Telemedicine journal : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association最新文献

Background: The U.S. Navy is considering the installation of telemedicine equipment on more than 300 ships. Besides improving the quality of care, benefits would arise from avoiding medical evacuations (MEDEVACs) and returning patients to work more quickly. Because telemedicine has not yet been fully implemented by the Navy, we relied on projections of anticipated savings and costs, rather than actual expenditures, to determine cost-effectiveness.

Objectives: To determine the demand for telemedicine and the cost-effectiveness of various technologies (telephone and fax, e-mail and Internet, video teleconferencing (VTC), teleradiology, and diagnostic instruments), as well as their bandwidth requirements.

Methods: A panel of Navy medical experts with telemedicine experience reviewed a representative sample of patient visits collected over a 1-year period and estimated the man-day savings and quality-of-care enhancements that might have occurred had telemedicine technologies been available. The savings from potentially avoiding MEDEVACs was estimated from a survey of ships' medical staff. These sample estimates were then projected to the medical workload of the entire fleet. Off-the-shelf telemedicine equipment prices were combined with installation, maintenance, training, and communication costs to obtain the lifecycle costs of the technology.

Results and conclusions: If telemedicine were available to the fleet, ship medical staffs would initiate nearly 19, 000 consults in a year-7% of all patient visits. Telemedicine would enhance quality of care in two-thirds of these consults. Seventeen percent of the MEDEVACs would be preventable with telemedicine (representing 155,000 travel miles), with a savings of $4400 per MEDEVAC. If the ship's communication capabilities were available, e-mail and Internet and telephone and fax would be cost-effective on all ships (including small ships and submarines). Video teleconferencing would be cost-effective on large ships (aircraft carriers and amphibious) only. Teleradiology would be cost-effective on carriers only. Telemedicine's bandwidth requirement is small-1% of a month's time. However, if the ships' medical departments need to resort to a commercial satellite, E-mail and Internet would be the only telemedicine modality generating enough monetary benefits to offset the costs.

Research findings suggest that the value added by the video channel of currently available video conferencing technology is limited to the creation of a social presence of the other party. Almost all clinical information exchange takes place on the audio channel, while the interpersonal interactions (nods, blinks, facial expressions, and body language), which are so important in a face-to-face meeting, may not be adequately captured by the video. Several of our case studies are presented which suggest that, consistent with the social presence role for video, low-cost videophones may be effectively substituted for expensive ISDN-based systems in many mental health applications.

Since the beginning of human space flight, NASA has been placing humans in extreme and remote environments. There are many challenges in maintaining humans in outer space, including the provision of life-support systems, radiation shielding, and countermeasures for minimizing the effect of microgravity. Because astronauts are selected for their health, among other factors, disease and illness are minimized. However, it is still of great importance to have appropriate medical care systems in place to address illness and injury should they occur. With the exception of the Apollo program, exploration of space has been limited to missions that are within several hundred miles of the surface of the Earth. At the drawn of the 21st century and the new millennium, human exploration will be focused on operation of the International Space Station (ISS) and preparation for human missions to Mars. These missions will present inherent risks to human health, and, therefore, appropriate plans must be established to address these challenges and risks. Crews of long-duration missions must become more independent from ground controllers. New systems, protocols, and procedures are currently being perfected. Application of emerging technologies in information systems and telecommunications will be critical to inflight medical care. Application of these technologies through telemedicine will provide crew members access to information, noninvasive procedures for assessing health status, and guidance through the integration of sensors, holography, decision-support systems, and virtual environments. These technologies will also serve as a basis to enhance training and medical education. The design of medical care for space flight should lead to a redesign of the practice of medicine on Earth.

Objective: To evaluate objectively the effect of different bandwidths on the ability to interpret obstetric ultrasound scans transmitted live over a commercial telephone network.

Materials and methods: An integrated services digital network (ISDN) was established from three satellite offices to our central prenatal diagnostic center. In the first half of the study, the network was based on four ISDN channels transmitting at a bandwidth of 256 kbits per second (kbps), while in the second half of the study, this was increased to six ISDN channels transmitting at 384 kbps. A physician trained in obstetric ultrasonography provided an interpretation of fetal anatomy using a live, real-time telemedicine link. A scoring system consisting of 33 anatomic items was used to evaluate image quality objectively. The number of transmissions complicated by motion artifact was also recorded.

Results: One hundred patients had a fetal anatomy survey performed using the 256 kbps system, and these interpretations were compared with those from another group of 100 patients who were examined using the 384 kbps system. Although the visibility of the 33 anatomic items was similar using the two systems, significantly more examinations at 256 kbps were complicated by motion artifact (12% vs. 3%; P = 0.02).

Conclusions: Remote sonographic viewing of fetal anatomy was adequate using both 256 and 384 kbps systems, although motion artifact was significantly more likely to occur using the slower system. This problem may affect the ability of the lower-bandwidth system to allow optimal detection when fetal anomalies are present.

Objective: To present the follow-up findings to a cost-benefit analysis of telemedicine subspecialty services provided between the Powhatan Correctional Center (PCC) of the Virginia Department of Corrections and the Medical College of Virginia Campus of Virginia Commonwealth University (MCV Campus).

Methods: Costs included those of operating the telemedicine system, transportation, litigation avoidance, and the medical care itself.

Results: Over a 12-month study period, the total number of consults completed through telemedicine was 290. The cost per visit of treating inmates at the MCV Campus clinics was $401. The cost per visit of treating inmates at PCC via telemedicine was $387, a net saving of $14 per visit with the use of telemedicine.

Conclusion: As a result of implementing telemedicine, the Department of Corrections for the State of Virginia was able to achieve a cost saving of $14 per visit. Nonmonetary cost savings, such as greater security and increased access to care, should be considered a net benefit as well.

Background: Over the past several years, there has been a resurgence of interest in telemedicine. Despite this renewed interest, some health care providers remain skeptical regarding the effectiveness of telemedicine for the delivery of health care.

Objective: The objective of this prospective, crossover study was to determine if there was any difference between care delivered using video conferencing-based telemedicine technology and that given by a traditional face-to-face encounter in a pulmonary medicine clinic.

Methods: Two pulmonologists sequentially examined 40 individuals via video conferencing-based telemedicine technology and by the traditional face-to-face method. Two additional pulmonologists, in a blinded fashion, compared the results for consistency in the history, examination with focus on auscultation of the lungs, diagnostic impression, and evaluation and treatment plans.

Results: Evaluation of patients by telemedicine was as effective as the traditional mode. The telemedicine physician and the physician examining the patient in the traditional manner were able to elicit the same key complaints and hear the same adventitious sounds on auscultation of the lungs.

Conclusion: Telemedicine can enable the provision of high-quality care in a pulmonary clinic setting.

Objective: To provide and evaluate telemedicine services for rural physicians and patients in Nova Scotia.

Materials and methods: As a pilot project, three telemedicine services (videoconference continuing medical education [CME], teledermatology, and teleradiology) were provided to four hospitals in Nova Scotia communities. All four sites received CME (a total of 269 physicians, 53 other health care professionals); three sites received teledermatology (66 consultations), and two sites received teleradiology (808 radiologic examinations). At the consulting site, 12 faculty members presented 24 one-hour videoconferences, and there was one consulting radiologist and dermatologist. Each service was evaluated independently. Methods included participant questionnaires; focus groups; numbers and categories of participants or examinations; comparison of operational costs, capitol costs (teledermatology and teleradiology), and travel costs (CME); technical assessments of hardware, software, and telecommunications; assessment of clinical diagnostic procedures (teledermatology); and comparative study of original and digitized films (teleradiology).

Results: Despite growing pains, the technologies effectively provided the three services: the services were acceptable to referring and consulting physicians and patients. Improvements in patient care and outcomes comparable to those of traditional methods were demonstrated in teleradiology and teledermatology, especially for emergencies. Physician access to CME and patient access to dermatology consultation services were improved. Financial savings were demonstrated for CME, but further investigation is required to determine the savings attributable to teleradiology and teledermatology.

Conclusions: The telemedicine services supported rural physicians, their patients, and their communities. Although telemedicine is not a panacea for all concerns of rural physicians, the pilot project provided a strong foundation for further development and study.

Objective: To examine the telehealth system as a means of improving access to cardiac consultations and specialized health services in remote areas of Ontario.

Methods: The University of Ottawa Heart Institute has set up a telehealth test program, Healthcare and Education Access for Remote Residents by Telecommunications (HEARRT), in collaboration with industry and the provincial and federal government, as well as several remote clinical test sites. The program makes off-site cardiology consultations possible. History taking and physical examinations are conducted by video and electronic stethoscope. Laboratory results and echocardiograms are transmitted by document camera and VCR. The technology is being tested in both stable outpatient and emergency situations. Various telecommunications bandwidths and encoding systems are being evaluated, including satellite and terrestrial-based asynchronous transfer-mode circuits. Patient satisfaction and cost-effectiveness are also being assessed.

Results: Bandwidths from as low as 384 kbps using H.320 encoders to 40 Mbps using digital transport of NTSC video signals have been evaluated. Although lower bandwidths are sufficient for sending echocardiographic and electrocardiogram data, bandwidths with transport speeds of 4 to 6 Mbps appear necessary to capture the nuances of the cardiac physical examination. A preliminary satisfaction survey of 19 patients noted that all felt that they could communicate effectively with the cardiologist by video, and each had confidence in the advice offered. None reported that he or she would rather have traveled to the doctor in person. Initial and projected examination of the costs suggested that telehealth will effectively reduce overall health care spending while decreasing travel expenses for rural patients.

Conclusion: Telehealth technology is sufficiently sophisticated to allow off-site cardiology assessments. Preliminary results suggest there is a sound business case for the implementation of telehealth technology to meet the needs of remote residents in northern Ontario. Working closely with government and industry, we will develop a marketing and commercialization plan to support the use of this technology throughout Ontario and expand application to patient education and continuing medical education.

Background: Telekid Care is a project that attempts to overcome the health and educational barriers faced by children in urban Kansas City, Kansas. Telemedicine units were placed in school nurses' offices and linked to physicians at the University of Kansas Medical Center (KUMC). This paper describes the development of this project, presents utilization data, and discuss the lessons learned from the application of telemedicine in a school setting.

Results: Project developers spent 11 months designing the protocol and procedures for a pilot test. Four elementary schools participated, and 187 consultations were conducted. The most common reason for consultation was ear, nose, and throat (ENT) problems, making up 28% of all consults. Mandatory school physical examinations and dermatology problems combined to make up an additional 40% of the consults. The average time that elapsed between the request for a consult and confirmation of an appointment was 23 minutes. When immediate service was requested, 85% of the consults occurred the day of the request. These results strongly demonstrate telemedicine's ability to offer immediate service to children in need.

Conclusion: Telemedicine enabled underserved inner-city children to gain access to health services. This service was most effective when it was integrated into the delivery system. Furthermore, community groups strongly favored the project, positively influencing its acceptance as an innovative health care delivery system.