Background Giant cell tumors of the tendon sheath (GCTTS) of the hand are considered the second most common benign tumors of the hand after ganglion cysts. Excision biopsy is considered the standard treatment at present. They are notorious for having a very high rate of recurrence as given in many studies. Many factors are said to be associated with recurrence of the tumors. The goal of this study is to evaluate the long-term results of a series of 48 patients operated on at a single institute and to find out if there is any correlation between the proposed risk factors with recurrence. Methods A retrospective analysis was done in cases of GCTTS operated on between 2015 and 2021. The patients were invited for follow-up for a minimum of 2 years, and the patient files were reviewed. Further data were collected at follow-up including recurrence, range of movement, sensation, skin necrosis, scarring, and digital neuropathy. A data analysis was done. The correlation between the proposed risk factors and recurrence was calculated with the Pearson correlation coefficient. A p -value of less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant. Results During the 6 years, 48 patients were operated on. Recurrence was observed in eight patients (16%) at an average of 38.7 months from the time of surgery. Of the risk factors, tumors with satellite nodules and tumor adjacency to joint correlated significantly with recurrence. No complications were observed during follow-up. Conclusion GCTTS of the hand has a high propensity to recur. The presence of satellite nodules and proximity to interphalangeal joints are two important risk factors for recurrence. Magnification during surgery ensures complete excision of the tumor and reduces the chance of recurrence.