Epigenetic cytosine methylation covers most of genomic CpG dinucleotides in human cells. In addition to common deamination-mediated mutagenesis at CpG sites, an alternative deamination-independent pathway associated with DNA polymerase activity was previously described. This mutagenesis is characterized by the TCG→TTG mutational signature and is believed to arise from dAMP misincorporation opposite 5-methylcytosine (mC) or its oxidized derivative 5-hydroxymethylcytosine (hmC) by B-family replicative DNA polymerases with disrupted proofreading 3→5′-exonuclease activity. In addition to being less stable and pro-mutagenic themselves, cytosine modifications also increase the risk of adjacent nucleotides damage, including the formation of 8-oxo-2'-deoxyguanosine (8-oxoG), a well-known mutagenic lesion. The effect of cytosine methylation on error-prone DNA polymerases lacking proofreading activity and involved in repair and DNA translesion synthesis remains unexplored. Here we analyze the efficiency and fidelity of translesion Y-family polymerases (Pol κ, Pol η, Pol ι and REV1) and primase-polymerase PrimPol opposite mC and hmC as well as opposite 8-oxoG adjacent to mC in the TCG context. We demonstrate that epigenetic cytosine modifications suppress Pol ι and REV1 activities and lead to increasing dAMP misincorporation by PrimPol, Pol κ and Pol ι in vitro. Cytosine methylation also increases misincorporation of dAMP opposite the adjacent 8-oxoG by PrimPol, decreases the TLS activity of Pol η opposite the lesion but increases dCMP incorporation opposite 8-oxoG by REV1. Altogether, these data suggest that methylation and hydroxymethylation of cytosine alter activity and fidelity of translesion DNA polymerases.