Understanding the effects of silvicultural practices on soil carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) is critical for sustainable forest management. This study investigates how fertilization and vegetation control impact soil C and N concentrations and contents in Pinus taeda plantations across four sites in Georgia, USA. This study considers soil depths of 0–10, 10–30, and 30–50 cm and stand ages of ∼10 and ∼30 years. We hypothesized that vegetation control would reduce soil C and N by limiting belowground inputs from understory vegetation, while fertilization would enhance soil C and N by increasing productivity and suppressing microbial decomposition. Results showed that vegetation control reduced mineral soil C and N by 10 % through 50 cm; however, compensatory accumulation in the forest floor and aboveground biomass led to overall gains in ecosystem C and N. Fertilization increased C and N in the forest floor but did not have an effect on mineral soil through 50 cm. Increasing stand age resulted in insignificant changes in mineral soil C, while mineral soil N increased d by 21 % at the well-drained Piedmont site (Eatonton) and decreased by 36 % at the poorly drained lower coastal plain location (Waycross). Mineral soil N increase in all treatments at Eatonton reflect an unexplained ecosystem-level N input. Intensive management practices such as complete understory vegetation control have repeatedly been demonstrated to deplete mineral soil C and N while fertilization has relatively little effect on soil C or N.