-in a hospital setting or in private care? Is a resolution possible? Analysis of these interviews enables us to draw up a preliminary map of typical situations experienced by patients and the reasons that led them to break off the TA. Methods This study is part of a qualitative social science approach. In the first stage, 5 interviews were carried out by a researcher with experience in psychiatry with people affected (all women) by a breakdown in TA. The data collected was then transcribed, analyzed, grouped by theme, compared by theme, reorganized, merged and prioritized. Results The analysis highlighted five key themes in the factors leading to TA breakdown: the power of professionals, the relationship as symbolic violence, the act of care, the functioning of care institutions and the repair of the alliance. A central element in the discourse of the patients interviewed is the violence provoked by the lived experience of an asymmetry of power between them and the psychiatric setting. Faced with this situation, the patients gradually implement strategies of influence to reduce their powerlessness and adapt the care context to their needs, such as withholding information or lying. These narratives call into question the validity of psychiatric acts of care, and invite us to question the epistemological determinants that led to these standards and acts of care in the first place. Discussion In psychiatric institutions, these results suggest that the determinants of TA are, in fact, not insignificantly linked to power issues at multiple levels. Maintaining or breaking a TA is part of a sociological register in which patients recognize themselves as dominated, stigmatized and marginalized. In this context of oppression, concealing or manipulating the truth appear as necessary and licit acts to escape from situations experienced as unjust and confining. Taking a step back, this type of reaction is not new; it's part of the development of the epistemology of the dominated, a movement in social science theorizing the construction of knowledge among people and groups experiencing domination, and where resistance to oppression constitutes a subversive act of lucidity. Not surprisingly, their perspectives are in the minority, as they also reflect the minority social position of the people who practice them. Conclusion The preservation, or repair, of a solid TA is a priority for any therapeutic relationship. In this context, sensitizing psychiatric staff to the limits of the biomedical
{"title":"[Therapeutic alliance: Between rupture and power games, a qualitative study].","authors":"Mizué Frey, Benedetta Silva, Philippe Golay, Stéphane Morandi, Charles Bonsack, Aurore Chambaz","doi":"","DOIUrl":"","url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>The therapeutic alliance (TA) is considered one of the founding pillars of a therapeutic approach. Its breakdown is a complex phenomenon affecting both patients and therapists. The breakdown of a TA involves dynamics of withdrawal or confrontation, or both. This article focuses on patients' experiences of TA breakdown through interviews. What do patients have to say about behaviors that are antinomic to the therapeutic process? How do they understand the breakdown of TA-in a hospital setting or in private care? Is a resolution possible? Analysis of these interviews enables us to draw up a preliminary map of typical situations experienced by patients and the reasons that led them to break off the TA. Methods This study is part of a qualitative social science approach. In the first stage, 5 interviews were carried out by a researcher with experience in psychiatry with people affected (all women) by a breakdown in TA. The data collected was then transcribed, analyzed, grouped by theme, compared by theme, reorganized, merged and prioritized. Results The analysis highlighted five key themes in the factors leading to TA breakdown: the power of professionals, the relationship as symbolic violence, the act of care, the functioning of care institutions and the repair of the alliance. A central element in the discourse of the patients interviewed is the violence provoked by the lived experience of an asymmetry of power between them and the psychiatric setting. Faced with this situation, the patients gradually implement strategies of influence to reduce their powerlessness and adapt the care context to their needs, such as withholding information or lying. These narratives call into question the validity of psychiatric acts of care, and invite us to question the epistemological determinants that led to these standards and acts of care in the first place. Discussion In psychiatric institutions, these results suggest that the determinants of TA are, in fact, not insignificantly linked to power issues at multiple levels. Maintaining or breaking a TA is part of a sociological register in which patients recognize themselves as dominated, stigmatized and marginalized. In this context of oppression, concealing or manipulating the truth appear as necessary and licit acts to escape from situations experienced as unjust and confining. Taking a step back, this type of reaction is not new; it's part of the development of the epistemology of the dominated, a movement in social science theorizing the construction of knowledge among people and groups experiencing domination, and where resistance to oppression constitutes a subversive act of lucidity. Not surprisingly, their perspectives are in the minority, as they also reflect the minority social position of the people who practice them. Conclusion The preservation, or repair, of a solid TA is a priority for any therapeutic relationship. In this context, sensitizing psychiatric staff to the limits of the biomedical","PeriodicalId":44148,"journal":{"name":"Sante Mentale au Quebec","volume":"50 1","pages":"319-340"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3,"publicationDate":"2025-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145641073","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
<p><p>Introduction The disclosure of mental health issues in the workplace highlights tensions between the need to adapt working conditions and the risk of stigmatization affecting the individuals concerned. This research examines the barriers and facilitators shaping this disclosure process within a collaborative framework involving the employee, colleagues, management, and health professionals, using an interdisciplinary approach that combines law and sociology. Method This study is part of an action-research initiative conducted in Belgium since 2018, aimed at developing a support system based on the Individual Placement and Support (IPS) methodology, intended for workers on long-term sick leave related to moderate to severe mental health conditions. It draws on three sets of data: a focus group conducted in 2023 on workplace accommodations for individuals living with mental health conditions, bringing together professionals from mutual insurance funds, employment support specialists, and experts by experience; a series of interviews conducted between 2023 and 2024 with employers and employees participating in the Belgian IPS program; and focus groups held in 2017 that explored the dynamics of professional reintegration, bringing together professionals involved in return-to-work processes, legal experts, and mental health practitioners to offer a more institutional perspective. Following a co-constructive approach with stakeholders, the research adopts a critical stance toward the tensions and limitations inherent in current legal, organizational, and practical frameworks. Thematic analysis of the data was combined with a review of Belgian, European, and international standards to shed light on common challenges across different occupational health systems. Results The disclosure of mental health issues in the workplace goes beyond an individual decision ("to disclose or not to disclose") and is embedded in complex social dynamics. Stigma, rooted in everyday social interactions, affects not only the employees directly concerned but also the professionals supporting them. Moreover, the legal framework reveals an imbalance: the right to privacy is better established than the right to workplace accommodations, which may limit the responsibilities of employers and other actors. A strictly individualized approach to these issues tends to obscure the need for broader engagement among workplace stakeholders. The Belgian case highlights promising practices, particularly within the IPS program, where job coaches play a key role: they help clarify individual needs, support the implementation of concrete accommodations, and contribute to sharing the burden of disclosure among different actors. However, these efforts remain hindered by weak inter-institutional coordination and the lack of shared trust frameworks for the exchange of sensitive information. Discussion The findings call for a collective approach that goes beyond individual handling of disclos
{"title":"[A Legal and Collective Approach to Mental Health Disclosure at Work].","authors":"Vanessa De Greef, Natasia Hamarat","doi":"","DOIUrl":"","url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>Introduction The disclosure of mental health issues in the workplace highlights tensions between the need to adapt working conditions and the risk of stigmatization affecting the individuals concerned. This research examines the barriers and facilitators shaping this disclosure process within a collaborative framework involving the employee, colleagues, management, and health professionals, using an interdisciplinary approach that combines law and sociology. Method This study is part of an action-research initiative conducted in Belgium since 2018, aimed at developing a support system based on the Individual Placement and Support (IPS) methodology, intended for workers on long-term sick leave related to moderate to severe mental health conditions. It draws on three sets of data: a focus group conducted in 2023 on workplace accommodations for individuals living with mental health conditions, bringing together professionals from mutual insurance funds, employment support specialists, and experts by experience; a series of interviews conducted between 2023 and 2024 with employers and employees participating in the Belgian IPS program; and focus groups held in 2017 that explored the dynamics of professional reintegration, bringing together professionals involved in return-to-work processes, legal experts, and mental health practitioners to offer a more institutional perspective. Following a co-constructive approach with stakeholders, the research adopts a critical stance toward the tensions and limitations inherent in current legal, organizational, and practical frameworks. Thematic analysis of the data was combined with a review of Belgian, European, and international standards to shed light on common challenges across different occupational health systems. Results The disclosure of mental health issues in the workplace goes beyond an individual decision (\"to disclose or not to disclose\") and is embedded in complex social dynamics. Stigma, rooted in everyday social interactions, affects not only the employees directly concerned but also the professionals supporting them. Moreover, the legal framework reveals an imbalance: the right to privacy is better established than the right to workplace accommodations, which may limit the responsibilities of employers and other actors. A strictly individualized approach to these issues tends to obscure the need for broader engagement among workplace stakeholders. The Belgian case highlights promising practices, particularly within the IPS program, where job coaches play a key role: they help clarify individual needs, support the implementation of concrete accommodations, and contribute to sharing the burden of disclosure among different actors. However, these efforts remain hindered by weak inter-institutional coordination and the lack of shared trust frameworks for the exchange of sensitive information. Discussion The findings call for a collective approach that goes beyond individual handling of disclos","PeriodicalId":44148,"journal":{"name":"Sante Mentale au Quebec","volume":"50 1","pages":"43-63"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3,"publicationDate":"2025-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145640834","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Objective Managers play an important role in supporting employees returning to work after long-term sick leave. However, little research has focused on the support practices that these managers use when dealing with employees returning to work after burnout. This exploratory study has two objectives. First, it outlines the variety of return to work (RTW) support practices implemented by managers. Second, it describes these managers' perceptions of burnout. We argue that these perceptions of burnout influence the type of support that they provide. Method A series of semi-structured interviews were conducted with 13 volunteer managers to describe the RTW support practices in place and their perceptions of burnout. All managers had been confronted, at least once, with supporting a team member's RTW after burnout (absence of more than one month). Results Managers provide four types of RTW support, including minimal support, collective support, and progressive support. Results are consistent with the general hypothesis and show a relationship between the perceptions of burnout and the type of support provided. Supervisors' perceptions of burnout have an impact on the type, amount, and effectiveness of their support. Conclusion In terms of practical implications, the results indicate that managers need training on burnout, its causes, and its consequences for RTW. They also need training in managing the emotions involved in supporting employees returning to work. The results also show the need to institutionalize collective procedures and systems to support RTW in order to reduce the risk of stigmatization and to promote inclusion and job retention.
{"title":"[Supporting successful return to work after burnout: Perceptions and practices of managers].","authors":"Sandrine Croity-Belz, Sandrine Corte, Isabelle Faurie","doi":"","DOIUrl":"","url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>Objective Managers play an important role in supporting employees returning to work after long-term sick leave. However, little research has focused on the support practices that these managers use when dealing with employees returning to work after burnout. This exploratory study has two objectives. First, it outlines the variety of return to work (RTW) support practices implemented by managers. Second, it describes these managers' perceptions of burnout. We argue that these perceptions of burnout influence the type of support that they provide. Method A series of semi-structured interviews were conducted with 13 volunteer managers to describe the RTW support practices in place and their perceptions of burnout. All managers had been confronted, at least once, with supporting a team member's RTW after burnout (absence of more than one month). Results Managers provide four types of RTW support, including minimal support, collective support, and progressive support. Results are consistent with the general hypothesis and show a relationship between the perceptions of burnout and the type of support provided. Supervisors' perceptions of burnout have an impact on the type, amount, and effectiveness of their support. Conclusion In terms of practical implications, the results indicate that managers need training on burnout, its causes, and its consequences for RTW. They also need training in managing the emotions involved in supporting employees returning to work. The results also show the need to institutionalize collective procedures and systems to support RTW in order to reduce the risk of stigmatization and to promote inclusion and job retention.</p>","PeriodicalId":44148,"journal":{"name":"Sante Mentale au Quebec","volume":"50 1","pages":"65-83"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3,"publicationDate":"2025-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145640994","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Objectives The literature highlights the role of the manager in the successful return to work (RTW) after an absence due to common mental disorders (e.g., depressive disorders). However, few studies have specifically examined the influence of leadership style in this context, thus limiting the knowledge that could inform effective behaviors in organizational settings for sustainable RTW. This paper aims to examine the role of leadership and support practices developed by managers and employers in the context of RTW. Two studies are presented. The first study analyzes the influence of leadership style (transformational vs. authoritarian) and perceived organizational support on employees' retention after their RTW. The second study examines the extent to which managers and employers perceive their ability to implement practices recognized in the literature as promoting sustainable RTW.
Method: In Study 1, 84 employees who had returned to work after a long-term sickness responded to an online questionnaire (Qualtrics). Among them, 70% were on sick leave due to a common mental disorder (CMD). In Study 2, which was international in scope, 30 employers and human resources managers and 28 managers responded to an online questionnaire (LimeSurvey). This questionnaire focused on RTW practices for employees on sick leave due to a CMD, covering the entire RTW sequence.
Results: Study 1: Multiple regression analysis highlights that transformational leadership plays a significant role in reducing burnout and the intention to leave the job, unlike authoritarian leadership, while enhancing the perception of organizational support. Furthermore, the mediating role of SOP and burnout in the effect of transformational leadership on the intention to leave has been demonstrated. Study 2: Descriptive analyses indicate that employers and human resources managers find it easier to communicate rules to the various RTW stakeholders within the organization. However, their self-efficacy is lower when it comes to supporting managers in implementing work accommodations for the affected employees. With respect to managers, they feel capable of establishing measures that promote the sustainable RTW of team members. However, they find it more challenging to adopt RTW practices during the employee's sick leave and to implement preventive measures for relapses.
Conclusion: These two studies highlight the importance of supportive attitudes in job retention and identify areas of difficulty encountered by managers. The discussion presents research perspectives and recommendations to better support managers, employers, and human resources managers.
{"title":"[Sustainable Return to Work: What Leadership and Supportive Practices from Managers and Employers?]","authors":"Donatienne Desmette, Marc Corbière","doi":"","DOIUrl":"","url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>Objectives The literature highlights the role of the manager in the successful return to work (RTW) after an absence due to common mental disorders (e.g., depressive disorders). However, few studies have specifically examined the influence of leadership style in this context, thus limiting the knowledge that could inform effective behaviors in organizational settings for sustainable RTW. This paper aims to examine the role of leadership and support practices developed by managers and employers in the context of RTW. Two studies are presented. The first study analyzes the influence of leadership style (transformational vs. authoritarian) and perceived organizational support on employees' retention after their RTW. The second study examines the extent to which managers and employers perceive their ability to implement practices recognized in the literature as promoting sustainable RTW.</p><p><strong>Method: </strong>In Study 1, 84 employees who had returned to work after a long-term sickness responded to an online questionnaire (Qualtrics). Among them, 70% were on sick leave due to a common mental disorder (CMD). In Study 2, which was international in scope, 30 employers and human resources managers and 28 managers responded to an online questionnaire (LimeSurvey). This questionnaire focused on RTW practices for employees on sick leave due to a CMD, covering the entire RTW sequence.</p><p><strong>Results: </strong>Study 1: Multiple regression analysis highlights that transformational leadership plays a significant role in reducing burnout and the intention to leave the job, unlike authoritarian leadership, while enhancing the perception of organizational support. Furthermore, the mediating role of SOP and burnout in the effect of transformational leadership on the intention to leave has been demonstrated. Study 2: Descriptive analyses indicate that employers and human resources managers find it easier to communicate rules to the various RTW stakeholders within the organization. However, their self-efficacy is lower when it comes to supporting managers in implementing work accommodations for the affected employees. With respect to managers, they feel capable of establishing measures that promote the sustainable RTW of team members. However, they find it more challenging to adopt RTW practices during the employee's sick leave and to implement preventive measures for relapses.</p><p><strong>Conclusion: </strong>These two studies highlight the importance of supportive attitudes in job retention and identify areas of difficulty encountered by managers. The discussion presents research perspectives and recommendations to better support managers, employers, and human resources managers.</p>","PeriodicalId":44148,"journal":{"name":"Sante Mentale au Quebec","volume":"50 1","pages":"85-114"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3,"publicationDate":"2025-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145640997","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Introduction Supported employment, financed by the French Government since 2016, has demonstrated its positive impact on employment access and retention for people declaring a mental health disorder (40% of people supported in 2022). Objective The objective of the analysis of avoided costs, led by the Agence nouvelle des solidarités actives (Ansa) in 2021 and 2022, was to measure the economic impact of supported employment on public finances. This analysis focused on three types of costs: social benefits, psychiatric hospitalizations, and medical leave. Method The method consisted of collecting information from supported employment clients to compare these costs over three years (the year before supported employment and the following 2 years). In total, 462 people responded to the questionnaire, including 136 people over 2 consecutive years. These 2 samples were representative of the entire population of supported employment clients (9,300 people at the end of 2022). Results This analysis demonstrates significant avoided costs with, on average, a saving of 802 euros per person during the first year and 1,213 euros per person during the second year of supported employment. If we extrapolate to the total number of clients at the end of 2023, this constitutes a saving of 7.3 million euros for the year 2022 alone and this only on the 3 types of costs observed. The largest part of avoided costs can be attributed to a significant drop in the cost of psychiatric hospitalizations (-56% over 2 years) and in the cost of social benefits (-8.5% over two years). This analysis also demonstrates that the avoided costs are greater for people declaring a mental health disorder (average avoided cost amounts around 2,200 euros per year). This difference is largely explained by the drop in the number of psychiatric hospitalizations, whether as a percentage of people hospitalized (from 18% the year preceding entry to 9% and 12% over the following 2 years) and by the reduction in the average number of days of hospitalization (from 31 days in the year preceding entry to 20 days in subsequent years). For this public, we also see a slight decrease in the cost of medical leave (-16% over 2 years). Conclusion From a purely economic point of view, this analysis demonstrates a greater impact of supported employment for people suffering from mental health disorders and the need to strengthen links with mental health professionals to orient people towards supported employment.
{"title":"[Analysis of avoided costs by supported employment for people with mental disorders].","authors":"Simon Roussey, Bernard Pachoud","doi":"","DOIUrl":"","url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>Introduction Supported employment, financed by the French Government since 2016, has demonstrated its positive impact on employment access and retention for people declaring a mental health disorder (40% of people supported in 2022). Objective The objective of the analysis of avoided costs, led by the Agence nouvelle des solidarités actives (Ansa) in 2021 and 2022, was to measure the economic impact of supported employment on public finances. This analysis focused on three types of costs: social benefits, psychiatric hospitalizations, and medical leave. Method The method consisted of collecting information from supported employment clients to compare these costs over three years (the year before supported employment and the following 2 years). In total, 462 people responded to the questionnaire, including 136 people over 2 consecutive years. These 2 samples were representative of the entire population of supported employment clients (9,300 people at the end of 2022). Results This analysis demonstrates significant avoided costs with, on average, a saving of 802 euros per person during the first year and 1,213 euros per person during the second year of supported employment. If we extrapolate to the total number of clients at the end of 2023, this constitutes a saving of 7.3 million euros for the year 2022 alone and this only on the 3 types of costs observed. The largest part of avoided costs can be attributed to a significant drop in the cost of psychiatric hospitalizations (-56% over 2 years) and in the cost of social benefits (-8.5% over two years). This analysis also demonstrates that the avoided costs are greater for people declaring a mental health disorder (average avoided cost amounts around 2,200 euros per year). This difference is largely explained by the drop in the number of psychiatric hospitalizations, whether as a percentage of people hospitalized (from 18% the year preceding entry to 9% and 12% over the following 2 years) and by the reduction in the average number of days of hospitalization (from 31 days in the year preceding entry to 20 days in subsequent years). For this public, we also see a slight decrease in the cost of medical leave (-16% over 2 years). Conclusion From a purely economic point of view, this analysis demonstrates a greater impact of supported employment for people suffering from mental health disorders and the need to strengthen links with mental health professionals to orient people towards supported employment.</p>","PeriodicalId":44148,"journal":{"name":"Sante Mentale au Quebec","volume":"50 1","pages":"211-230"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3,"publicationDate":"2025-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145640860","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Domestic violence is now an international social issue. Although some countries have been slow to respond, many have developed interventions based on an empowerment approach. This article examines a number of psychological variables and their impact on the implementation of an accountability approach in a group of participants from France and Canada (Quebec). The variables examined are traumatic and dissociative symptoms, attachment and suicide risk. Although these factors are crucial, they have been little studied, even though they may have an impact on the quality of support provided to perpetrators of domestic violence. Objectives Our objectives were to identify the psycho-socio-criminological profiles of perpetrators of domestic violence who had attended a course or an intervention group. We also wanted to compare these two groups and their respective support in order to hypothesize about the implementation of an accountability process in relation to certain psychological variables. Method A total of 57 men were interviewed, 38 from France and 19 from Quebec, who completed questionnaires on attachment, suicide risk, traumatic and dissociative symptoms, and socio-demographic data. Results The French and Quebec groups of men were similar in terms of their socio-demographic profiles, but there were significant differences in the types of violence reported. The Quebec group reported more sexual violence than the French group, while the French group reported more physical violence than the Quebec group. There were no significant differences in the results of the questionnaires on attachment and suicide risk, but the questionnaires on traumatic and dissociative symptoms were significantly higher among the Quebec perpetrators of domestic violence. Conclusion These differences may be explained by differences in the recruitment sites, the level of self-reflection and the time between the act of violence and the research interview. Secondary prevention work needs to be carried out so that perpetrators of domestic violence can identify their difficulties and verbalise and mentalise the issues that affect them. In addition, the obligation to attend training courses on responsibility, as proposed in France, seems appropriate but not sufficient. Individual meetings with a counsellor or psychologist, as a complement to these courses or groups, could help to increase the level of responsibility for the act and encourage more in-depth work. This awareness could in turn reduce the risk of re-offending and intergenerational transmission.
{"title":"[Sociodemographic, criminological and clinical profiles of perpetrators of domestic violence in France and Quebec: Comparative research].","authors":"Telma Mimault, Suzanne Léveillée, Yann Auxemery","doi":"","DOIUrl":"","url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>Domestic violence is now an international social issue. Although some countries have been slow to respond, many have developed interventions based on an empowerment approach. This article examines a number of psychological variables and their impact on the implementation of an accountability approach in a group of participants from France and Canada (Quebec). The variables examined are traumatic and dissociative symptoms, attachment and suicide risk. Although these factors are crucial, they have been little studied, even though they may have an impact on the quality of support provided to perpetrators of domestic violence. Objectives Our objectives were to identify the psycho-socio-criminological profiles of perpetrators of domestic violence who had attended a course or an intervention group. We also wanted to compare these two groups and their respective support in order to hypothesize about the implementation of an accountability process in relation to certain psychological variables. Method A total of 57 men were interviewed, 38 from France and 19 from Quebec, who completed questionnaires on attachment, suicide risk, traumatic and dissociative symptoms, and socio-demographic data. Results The French and Quebec groups of men were similar in terms of their socio-demographic profiles, but there were significant differences in the types of violence reported. The Quebec group reported more sexual violence than the French group, while the French group reported more physical violence than the Quebec group. There were no significant differences in the results of the questionnaires on attachment and suicide risk, but the questionnaires on traumatic and dissociative symptoms were significantly higher among the Quebec perpetrators of domestic violence. Conclusion These differences may be explained by differences in the recruitment sites, the level of self-reflection and the time between the act of violence and the research interview. Secondary prevention work needs to be carried out so that perpetrators of domestic violence can identify their difficulties and verbalise and mentalise the issues that affect them. In addition, the obligation to attend training courses on responsibility, as proposed in France, seems appropriate but not sufficient. Individual meetings with a counsellor or psychologist, as a complement to these courses or groups, could help to increase the level of responsibility for the act and encourage more in-depth work. This awareness could in turn reduce the risk of re-offending and intergenerational transmission.</p>","PeriodicalId":44148,"journal":{"name":"Sante Mentale au Quebec","volume":"50 1","pages":"269-291"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3,"publicationDate":"2025-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145641012","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}