Observed discharge has been used to estimate the temporal variation in non-point or diffuse loads of phosphorus into receiving waters. Given that a large number of river basins have limited or no discharge data, this study evaluated whether reliable estimates of annual total phosphorus loads can be generated using daily probability time series derived from precipitation or modeled discharge. The i-Tree probabilistic export coefficient model uses a daily probability time series to simulate the load traveling into and through a riverine network to simulate annual total phosphorus loads. Two types of multi-decadal probability time series were tested against observed loads and benchmarked against simulations driven by observed discharge: derived from observed precipitation to represent ungauged basins, and derived from modeled discharge, calibrated using at least one year of streamflow observations.
Model performance was tested in three diverse U.S. river basins. Compared with annual loads estimated using observed discharge, those estimated with modeled discharge on average had a decrease of 0.25 in the Pearson correlation coefficient (r), a decrease of 0.13 in the Index of Agreement (d), an increase of 13.3 metric tons in root mean square error (RMSE) and 15.7 metric tons in mean absolute error (MAE), and an increase of 3.90% in percent bias (Pbias). Estimates based on observed precipitation showed a larger performance drop, with a decrease of 0.36 in a decrease of 0.41 in d, an increase of 14.9 metric tons in RMSE and 14.5 metric tons in MAE, and a decrease of 6.6% in Pbias. These findings suggest that while modeled discharge provides more accurate estimates, precipitation-based estimates remain a viable option for ungauged basins.
扫码关注我们
求助内容:
应助结果提醒方式:
