Shumiao Shu, Xiaolu Tang, George Kontsevich, Xiaodan Wang, Wanze Zhu, Yangyi Zhao, Wenzhi Wang, Xiaoxiang Zhao, Zhaoyong Hu
Predicting the growth and maximum biomass (Mmax) of woody plant communities (WPCs) remains a central challenge in terrestrial ecology due to the complex and heterogeneous nature of tree growth. While metabolic scaling theory (MST) provides a valuable conceptual framework, it remains limited in its ability to fully explain community-level growth or carbon dynamics. To address this limitation, we developed an iterative growth model for forests (IGMF), built upon an iterative growth framework grounded in MST's core principles and further incorporating the self-thinning effect. The IGMF and its extensions suggest that community-level growth, net primary productivity (NPP), and other key components of the carbon budget—including gross primary productivity, autotrophic respiration, organ turnover, and non-structural carbohydrate storage—may be approximated as functions of current biomass, biomass-specific maintenance respiration, stand age, or Mmax. These relationships provide a basis for estimating the global Mmax of WPCs during 2018–2020 at approximately 1440 ± 26 Pg (1 Pg = 1 × 1015 g), with an additional biomass potential of about 510 Pg under current conditions. However, machine learning projections suggest that this potential may decline by up to 246 Pg by 2100, primarily within evergreen broadleaf forests. Our analyses also indicate that species richness, by promoting functional convergence, can amplify the negative effects of temperature and precipitation seasonality on Mmax. In contrast, warming in the Northern Hemisphere may favor Mmax accumulation in open shrublands. Together, these results help to clarify the growth dynamics of WPCs and suggest a possible shift in the major contributors to terrestrial carbon sequestration—from forests to shrublands—under future climate scenarios.
{"title":"Metabolic growth mechanisms and theoretical growth potential of global woody plant communities","authors":"Shumiao Shu, Xiaolu Tang, George Kontsevich, Xiaodan Wang, Wanze Zhu, Yangyi Zhao, Wenzhi Wang, Xiaoxiang Zhao, Zhaoyong Hu","doi":"10.1002/ecm.70048","DOIUrl":"10.1002/ecm.70048","url":null,"abstract":"<p>Predicting the growth and maximum biomass (<i>M</i><sub>max</sub>) of woody plant communities (WPCs) remains a central challenge in terrestrial ecology due to the complex and heterogeneous nature of tree growth. While metabolic scaling theory (MST) provides a valuable conceptual framework, it remains limited in its ability to fully explain community-level growth or carbon dynamics. To address this limitation, we developed an iterative growth model for forests (IGMF), built upon an iterative growth framework grounded in MST's core principles and further incorporating the self-thinning effect. The IGMF and its extensions suggest that community-level growth, net primary productivity (NPP), and other key components of the carbon budget—including gross primary productivity, autotrophic respiration, organ turnover, and non-structural carbohydrate storage—may be approximated as functions of current biomass, biomass-specific maintenance respiration, stand age, or <i>M</i><sub>max</sub>. These relationships provide a basis for estimating the global <i>M</i><sub>max</sub> of WPCs during 2018–2020 at approximately 1440 ± 26 Pg (1 Pg = 1 × 10<sup>15</sup> g), with an additional biomass potential of about 510 Pg under current conditions. However, machine learning projections suggest that this potential may decline by up to 246 Pg by 2100, primarily within evergreen broadleaf forests. Our analyses also indicate that species richness, by promoting functional convergence, can amplify the negative effects of temperature and precipitation seasonality on <i>M</i><sub>max</sub>. In contrast, warming in the Northern Hemisphere may favor <i>M</i><sub>max</sub> accumulation in open shrublands. Together, these results help to clarify the growth dynamics of WPCs and suggest a possible shift in the major contributors to terrestrial carbon sequestration—from forests to shrublands—under future climate scenarios.</p>","PeriodicalId":11505,"journal":{"name":"Ecological Monographs","volume":"96 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":7.5,"publicationDate":"2026-02-05","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"146122001","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
N. Thompson Hobbs, Danielle B. Johnston, Kristin N. Marshall, Evan C. Wolf, David J. Cooper
<p>Beschta and colleagues offer a lengthy, wide-ranging critique of Hobbs et al. (<span>2024</span>) in their Comment (Beschta et al., <span>2025</span>). We focus our Reply to Beschta et al. on the overarching issues they raise, that the scope of inference of our paper is not supported by our research and that we failed to adequately consider extensive evidence of a trophic cascade initiated by the restoration of wolves to the food web of the northern range of Yellowstone National Park.</p><p>It is useful to summarize the line of inference developed in the Hobbs et al. monograph. The paper contributes to ecological theory by addressing the core question: “Can the simplification of food webs caused by the removal of apex predators create conditions in the ecosystem that are resilient to the effects of predator restoration?” using the small stream network of Yellowstone's northern range as a model system. The return of a guild of large carnivores to the northern range of Yellowstone after their protracted absence offered an unusually valuable opportunity to address this question. The state of the ecosystem along the network of small streams changed dramatically during the twentieth century as we describe in the section on History. These changes appeared to be initiated by the loss of apex predators from the system. In particular, tall willows were mostly eliminated from stream sides and engineering of streams by beaver ceased. Established ecological theory on hysteresis and the empirical results of Wolf et al. (<span>2007</span>) (summarized in Figures 1, 2, and 3 of Hobbs et al.) motivated two competing hypotheses on the stability of the small stream ecosystem in response to the disturbance created by restoration of top predators to the food web (Figure 5B,C and the section <i>Experimental Design</i>). The first hypothesis specified that the system failed to exhibit hysteresis, that the restoration of apex predators allowed a rapid return of the conditions that prevailed on the small stream network before the removal of apex predators, especially the presence of tall willows (<i>Salix</i> spp.) and engineering by beaver (<i>Castor canadensis</i>). The second, alternative hypothesis was that the removal of apex predators created hysteresis in the system by interrupting the symbiosis of willows and beaver. These hypotheses were tested in a replicated, manipulative experiment and analysis of a set of sites drawn from areas of the small stream network suitable for colonization by beaver. Analysis of two decades of data from this experiment allowed unambiguous rejection of the first hypothesis, leading to the conclusion that the conditions that emerged while predators were absent from streams capable of being engineered by beaver were not quickly reversed by predator restoration. The conclusions of Hobbs et al., <span>2024</span> extended from development of hypotheses motivated by established ecological theory, from our experimental design, and from
Beschta及其同事在他们的评论(Beschta et al., 2025)中对Hobbs et al.(2024)进行了冗长而广泛的批评。我们将回复Beschta等人的重点放在他们提出的首要问题上,即我们的研究不支持我们论文的推断范围,并且我们未能充分考虑黄石国家公园北部地区狼群恢复食物网引发的营养级联的广泛证据。总结霍布斯等人的专著中发展起来的推理路线是有用的。这篇论文以黄石公园北部地区的小河网络为模型系统,通过解决核心问题:“顶端捕食者的消失导致的食物网的简化,能否在生态系统中创造出适应捕食者恢复影响的条件?”从而为生态学理论做出了贡献。一群大型食肉动物在长期消失后重返黄石公园北部地区,为解决这个问题提供了难得的宝贵机会。正如我们在“历史”一节中所描述的那样,沿着小溪网络的生态系统状态在20世纪发生了巨大变化。这些变化似乎是由系统中顶端捕食者的消失引起的。特别是河边的高柳大部分被清除,河狸修筑溪流的工程也停止了。关于滞后性的既定生态学理论和Wolf等人(2007)的实证结果(Hobbs等人的图1、2和3进行了总结)提出了两种相互竞争的假设,即小溪生态系统在应对顶级捕食者恢复对食物网造成的干扰时的稳定性(图5B、C和实验设计部分)。第一个假设指出,该系统没有表现出滞后性,即顶端捕食者的恢复允许在移除顶端捕食者之前在小型河流网络中普遍存在的条件迅速恢复,特别是高柳树(Salix spp.)和海狸工程(Castor canadensis)的存在。第二种假设是,顶端捕食者的消失通过打断柳树和海狸的共生关系,在系统中造成了滞后。这些假设在一项重复的、可操作的实验和分析中得到了验证,这些实验和分析是从适合海狸定居的小河网络区域中抽取的一组地点。对该实验20年数据的分析明确否定了第一个假设,并由此得出结论:当海狸改造的河流中没有捕食者时出现的情况,不会因为捕食者的恢复而迅速逆转。Hobbs et al., 2024的结论来自于由既定生态理论驱动的假设的发展,来自于我们的实验设计,以及我们对实验数据的严格统计分析。Beschta等人根据自己的研究可能不同意这些结论,但在他们的评论中并没有显示Hobbs et al.(2024)的推理路线存在错误。我们强调,我们的推断方法的优势在于,我们评估了关于生态系统(北部山脉的小河网络)如何响应扰动(顶级捕食者的恢复)的替代观点的证据。考虑对状态和过程的不同解释是可靠科学的核心,我们很快就会重新审视这个真理。这一段的其余部分清楚地表明,我们关于“失败”的结论仅限于我们从概念框架中发展出来的其他假设,特别是顶端捕食者的恢复并没有导致麋鹿-草原状态在小溪网络上逆转到海狸-柳树状态,这些想法在我们的图2和相关讨论中得到了详细的证明。Beschta等人断言,我们的推断范围取决于对恢复的任意定义。我们认为这种批评毫无根据。我们在图2中证明了恢复的定义以及与之相关的文本。这个理由没有任何武断之处。Beschta等人还认为,我们的推断应限于我们所研究的小河网络的30%的河段,而不包括历史上没有被海狸占据的地点。从严格的统计意义上讲,这一论点是正确的,但对我们的推断的这种狭隘限制忽略了对海狸工程对生态系统状态和过程的不成比例影响的公认理解(Larsen等人,2021;Naiman & d<s:1> camp, 1997)。海狸局部干扰的影响扩展到整个流域。一个退化的生态系统如果不恢复其干扰状态,就不能被认为是恢复的。Beschta等人的论点。 关于我们的研究设计的过分宽泛的推断是不准确的。Beschta等人写道,在我们的实验中,控制地点被选择为代表“干燥条件”,这扭曲了我们描述选择地点的标准(见实验设计)。此外,正如Beschta等人所写,这些标准同样适用于治疗组和对照组,而不仅仅适用于对照组。他们还认为,我们的实验“……排除了最有弹性、最多样化、最多产的河边地点,在那里,柳树由地下水或高水位支撑,错过了恢复海狸柳树状态的重要过程的关键要素。”我们选择在没有地下水流入溪流造成的高水位的地点工作,这样我们就可以测试水的可用性对柳树生长的重要性,以及模拟海狸结构所复制的海狸造成的干扰制度的作用。此外,许多地下水补给点是泥炭聚集沼泽,而不是河岸生态系统。他们的说法在一定程度上是正确的,但它忽略了我们分析的广泛结果(表2,图14和15),我们表明地下水可用性的低可变性加速了柳树的生长。我们工作的一个新颖贡献是表明迟滞的强度取决于能够支持柳树生长的地下水可用性的景观变异性(图21和相关讨论)。由此可见,我们利用自己的设计,准确地表达了Besctha等人认为我们无法表达的观点。我们显示(图21),在地下水资源丰富的地区,海狸柳树状态会迅速恢复。Beschta等人并没有谈到我们论文的总体目标。我们试图通过考虑顶端捕食者的恢复何时能迅速扭转其损失的影响来推进生态理论,我们称之为互惠效应。我们在图1及其相关的讨论中全面地发展了这些想法,预测简单的食物链将表现出相互作用,而复杂的食物网则不会。我们使用黄石公园作为模型系统来推进这些想法,结果表明我们的结果与预测一致,即由于捕食者的消失而导致的生态系统退化可能不会通过捕食者的恢复而迅速逆转,因为在没有捕食者的情况下发生的生态系统状态和过程的变化,特别是干扰制度的变化,会产生滞后。所有试图利用实证研究来推进理论的研究者都必须描述他们所研究的特定系统如何提供一般见解。读者个人可以判断,我们为推进理论所提供的总体见解是否超过了数据和分析所提供的支持。Beschta等人提出了许多担忧,即我们未能承认大量证据表明狼的重新引入通过营养级联启动了木质落叶植物恢复的轨迹。在我们的辩护中,我们确实回顾了狼群重新引入后小溪沿岸柳树生长的所有研究,包括那些主张营养级联的研究。我们明确指出,这些研究得出的结论与我们的不同。我们提供了这些差异的原因(见我们的论文“与北方地区柳树的其他研究的比较”)。我们没有回顾Beschta等人认为我们应该包括的其他植物群落和脊椎动物消费者的研究,因为我们认为这些研究与我们论文的核心思想无关。然而,忽略这些研究的一个更重要的动机是,我们认为它们提供了不可靠的推断。我们的结论是基于两条思路的推理:实验对因果推理的重要性,以及考虑狼群重新引入后植物生长趋势的替代解释的要求。有一种开创性的假说认为,狼群的重新引入引发了由捕食风险介导的营养级联反应,从而启动了黄石公园北部地区植物群落的恢复(Ripple & Beschta, 2004),这激发了科学家和公众的想象力。这是个好主意。科学用经过验证的方法获得的证据来面对思想,特别是操纵性实验,统计上稳健且设计适当的抽样,认可的分析,以及对状态和过程的竞争性解释的评估。科学往往表明,生态系统的过程比最初认为的要复杂得多。我们的专著增加了大量证据,揭示了狼重新引入黄石公园后发生的事件远比营养级联假说所预期的要复杂得多(Bilyeu等人,2008;Brice等人,2022;Brice, Larsen等人,2025);Creel等人;Christianson, 2009; Eisenberg等人,2013;Kauffman等人。 , 2010;Kohl et al., 2018;
{"title":"Does restoring apex predators to food webs restore ecosystems? Reply","authors":"N. Thompson Hobbs, Danielle B. Johnston, Kristin N. Marshall, Evan C. Wolf, David J. Cooper","doi":"10.1002/ecm.70049","DOIUrl":"10.1002/ecm.70049","url":null,"abstract":"<p>Beschta and colleagues offer a lengthy, wide-ranging critique of Hobbs et al. (<span>2024</span>) in their Comment (Beschta et al., <span>2025</span>). We focus our Reply to Beschta et al. on the overarching issues they raise, that the scope of inference of our paper is not supported by our research and that we failed to adequately consider extensive evidence of a trophic cascade initiated by the restoration of wolves to the food web of the northern range of Yellowstone National Park.</p><p>It is useful to summarize the line of inference developed in the Hobbs et al. monograph. The paper contributes to ecological theory by addressing the core question: “Can the simplification of food webs caused by the removal of apex predators create conditions in the ecosystem that are resilient to the effects of predator restoration?” using the small stream network of Yellowstone's northern range as a model system. The return of a guild of large carnivores to the northern range of Yellowstone after their protracted absence offered an unusually valuable opportunity to address this question. The state of the ecosystem along the network of small streams changed dramatically during the twentieth century as we describe in the section on History. These changes appeared to be initiated by the loss of apex predators from the system. In particular, tall willows were mostly eliminated from stream sides and engineering of streams by beaver ceased. Established ecological theory on hysteresis and the empirical results of Wolf et al. (<span>2007</span>) (summarized in Figures 1, 2, and 3 of Hobbs et al.) motivated two competing hypotheses on the stability of the small stream ecosystem in response to the disturbance created by restoration of top predators to the food web (Figure 5B,C and the section <i>Experimental Design</i>). The first hypothesis specified that the system failed to exhibit hysteresis, that the restoration of apex predators allowed a rapid return of the conditions that prevailed on the small stream network before the removal of apex predators, especially the presence of tall willows (<i>Salix</i> spp.) and engineering by beaver (<i>Castor canadensis</i>). The second, alternative hypothesis was that the removal of apex predators created hysteresis in the system by interrupting the symbiosis of willows and beaver. These hypotheses were tested in a replicated, manipulative experiment and analysis of a set of sites drawn from areas of the small stream network suitable for colonization by beaver. Analysis of two decades of data from this experiment allowed unambiguous rejection of the first hypothesis, leading to the conclusion that the conditions that emerged while predators were absent from streams capable of being engineered by beaver were not quickly reversed by predator restoration. The conclusions of Hobbs et al., <span>2024</span> extended from development of hypotheses motivated by established ecological theory, from our experimental design, and from ","PeriodicalId":11505,"journal":{"name":"Ecological Monographs","volume":"96 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":7.5,"publicationDate":"2026-02-03","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/ecm.70049","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"146122003","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"OA","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Robert L. Beschta, Luke E. Painter, William J. Ripple, J. Boone Kauffman
<p>Trophic cascades, which represent the indirect effects of predators that extend downward through multiple trophic levels and food webs, have gained significant recognition in the scientific community (Ripple et al., <span>2016</span>; Terborgh & Estes, <span>2010</span>). In northern Yellowstone's ungulate winter range, or northern range, intensive herbivory by Rocky Mountain elk (<i>Cervus canadensis</i>) was a dominant force across the landscape during the seven decades when gray wolves (<i>Canis lupus</i>) were absent, suppressing the growth of deciduous woody plants and affecting the availability of resources and physical habitat for other species (Barmore, <span>2003</span>; Jonas, <span>1955</span>; Kay, <span>1990</span>). However, following the 1995–1996 reintroduction of wolves, thus completing the park's large carnivore guild, studies of willows (<i>Salix</i> spp.) in the northern range reported that some of them were again growing taller due to a decrease in herbivory—a trophic cascade resulting from large carnivore restoration (e.g., Baril et al., <span>2011</span>; Beyer et al., <span>2007</span>).</p><p>Hobbs et al. (<span>2024</span>), hereafter referred to as Hobbs et al., conducted research to evaluate the effects of a restored large carnivore guild on willow dynamics by studying their heights over time in northern Yellowstone riparian zones and concluded that apex predator restoration was unsuccessful in restoring riparian willow communities. This conclusion relied on a narrow and arbitrary definition of a trophic cascade and restoration success. Specifically, they indicated that since tall willows were largely lost from the northern range within two decades following apex predator loss, a similarly abrupt recovery of tall willows following apex predator restoration was necessary for evidence of a trophic cascade and willow restoration. We demonstrate, based on published research, that a trophic cascade in northern Yellowstone is reversing the effects of large predator loss to multiple taxa and food webs. Although specific historical conditions in riparian areas have not been fully replicated or restored, important ecological processes have been changed and a trajectory of ecosystem restoration is underway.</p><p>Hobbs et al. conducted their 20-year study (2001–2020) of willows growing on riparian floodplains and terraces along streams in the park's northern range. Based on those results and their interpretation of what constitutes restoration, they developed far-reaching conclusions: “Our two decades of research revealed that the restoration of apex predators to a food web after a long absence <i>failed to reverse the effects of their loss from the food web</i>” (p. 18). At face value, their comments would lead readers to believe the restored large carnivore guild has had little, if any, influence on the ecosystem structure and function of northern Yellowstone's riparian areas.</p><p>Hobbs et al. (p. 27) indicated a numb
营养级联,代表了捕食者通过多个营养水平和食物网向下延伸的间接影响,已经在科学界得到了显著的认可(Ripple et al., 2016; Terborgh & Estes, 2010)。在黄石公园北部的有蹄类冬季区或北部区,落基山麋鹿(Cervus canadensis)的密集食草在灰狼(Canis lupus)缺席的70年里是整个景观的主导力量,抑制了落叶木本植物的生长,影响了其他物种的资源和自然栖息地的可用性(Barmore, 2003; Jonas, 1955; Kay, 1990)。然而,随着1995-1996年狼群的重新引入,从而完成了公园的大型食肉动物协会,对北部地区柳树(Salix spp.)的研究报告称,由于食草动物的减少,其中一些柳树又长得更高了——这是大型食肉动物恢复造成的营养级联(例如,Baril et al., 2011; Beyer et al., 2007)。Hobbs et al.(2024)(以下简称Hobbs et al.)通过研究黄石公园北部河岸地带的柳树高度随时间的变化,研究了大型食肉动物群落恢复后对柳树动态的影响,并得出结论:顶端捕食者恢复对河岸柳树群落的恢复是不成功的。这一结论依赖于对营养级联和恢复成功的狭隘和武断的定义。具体来说,他们指出,由于在顶端捕食者消失后的20年内,北方地区的高柳大量消失,因此在顶端捕食者恢复后,高柳的类似突然恢复是营养级联和柳树恢复的必要证据。根据已发表的研究,我们证明黄石公园北部的营养级联正在逆转大型捕食者减少对多个分类群和食物网的影响。虽然沿岸区特定的历史条件还没有完全复制或恢复,但重要的生态过程已经改变,生态系统正在恢复。Hobbs等人进行了为期20年的研究(2001-2020),研究对象是生长在公园北部河流沿岸洪泛平原和梯田上的柳树。基于这些结果和他们对什么是恢复的解释,他们得出了影响深远的结论:“我们二十年的研究表明,在食物网长期消失后,顶端捕食者恢复到食物网并不能扭转它们从食物网中消失的影响”(第18页)。从表面上看,他们的评论会让读者相信,恢复的大型食肉动物协会对黄石公园北部河岸地区的生态系统结构和功能几乎没有影响。Hobbs等人(第27页)指出,许多研究声称,随着灰狼的回归,黄石公园北部的生态系统已经恢复,进一步表明这种说法可能是错误的或夸大的。然而,最近对Hobbs等人确定的7项黄石研究的评估发现,没有一项研究声称黄石北部生态系统已恢复到以前的状态(Beschta等人,2023);因此,霍布斯等人批评他们没有主张的东西。虽然未来不太可能复制过去,但北部山脉的研究已经并将继续显示出由营养级联引起的重要植被变化的证据,这有助于河岸地区和生态系统的其他方面的生态恢复(见Beschta &; Ripple, 2016; Ripple & Beschta, 2012)。即便如此,考虑到数十年来麋鹿密集的草食对河岸植物群落及其溪流通道的影响程度,以及与气候变化(Beschta & Ripple, 2016)和野牛种群激增(bison bison)相关的新限制,生态系统的恢复仍需要时间(Beschta等人,2020;Kauffman等人,2022;Painter等人,2023)。Hobbs等人以及他们之前发表的研究的主要结论是,柳树生长在相对干燥的河岸洪泛平原和与切割河道相关的梯田上,需要海狸完全恢复以前允许这些植物在那里生存的水文环境。我们会注意到,恢复海狸柳树的状态通常是一个四个阶段的过程:(1)必须减少柳树被压制的历史原因,即长期密集的有蹄类动物的使用;(2)柳树与白杨(Populus tremuloides)和其他落叶木本树种一起,可以生长成高大的灌木丛,能够养活海狸;(3)河狸回巢筑坝,扩大柳树生境;(4)这种扩大的栖息地能够支持后代的海狸。事实上,对河岸植被的各种研究,包括Hobbs等人的研究。 研究表明,随着大型食肉动物的恢复和麋鹿食草动物的减少,所有这些阶段都出现在黄石公园北部的一些地区。我们认为,这些变化具有重要的生态意义,霍布斯等人认为这种复杂情况是恢复失败,营养级联无效的结论是不正确的。事实上,恰恰相反。最近一项评估柳树树冠体积变化的分析提供了另一个挑战霍布斯等人断言的例子,即黄石公园北部地区的营养级联实验是失败的。在该分析中,Ripple et al.(2025)利用Cooper and Hobbs(2023)的2001-2020年柳树高度数据估算了单个柳树树冠体积的时间变化。由于柳树树冠生物量和树冠体积高度相关(Yao et al., 2021),任何树冠体积的增加都是生物量变化的合理替代指标,生物量变化通常用于评估营养级联的强度。Ripple等人(2025)的分析结果表明,柳树树冠体积增加了1500%(图1),这一效应大于Borer等人(2005)在荟萃分析中总结的绝大多数营养级联研究。Hobbs等人假设,海狸消失后,河道的切断即使减少了草食性,也会阻止柳树的恢复,并认为这是对顶端捕食者恢复有弹性的另一种稳定状态。Hobbs等人研究的核心是选择四个有柳树、历史上有海狸存在的河岸遗址和一个切割的河道。在每个地点,建立了一个对照地块,在那里有蹄动物可以接触到柳树。还建立了三个处理地块(即:(1)围栏以防止有蹄类草食,(2)河道内水坝以提高地下水位,(3)围栏和水坝),这些处理有望提高柳树的生长率。在他们的实验过程中,处理地块内的许多柳树长到了恢复群落的预期高度(即平均高度≥200厘米,见Marshall et al., 2013)。相比之下,经历环境条件(即对照地块)的柳树高度增加较少。因为对照地点是在干燥、切割的条件下选择的,所以用它们来代表黄石公园北部柳树地点的“环境条件”是不合适的。还根据有限的标准选择了其他“观测地点”。即使在选址方面存在这些限制,到2020年,Hobbs等人的对照和观测站点中,近30%的柳树平均高度≥200 cm,其余许多站点呈上升趋势。考虑到“环境”地点的平均柳树高度持续上升的趋势,如果研究再持续几年,似乎在其他地点可能会超过200厘米的阈值。因此,即使对于这些相对干燥的柳树场地,仅根据这个高度阈值得出恢复失败的结论似乎是武断和过早的。Hobbs等人指出,退化生态系统的恢复可能是复杂的,从麋鹿-草原到海狸-柳树状态的演替路径可能表现出滞后性,我们同意这一结论。根据数十年来有蹄类动物的密集使用和海狸的减少对植被和河道的影响程度,生态系统的恢复可能采取各种途径,可能不会很快恢复到历史上存在的确切条件。因此,我们认为Hobbs等人认为目前只有完全恢复的海狸-柳树状态才能作为恢复成功的主要衡量标准,这是一种过于简单的视角,用于评估整个公园河岸地区的营养级联效应和恢复过程,并低估了目前正在进行的许多大型食肉动物的级联营养效应。Hobbs等人关于缺乏恢复成功的结论与观察到的Blacktail Deer Creek沿岸的变化(图1)以及他们自己的数据不一致。这也与大型食肉动物恢复后各种植被实地研究的广泛证据不一致。在狼重新引入后的二十年里,对北部地区河岸地带落叶植物的24项研究进行了综合(Beschta & Ripple, 2016
{"title":"Does restoring apex predators to food webs restore ecosystems? Comment","authors":"Robert L. Beschta, Luke E. Painter, William J. Ripple, J. Boone Kauffman","doi":"10.1002/ecm.70050","DOIUrl":"10.1002/ecm.70050","url":null,"abstract":"<p>Trophic cascades, which represent the indirect effects of predators that extend downward through multiple trophic levels and food webs, have gained significant recognition in the scientific community (Ripple et al., <span>2016</span>; Terborgh & Estes, <span>2010</span>). In northern Yellowstone's ungulate winter range, or northern range, intensive herbivory by Rocky Mountain elk (<i>Cervus canadensis</i>) was a dominant force across the landscape during the seven decades when gray wolves (<i>Canis lupus</i>) were absent, suppressing the growth of deciduous woody plants and affecting the availability of resources and physical habitat for other species (Barmore, <span>2003</span>; Jonas, <span>1955</span>; Kay, <span>1990</span>). However, following the 1995–1996 reintroduction of wolves, thus completing the park's large carnivore guild, studies of willows (<i>Salix</i> spp.) in the northern range reported that some of them were again growing taller due to a decrease in herbivory—a trophic cascade resulting from large carnivore restoration (e.g., Baril et al., <span>2011</span>; Beyer et al., <span>2007</span>).</p><p>Hobbs et al. (<span>2024</span>), hereafter referred to as Hobbs et al., conducted research to evaluate the effects of a restored large carnivore guild on willow dynamics by studying their heights over time in northern Yellowstone riparian zones and concluded that apex predator restoration was unsuccessful in restoring riparian willow communities. This conclusion relied on a narrow and arbitrary definition of a trophic cascade and restoration success. Specifically, they indicated that since tall willows were largely lost from the northern range within two decades following apex predator loss, a similarly abrupt recovery of tall willows following apex predator restoration was necessary for evidence of a trophic cascade and willow restoration. We demonstrate, based on published research, that a trophic cascade in northern Yellowstone is reversing the effects of large predator loss to multiple taxa and food webs. Although specific historical conditions in riparian areas have not been fully replicated or restored, important ecological processes have been changed and a trajectory of ecosystem restoration is underway.</p><p>Hobbs et al. conducted their 20-year study (2001–2020) of willows growing on riparian floodplains and terraces along streams in the park's northern range. Based on those results and their interpretation of what constitutes restoration, they developed far-reaching conclusions: “Our two decades of research revealed that the restoration of apex predators to a food web after a long absence <i>failed to reverse the effects of their loss from the food web</i>” (p. 18). At face value, their comments would lead readers to believe the restored large carnivore guild has had little, if any, influence on the ecosystem structure and function of northern Yellowstone's riparian areas.</p><p>Hobbs et al. (p. 27) indicated a numb","PeriodicalId":11505,"journal":{"name":"Ecological Monographs","volume":"96 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":7.5,"publicationDate":"2026-02-03","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/ecm.70050","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"146122002","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"OA","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Colin T. Kremer, Mridul K. Thomas, Christopher A. Klausmeier, Elena Litchman
Temperature and resources are fundamental factors that determine the ability of organisms to function and survive, while influencing their individual and population growth. Major bodies of ecological theory have emerged, largely independently, to address temperature and resource effects. It remains a pressing challenge to unite these ideas and determine the interactive effects of temperature and resources on ecological patterns and processes, and their consequences across ecological scales. Here, we propose a simple, physiologically motivated model capturing the interactive effects of temperature and resources (specifically, inorganic nutrients and light) on the growth of microbial ectotherms over multiple ecological scales. From this model we derive a set of key predictions. At the population level, we predict (1) interactive effects of resource limitation on thermal traits (parameters describing effects of temperature on growth), (2) consistent differences in the temperature sensitivity of auto- and heterotrophs, and (3) the existence of specific trade-offs between traits that determine the shape of thermal performance curves. At the community level, we derive predictions for (4) how limitation by nutrients and light can change the relationship between temperature and productivity. All four predictions are upheld, based on our analyses of a large compilation of laboratory data on microbial growth, as well as field experiments with marine phytoplankton communities. Collectively, our modeling framework provides a new way of thinking about the interplay between two fundamental aspects of life—temperature and resources—and how they constrain and structure ecological properties across scales. Providing links between population and community responses to simultaneous changes in abiotic factors is essential to anticipating the multifaceted effects of global change.
{"title":"How interactions between temperature and resources scale from populations to communities in microbes","authors":"Colin T. Kremer, Mridul K. Thomas, Christopher A. Klausmeier, Elena Litchman","doi":"10.1002/ecm.70045","DOIUrl":"10.1002/ecm.70045","url":null,"abstract":"<p>Temperature and resources are fundamental factors that determine the ability of organisms to function and survive, while influencing their individual and population growth. Major bodies of ecological theory have emerged, largely independently, to address temperature and resource effects. It remains a pressing challenge to unite these ideas and determine the interactive effects of temperature and resources on ecological patterns and processes, and their consequences across ecological scales. Here, we propose a simple, physiologically motivated model capturing the interactive effects of temperature and resources (specifically, inorganic nutrients and light) on the growth of microbial ectotherms over multiple ecological scales. From this model we derive a set of key predictions. At the population level, we predict (1) interactive effects of resource limitation on thermal traits (parameters describing effects of temperature on growth), (2) consistent differences in the temperature sensitivity of auto- and heterotrophs, and (3) the existence of specific trade-offs between traits that determine the shape of thermal performance curves. At the community level, we derive predictions for (4) how limitation by nutrients and light can change the relationship between temperature and productivity. All four predictions are upheld, based on our analyses of a large compilation of laboratory data on microbial growth, as well as field experiments with marine phytoplankton communities. Collectively, our modeling framework provides a new way of thinking about the interplay between two fundamental aspects of life—temperature and resources—and how they constrain and structure ecological properties across scales. Providing links between population and community responses to simultaneous changes in abiotic factors is essential to anticipating the multifaceted effects of global change.</p>","PeriodicalId":11505,"journal":{"name":"Ecological Monographs","volume":"95 4","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":7.5,"publicationDate":"2025-12-04","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/ecm.70045","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145664623","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"OA","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Nerea Montes-Perez, Francisco P. Molina, Ignasi Bartomeus
Climate change is altering the phenology of interacting species, potentially leading to mismatches in the timing of their interactions. This may affect the delivery of key ecosystem services such as pollination. Temperature-mediated phenological variation has been widely studied at the species level, showing that increased temperatures lead to earlier activity periods for both plant flowering and pollinator emergence. However, some classic examples of tracked interacting pairs show that phenological mismatches can occur between plants and pollinators. Even though plants and pollinators are embedded in complex interaction networks, it remains unclear how phenological shifts scale up to the community level and what role biodiversity may play in buffering negative outcomes. We analyzed an 8-year time series of plant and pollinator seasonal abundances across 12 Mediterranean scrublands increasingly affected by drought and extreme temperatures, focusing on the subset of common species whose phenology could be reliably described each year. Our aim is to understand how climate change has altered plant–pollinator interactions from the species to the community level. We found that plants and pollinators have been advancing their phenologies over time at similar rates, with an average advance of 5 days per decade. Changes in rainfall and temperature patterns are key drivers of these advances. Despite the congruent shifts and no consistent change in pairwise phenological overlap, total overlap between each species and its potential partners has slightly declined over time. While more diverse communities show higher potential overlap, biodiversity is not directly buffering the reduction in interaction overlap in the studied rich communities. However, in silico experiments show that the buffering effect of biodiversity becomes apparent at lower diversity levels (i.e., fewer than 10 species). In the context of ongoing climate change, protecting diverse communities with high interaction overlap is crucial, as phenological shifts may gradually erode network structure in Mediterranean plant–pollinator systems. Sustained long-term data collection is also essential to understand the fate of most species, including those whose low abundances may conceal early signs of biodiversity loss.
{"title":"Generalized plant–pollinator phenological climate-driven advances still lead to a decline in phenological overlap","authors":"Nerea Montes-Perez, Francisco P. Molina, Ignasi Bartomeus","doi":"10.1002/ecm.70046","DOIUrl":"10.1002/ecm.70046","url":null,"abstract":"<p>Climate change is altering the phenology of interacting species, potentially leading to mismatches in the timing of their interactions. This may affect the delivery of key ecosystem services such as pollination. Temperature-mediated phenological variation has been widely studied at the species level, showing that increased temperatures lead to earlier activity periods for both plant flowering and pollinator emergence. However, some classic examples of tracked interacting pairs show that phenological mismatches can occur between plants and pollinators. Even though plants and pollinators are embedded in complex interaction networks, it remains unclear how phenological shifts scale up to the community level and what role biodiversity may play in buffering negative outcomes. We analyzed an 8-year time series of plant and pollinator seasonal abundances across 12 Mediterranean scrublands increasingly affected by drought and extreme temperatures, focusing on the subset of common species whose phenology could be reliably described each year. Our aim is to understand how climate change has altered plant–pollinator interactions from the species to the community level. We found that plants and pollinators have been advancing their phenologies over time at similar rates, with an average advance of 5 days per decade. Changes in rainfall and temperature patterns are key drivers of these advances. Despite the congruent shifts and no consistent change in pairwise phenological overlap, total overlap between each species and its potential partners has slightly declined over time. While more diverse communities show higher potential overlap, biodiversity is not directly buffering the reduction in interaction overlap in the studied rich communities. However, in silico experiments show that the buffering effect of biodiversity becomes apparent at lower diversity levels (i.e., fewer than 10 species). In the context of ongoing climate change, protecting diverse communities with high interaction overlap is crucial, as phenological shifts may gradually erode network structure in Mediterranean plant–pollinator systems. Sustained long-term data collection is also essential to understand the fate of most species, including those whose low abundances may conceal early signs of biodiversity loss.</p>","PeriodicalId":11505,"journal":{"name":"Ecological Monographs","volume":"95 4","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":7.5,"publicationDate":"2025-11-30","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/ecm.70046","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145619639","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"OA","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Alexis R. Stansfield, Robert K. Booth, Julie Loisel, Philip Camill, Zicheng Yu, Zhengyu Xia, Alyssa Gengaro, Ava Scally
Observations on the North Slope of Alaska have revealed patches of Sphagnum peat within the widespread matrix of tussock tundra on mineral soils. Little is known about the developmental history of these Sphagnum patches and whether they represent incipient peatlands established in response to warming-related environmental changes. Nine peat cores were collected from nine Sphagnum-dominated peat patches spanning an approximately 300-km longitudinal gradient on the North Slope to determine their development and establishment history. Stratigraphically constrained cluster analysis was applied to plant macrofossil data, carbon-to-nitrogen ratios, and total organic matter measured from bulk peat to delineate developmental phases, and radiocarbon dating was used to constrain the timing of Sphagnum peat patch establishment. We compared these data to changes in testate amoeba community composition and amoeba-inferred water-table depth and pH in six of the peat cores. We also compared Sphagnum peat-patch development and establishment history to paleoclimate and local instrumental temperature records. Results indicated a predictable pattern that describes the transition from moist tussock tundra to Sphagnum peat. Furthermore, although Sphagnum has been present on the North Slope for millennia, our data suggest that Sphagnum-dominated peat patches constitute recent landscape features, mainly established in the 1800s and 1900s, and with rapidly increasing Sphagnum abundance in the past 50 years. Sphagnum expansion was associated with pronounced changes in testate amoeba communities, including an increase in mixotrophic taxa and species associated with densely growing Sphagnum, and community changes consistent with drying and increased acidity. The recent development of Sphagnum-dominated peat patches has been associated with warming air and soil temperatures, active layer deepening, and earlier snowmelt. Sphagnum expansion has also been observed in other arctic regions, and understanding the extent and growth potential of Sphagnum peat patches has implications for understanding and anticipating changes in carbon cycling, edaphic conditions, permafrost thermal regimes, and floristic diversity.
{"title":"Recent Sphagnum expansion into the tundra on the North Slope of Alaska","authors":"Alexis R. Stansfield, Robert K. Booth, Julie Loisel, Philip Camill, Zicheng Yu, Zhengyu Xia, Alyssa Gengaro, Ava Scally","doi":"10.1002/ecm.70042","DOIUrl":"10.1002/ecm.70042","url":null,"abstract":"<p>Observations on the North Slope of Alaska have revealed patches of <i>Sphagnum</i> peat within the widespread matrix of tussock tundra on mineral soils. Little is known about the developmental history of these <i>Sphagnum</i> patches and whether they represent incipient peatlands established in response to warming-related environmental changes. Nine peat cores were collected from nine <i>Sphagnum</i>-dominated peat patches spanning an approximately 300-km longitudinal gradient on the North Slope to determine their development and establishment history. Stratigraphically constrained cluster analysis was applied to plant macrofossil data, carbon-to-nitrogen ratios, and total organic matter measured from bulk peat to delineate developmental phases, and radiocarbon dating was used to constrain the timing of <i>Sphagnum</i> peat patch establishment. We compared these data to changes in testate amoeba community composition and amoeba-inferred water-table depth and pH in six of the peat cores. We also compared <i>Sphagnum</i> peat-patch development and establishment history to paleoclimate and local instrumental temperature records. Results indicated a predictable pattern that describes the transition from moist tussock tundra to <i>Sphagnum</i> peat. Furthermore, although <i>Sphagnum</i> has been present on the North Slope for millennia, our data suggest that <i>Sphagnum</i>-dominated peat patches constitute recent landscape features, mainly established in the 1800s and 1900s, and with rapidly increasing <i>Sphagnum</i> abundance in the past 50 years. <i>Sphagnum</i> expansion was associated with pronounced changes in testate amoeba communities, including an increase in mixotrophic taxa and species associated with densely growing <i>Sphagnum,</i> and community changes consistent with drying and increased acidity. The recent development of <i>Sphagnum</i>-dominated peat patches has been associated with warming air and soil temperatures, active layer deepening, and earlier snowmelt. <i>Sphagnum</i> expansion has also been observed in other arctic regions, and understanding the extent and growth potential of <i>Sphagnum</i> peat patches has implications for understanding and anticipating changes in carbon cycling, edaphic conditions, permafrost thermal regimes, and floristic diversity.</p>","PeriodicalId":11505,"journal":{"name":"Ecological Monographs","volume":"95 4","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":7.5,"publicationDate":"2025-11-28","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/ecm.70042","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145610939","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"OA","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Emilian S. Kihwele, Matthew C. Hutchinson, Damari S. Nassary, John R. Hongoa, J. Grant C. Hopcraft, Han Olff, Robert M. Pringle, Michiel P. Veldhuis
The enchanting diversity of large mammalian herbivores in African savannas has long challenged ecologists: How can so many species of large, generalist plant eaters coexist? Variation in body size and craniofacial/dental anatomy are key morphological determinants of ecological niche differentiation, shaping foraging behavior in ways that stabilize coexistence by limiting interspecific competition for space and food. Variation in water requirements may be another important dimension of niche differentiation, but whether and how variability in water requirements affects the partitioning of other resources is unknown. Here, we investigate how body size, dental morphology, and water requirements interactively affect space use and diet of 15 large-herbivore species in Serengeti National Park. Water requirements predicted space use in relation to permanent water sources, while diet type (percentage grass) was best predicted by dental morphology. Food partitioning was best predicted by a combination of all three traits in both wet and dry seasons. Furthermore, the total explained variation of diet dissimilarity explained almost tripled when these three traits were combined compared to single traits, emphasizing the importance of multiple dimensions of niche differentiation. Our results show that variation in water requirements is strongly associated with spatial and dietary niche differentiation among large herbivores, emphasizing the importance of spatial heterogeneity in surface water and vegetation structure for maintaining the world's last mega-diverse megafaunal assemblages. Integrating multiple dimensions of resource partitioning is a crucial step toward predicting how species will respond to homogenization of savanna landscapes due to changes in land use, surface water availability, and rainfall.
{"title":"Multidimensional resource partitioning by Serengeti herbivores","authors":"Emilian S. Kihwele, Matthew C. Hutchinson, Damari S. Nassary, John R. Hongoa, J. Grant C. Hopcraft, Han Olff, Robert M. Pringle, Michiel P. Veldhuis","doi":"10.1002/ecm.70044","DOIUrl":"10.1002/ecm.70044","url":null,"abstract":"<p>The enchanting diversity of large mammalian herbivores in African savannas has long challenged ecologists: How can so many species of large, generalist plant eaters coexist? Variation in body size and craniofacial/dental anatomy are key morphological determinants of ecological niche differentiation, shaping foraging behavior in ways that stabilize coexistence by limiting interspecific competition for space and food. Variation in water requirements may be another important dimension of niche differentiation, but whether and how variability in water requirements affects the partitioning of other resources is unknown. Here, we investigate how body size, dental morphology, and water requirements interactively affect space use and diet of 15 large-herbivore species in Serengeti National Park. Water requirements predicted space use in relation to permanent water sources, while diet type (percentage grass) was best predicted by dental morphology. Food partitioning was best predicted by a combination of all three traits in both wet and dry seasons. Furthermore, the total explained variation of diet dissimilarity explained almost tripled when these three traits were combined compared to single traits, emphasizing the importance of multiple dimensions of niche differentiation. Our results show that variation in water requirements is strongly associated with spatial and dietary niche differentiation among large herbivores, emphasizing the importance of spatial heterogeneity in surface water and vegetation structure for maintaining the world's last mega-diverse megafaunal assemblages. Integrating multiple dimensions of resource partitioning is a crucial step toward predicting how species will respond to homogenization of savanna landscapes due to changes in land use, surface water availability, and rainfall.</p>","PeriodicalId":11505,"journal":{"name":"Ecological Monographs","volume":"95 4","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":7.5,"publicationDate":"2025-11-24","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/ecm.70044","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145593526","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"OA","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Gaigai Ding, Wenjing Zeng, Tao Yan, Lijuan Sun, Weile Chen, Mingzhen Lu, Zeqing Ma
Plant nutrient foraging depends on roots and mycorrhizal fungi, which are affected by plant carbon (C) investment and soil nutrient availability. The C supply for root metabolism and associated fungi might be diminished as the host plant size or age increases, while the quality and quantity of soil nitrogen (N) change with forest age. There is still no holistic understanding of how the organization of belowground mycorrhizal root structure and fungi in the nutrient acquisition continuum shifts with forest age and soil resources, which restrains our understanding of the functional relations among roots, fungi, and soil. Here, we examined shifts in the absorptive root, mycorrhizal strategies, and soil-associated fungal community compositions after 9 years of nitrogen manipulation (0, 20, and 50 kg N ha−1 year−1) in temperate larch forests across three age cohorts (11, 20, and 45 years). We found that the effect of forest age on root and fungal traits outweighs that of nitrogen treatment. Specifically, with increasing forest tree age, root respiration and specific root length decreased, while protective investments such as tissue density and phenolics increased. Meanwhile, the proportion of ectomycorrhizal fungi of the long-distance exploration type decreased, but those of the short-distance exploration type increased. Together, these patterns suggest a forest age-mediated nutrient acquisition continuum spanning from “explorative roots with long-distance exploration types” to “conservative roots with short-distance exploration types.” We propose that this nutrient acquisition continuum is functionally constrained by the “size vs. rate” trade-off between the root architecture and root segment metabolism, and the “roots vs. mycorrhizal fungi” complementarity between root architecture and mycorrhizal exploration types. Our results suggest that forest age explains shifts in systemic functional trade-offs in root architecture, root segment metabolism, and mycorrhizal exploration types.
植物的养分取食依赖于根和菌根真菌,而根和菌根真菌受植物碳(C)投入和土壤养分有效性的影响。根系代谢和相关真菌的碳供应可能随着寄主植株大小或林龄的增加而减少,而土壤氮的质量和数量则随林龄的变化而变化。对于地下菌根结构和真菌在养分获取连续体中的组织如何随着林龄和土壤资源的变化而变化,目前还没有全面的认识,这限制了我们对根、真菌和土壤之间功能关系的认识。在这里,我们研究了在温带落叶松森林中,经过9年的氮处理(0、20和50 kg N ha−1年−1年)后,吸收根、菌根策略和土壤相关真菌群落组成的变化,这些变化涉及三个年龄组(11、20和45岁)。我们发现林龄对根系和真菌性状的影响大于氮处理的影响。随着树龄的增加,根系呼吸和比根长度减少,而组织密度和酚类物质等保护性投资增加。与此同时,长距离勘探类型的外生菌根真菌比例下降,而近距离勘探类型的外生菌根真菌比例增加。总之,这些模式表明了森林年龄介导的营养获取连续体,从“具有长距离勘探类型的探索性根系”到“具有短距离勘探类型的保守性根系”。我们认为,这种营养获取连续体在功能上受到根结构和根段代谢之间的“大小与速率”权衡,以及根结构和菌根探索类型之间的“根与菌根真菌”互补的制约。我们的研究结果表明,森林年龄解释了根系结构、根段代谢和菌根探索类型的系统功能权衡的变化。
{"title":"Root-mycorrhizal foraging strategies shift with forest age more than with nitrogen manipulation","authors":"Gaigai Ding, Wenjing Zeng, Tao Yan, Lijuan Sun, Weile Chen, Mingzhen Lu, Zeqing Ma","doi":"10.1002/ecm.70039","DOIUrl":"10.1002/ecm.70039","url":null,"abstract":"<p>Plant nutrient foraging depends on roots and mycorrhizal fungi, which are affected by plant carbon (C) investment and soil nutrient availability. The C supply for root metabolism and associated fungi might be diminished as the host plant size or age increases, while the quality and quantity of soil nitrogen (N) change with forest age. There is still no holistic understanding of how the organization of belowground mycorrhizal root structure and fungi in the nutrient acquisition continuum shifts with forest age and soil resources, which restrains our understanding of the functional relations among roots, fungi, and soil. Here, we examined shifts in the absorptive root, mycorrhizal strategies, and soil-associated fungal community compositions after 9 years of nitrogen manipulation (0, 20, and 50 kg N ha<sup>−1</sup> year<sup>−1</sup>) in temperate larch forests across three age cohorts (11, 20, and 45 years). We found that the effect of forest age on root and fungal traits outweighs that of nitrogen treatment. Specifically, with increasing forest tree age, root respiration and specific root length decreased, while protective investments such as tissue density and phenolics increased. Meanwhile, the proportion of ectomycorrhizal fungi of the long-distance exploration type decreased, but those of the short-distance exploration type increased. Together, these patterns suggest a forest age-mediated nutrient acquisition continuum spanning from “explorative roots with long-distance exploration types” to “conservative roots with short-distance exploration types.” We propose that this nutrient acquisition continuum is functionally constrained by the “size vs. rate” trade-off between the root architecture and root segment metabolism, and the “roots vs. mycorrhizal fungi” complementarity between root architecture and mycorrhizal exploration types. Our results suggest that forest age explains shifts in systemic functional trade-offs in root architecture, root segment metabolism, and mycorrhizal exploration types.</p>","PeriodicalId":11505,"journal":{"name":"Ecological Monographs","volume":"95 4","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":7.5,"publicationDate":"2025-11-12","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/ecm.70039","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145492009","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"OA","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Lisa Buche, Lauren G. Shoemaker, Peter Vesk, Lauren M. Hallett, Oscar Godoy, Margaret Mayfield
The ability of species to form diverse communities is not fully understood. Species are known to interact in various ways with their neighborhood. Despite this, common phenomenological models of species coexistence assume that per capita interactions are constant and competitive, even as the environment changes. In this study, we investigate how neighbor density-dependent variation in the strength and sign of species interactions changes species and community dynamics. We demonstrate that incorporating these sources of variation significantly improves predictions of ecological dynamics compared to the outcomes of typical models, which hold interaction strengths constant. We compared the performance of models based on different functions of neighbor density and identity in describing population trajectories (i.e., persistence over time) and community dynamics (i.e., temporal stability, synchrony, and degree of oscillation) in simulated two-species communities and a real, diverse annual plant system. In our simulated communities, we observed the highest level of coexistence between species pairs when species interactions varied from competitive to facilitative, depending on neighbor density (i.e., following a sigmoid function). Introducing within-guild facilitation through a nonlinear bounded function allowed populations, both simulated and empirical, to avoid extinction or runaway growth. In fact, nonlinear bounded functions (i.e., exponential and sigmoid functions) accurately predicted population trends over time within the range of abundances observed over the last 10 years. With the sigmoid function, the simulated communities of two species exhibited a higher probability of synchrony and oscillation compared to other functional forms. These simulated communities did not always show temporal stability, even when they were predicted to coexist. Overall, varying species interactions lead to realistic ecological trajectories and community dynamics when bounded by asymptotes based on neighbor density. These findings are crucial for advancing our understanding of how diverse communities are sustained and for applying ecological theory to real-world studies.
{"title":"Neighbor density-dependent facilitation promotes coexistence and internal oscillation","authors":"Lisa Buche, Lauren G. Shoemaker, Peter Vesk, Lauren M. Hallett, Oscar Godoy, Margaret Mayfield","doi":"10.1002/ecm.70040","DOIUrl":"10.1002/ecm.70040","url":null,"abstract":"<p>The ability of species to form diverse communities is not fully understood. Species are known to interact in various ways with their neighborhood. Despite this, common phenomenological models of species coexistence assume that per capita interactions are constant and competitive, even as the environment changes. In this study, we investigate how neighbor density-dependent variation in the strength and sign of species interactions changes species and community dynamics. We demonstrate that incorporating these sources of variation significantly improves predictions of ecological dynamics compared to the outcomes of typical models, which hold interaction strengths constant. We compared the performance of models based on different functions of neighbor density and identity in describing population trajectories (i.e., persistence over time) and community dynamics (i.e., temporal stability, synchrony, and degree of oscillation) in simulated two-species communities and a real, diverse annual plant system. In our simulated communities, we observed the highest level of coexistence between species pairs when species interactions varied from competitive to facilitative, depending on neighbor density (i.e., following a sigmoid function). Introducing within-guild facilitation through a nonlinear bounded function allowed populations, both simulated and empirical, to avoid extinction or runaway growth. In fact, nonlinear bounded functions (i.e., exponential and sigmoid functions) accurately predicted population trends over time within the range of abundances observed over the last 10 years. With the sigmoid function, the simulated communities of two species exhibited a higher probability of synchrony and oscillation compared to other functional forms. These simulated communities did not always show temporal stability, even when they were predicted to coexist. Overall, varying species interactions lead to realistic ecological trajectories and community dynamics when bounded by asymptotes based on neighbor density. These findings are crucial for advancing our understanding of how diverse communities are sustained and for applying ecological theory to real-world studies.</p>","PeriodicalId":11505,"journal":{"name":"Ecological Monographs","volume":"95 4","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":7.5,"publicationDate":"2025-11-09","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145477816","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Martin, Ellen C., Brage Bremset Hansen, Aline Magdalena Lee, and Ivar Herfindal. 2025. “Life History Traits Influence Environmental Impacts on Spatial Population Synchrony in European Birds and Butterflies.” Ecological Monographs 95(3): e70029. https://doi.org/10.1002/ecm.70029.
The funding statement for this article was missing. The below funding statement has been added to the Acknowledgments section of the article:
Open-access publishing facilitated by Schweizerische Vogelwarte, as part of the Wiley - Schweizerische Vogelwarte agreement via the Consortium Of Swiss Academic Libraries.
{"title":"Correction to “Life history traits influence environmental impacts on spatial population synchrony in European birds and butterflies”","authors":"","doi":"10.1002/ecm.70041","DOIUrl":"https://doi.org/10.1002/ecm.70041","url":null,"abstract":"<p>Martin, Ellen C., Brage Bremset Hansen, Aline Magdalena Lee, and Ivar Herfindal. 2025. “Life History Traits Influence Environmental Impacts on Spatial Population Synchrony in European Birds and Butterflies.” <i>Ecological Monographs</i> 95(3): e70029. https://doi.org/10.1002/ecm.70029.</p><p>The funding statement for this article was missing. The below funding statement has been added to the Acknowledgments section of the article:</p><p>Open-access publishing facilitated by Schweizerische Vogelwarte, as part of the Wiley - Schweizerische Vogelwarte agreement via the Consortium Of Swiss Academic Libraries.</p><p>We apologize for this error.</p>","PeriodicalId":11505,"journal":{"name":"Ecological Monographs","volume":"95 4","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":7.5,"publicationDate":"2025-11-05","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/ecm.70041","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"145443009","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"OA","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}