The dibenzo-annulated six-membered ring of 9(10H)-phenanthrenone- and the dibenzo-annulated five-membered ring in 1-acenaphthenone-derived α, β-unsaturated ketones were chosen to study the influence of the ring size on the reactivity of the exocyclic electron-deficient π-system. The kinetics of nucleophilic addition of carbanions to both Michael acceptors in DMSO at 20°C was monitored by UV-Vis spectroscopy to determine the second-order rate constants k2 of the carbon–carbon bond-forming reactions. The Mayr–Patz equation, lg k2 = sN(N + E), along with reported reactivity parameters (N and sN) of the carbanions were used to calculate the electrophilicity parameter E for both electrophiles. The higher electrophilicity of the phenanthrenone-derived Michael acceptor was further scrutinized by quantum chemical calculations, which showed a less advanced bond formation in the transition state and a greater thermodynamic driving force for adduct formation for the phenanthrenone (E = −15.93) than for the acenaphthenone-derived α, β-unsaturated ketone (E = −18.72). Thus, the phenanthrenone derivative is located on the electrophilicity scale in the reactivity range of structurally related ortho-quinone methides. The acenaphthenone derivative has similar electrophilicity as cyclic α, β-unsaturated lactones with an exocyclic methylene group. Further nucleophilic reaction partners for both studied electrophiles can now be systematically selected by using the Mayr reactivity scales.