The present study explores the potential of producing an alternative ASTM Type IL portland-limestone cement (PLC) using up to 20 % eggshell powder (ESP) by mass as crushed ESP is similar in chemical composition to limestone. To this aim, the hydration, durability, and mechanical properties of the ESP blended cementitious system (using ASTM Type I/II portland cement) are compared to a commercially available ASTM Type IL cement system containing approximately 10 % limestone. ESP was prepared by milling for 3 h upon drying. Characterization of the ESP was done by x-ray diffraction for phase analysis, scanning electron microscopy for microstructural observation, and laser diffraction analysis for particle size distribution. A range of experimental tests were undertaken on both the ASTM Type I/II cement replaced with ESP and the ASTM Type IL systems. Results revealed that the utilization of up to 20 % ESP enhanced the heat of hydration secondary peak (C3A) by increasing the aluminate phase kinetics in the blended system at a favorable pH pore solution. Also, an accelerating effect on the setting time (increased by 20–100 mins) was observed for ESP samples. Chemical shrinkage, compressive strength, and degree of hydration were similar between the ESP and PLC samples. Results also revealed that ESP particles were relatively more effective in minimizing drying shrinkage by 20–35 %, which is attributed to possible internal curing effects. Overall, 10 % ESP blended with ASTM Type I/II cementitious system was similar to the 10 % limestone containing PLC system and could be used as waste material in producing an alternative ASTM Type IL cement.