Pub Date : 2019-01-01DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P344-363
Sara Luiza Hoff
A traducao e uma atividade que necessariamente implica a consideracao de questoes relacionadas ao tempo, posto que o texto a ser traduzido sempre se origina em um momento anterior ao do ato de traduzi-lo. Este trabalho se baseia nessa perspectiva e considera como os conceitos de sincronia e diacronia, propostos por Ferdinand de Saussure, se relacionam a pratica tradutoria. Enquanto a leitura estruturalista de Saussure muitas vezes defendeu a dissociacao completa entre essas duas nocoes, a traducao evidencia que a diacronia e a sincronia se relacionam intima e mutuamente. Portanto, o fenomeno tradutorio se torna um modo de apontar para a necessidade de, em certos casos, considerar a sincronia e a diacronia conjuntamente. Thinking about translation with Saussure: another consideration of synchrony and diachrony Translation is an activity that sometimes implies matters relating to time, since the text to be translated may originate in a moment previous to the act of translation. This perspective is the basis for this study, which considers how the concepts of synchrony and diachrony, proposed by Ferdinand de Saussure, relate to the practice of translation. While the structuralist interpretation of Saussure often advocated a complete dissociation between these two notions, translation seems to indicate that diachrony and synchrony are closely and mutually related. Therefore, the translation phenomenon becomes a way of indicating that there is a need to take synchrony and diachrony into account jointly in some cases. Keywords: Translation. Diachrony. Synchrony. Linguistic value DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p344-363
{"title":"Pensando a tradução com Saussure: uma outra consideração da sincronia e da diacronia","authors":"Sara Luiza Hoff","doi":"10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P344-363","DOIUrl":"https://doi.org/10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P344-363","url":null,"abstract":"A traducao e uma atividade que necessariamente implica a consideracao de questoes relacionadas ao tempo, posto que o texto a ser traduzido sempre se origina em um momento anterior ao do ato de traduzi-lo. Este trabalho se baseia nessa perspectiva e considera como os conceitos de sincronia e diacronia, propostos por Ferdinand de Saussure, se relacionam a pratica tradutoria. Enquanto a leitura estruturalista de Saussure muitas vezes defendeu a dissociacao completa entre essas duas nocoes, a traducao evidencia que a diacronia e a sincronia se relacionam intima e mutuamente. Portanto, o fenomeno tradutorio se torna um modo de apontar para a necessidade de, em certos casos, considerar a sincronia e a diacronia conjuntamente. Thinking about translation with Saussure: another consideration of synchrony and diachrony Translation is an activity that sometimes implies matters relating to time, since the text to be translated may originate in a moment previous to the act of translation. This perspective is the basis for this study, which considers how the concepts of synchrony and diachrony, proposed by Ferdinand de Saussure, relate to the practice of translation. While the structuralist interpretation of Saussure often advocated a complete dissociation between these two notions, translation seems to indicate that diachrony and synchrony are closely and mutually related. Therefore, the translation phenomenon becomes a way of indicating that there is a need to take synchrony and diachrony into account jointly in some cases. Keywords: Translation. Diachrony. Synchrony. Linguistic value DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p344-363","PeriodicalId":33154,"journal":{"name":"Leitura","volume":"1 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0,"publicationDate":"2019-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"69415024","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Pub Date : 2019-01-01DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P255-275
Dayanne Teixeira Lima
Sabe-se que Ferdinand de Saussure foi contemporâneo de Michel Breal. No entanto, um fato minimamente curioso e o da ausencia de uma discussao sobre as ideias de Breal na teorizacao de Saussure. Partindo desse pressuposto, o presente trabalho, de natureza teorica, tem o objetivo de discutir alguns aspectos da reflexao desses autores acerca do sentido , com o intuito de problematizarmos o "silencio" saussuriano em relacao as ideias do mestre frances. Para abordarmos a teorizacao saussuriana, partiremos de sua obra postuma, o Curso de linguistica geral , de 1916, e dos manuscritos reunidos e publicados, em 2002, por Simon Bouquet e Rudolf Engler nos Escritos de linguistica geral ; ja a perspectiva brealiana sera abordada a partir de seu Ensaio de semântica , publicado em 1897. Parece-nos que o estatuto necessariamente sincronico do signo , proposto por Saussure a partir da oposicao sincronia / diacronia , desautoriza a possibilidade de uma abordagem historica do sentido, tal como propos Breal. Saussure, Breal and the issue of the meaning It is known that Ferdinand de Saussure was a contemporary of Michel Breal. However, a minimally curious fact is the absence of a discussion of Breal's ideas in Saussure's theorizing. Based on this assumption, the present work, of a theoretical nature, has the objective of discussing some aspects of the reflection of these authors about the meaning, in order to problematize the saussurian "silence" in relation to the french master ideas. In order to approach Saussurian theorization, we will start with his posthumous work, the General Linguistics Course of 1916, and the manuscripts collected and published in 2002 by Simon Bouquet and Rudolf Engler in the Writings in General Linguistics ; the brealian perspective will be approached from his Semantic Essay , published in 1897. It seems to us that the necessarily synchronic status of the sign, proposed by Saussure from the synchrony/diacrony opposition, deters the possibility of a historical approach to meaning, as Breal proposed. Keywords: Saussure. Breal. Meaning. Synchrony and Diacrony DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p255-275
{"title":"Saussure, Bréal e a questão do sentido","authors":"Dayanne Teixeira Lima","doi":"10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P255-275","DOIUrl":"https://doi.org/10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P255-275","url":null,"abstract":"Sabe-se que Ferdinand de Saussure foi contemporâneo de Michel Breal. No entanto, um fato minimamente curioso e o da ausencia de uma discussao sobre as ideias de Breal na teorizacao de Saussure. Partindo desse pressuposto, o presente trabalho, de natureza teorica, tem o objetivo de discutir alguns aspectos da reflexao desses autores acerca do sentido , com o intuito de problematizarmos o \"silencio\" saussuriano em relacao as ideias do mestre frances. Para abordarmos a teorizacao saussuriana, partiremos de sua obra postuma, o Curso de linguistica geral , de 1916, e dos manuscritos reunidos e publicados, em 2002, por Simon Bouquet e Rudolf Engler nos Escritos de linguistica geral ; ja a perspectiva brealiana sera abordada a partir de seu Ensaio de semântica , publicado em 1897. Parece-nos que o estatuto necessariamente sincronico do signo , proposto por Saussure a partir da oposicao sincronia / diacronia , desautoriza a possibilidade de uma abordagem historica do sentido, tal como propos Breal. Saussure, Breal and the issue of the meaning It is known that Ferdinand de Saussure was a contemporary of Michel Breal. However, a minimally curious fact is the absence of a discussion of Breal's ideas in Saussure's theorizing. Based on this assumption, the present work, of a theoretical nature, has the objective of discussing some aspects of the reflection of these authors about the meaning, in order to problematize the saussurian \"silence\" in relation to the french master ideas. In order to approach Saussurian theorization, we will start with his posthumous work, the General Linguistics Course of 1916, and the manuscripts collected and published in 2002 by Simon Bouquet and Rudolf Engler in the Writings in General Linguistics ; the brealian perspective will be approached from his Semantic Essay , published in 1897. It seems to us that the necessarily synchronic status of the sign, proposed by Saussure from the synchrony/diacrony opposition, deters the possibility of a historical approach to meaning, as Breal proposed. Keywords: Saussure. Breal. Meaning. Synchrony and Diacrony DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p255-275","PeriodicalId":33154,"journal":{"name":"Leitura","volume":"1 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0,"publicationDate":"2019-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"69415057","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Pub Date : 2019-01-01DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P276-295
A. Marques
Neste trabalho, apresentamos uma leitura da nocao de relacao na reflexao teorica do neogramatico Hermann Paul em cotejo com a elaboracao teorica de Ferdinand de Saussure. Essa leitura demonstrara como a nocao de relacao e tratada, na reflexao de Paul, de maneira secundaria, principalmente, em funcao do entendimento da mudanca, diferentemente do que acontece na reflexao saussuriana, na qual ela ocupa lugar de destaque. Para tanto, procederemos com uma revisao bibliografica da obra Principios Fundamentais da Historia da Lingua de Hermann Paul, dando enfase as passagens em que a nocao de relacao e mobilizada por ele e, oportunamente, estabeleceremos uma comparacao com a proposta teorica saussuriana que se apresenta na edicao do Curso de Linguistica Geral . Re-establishing the fundamental relations: from historical linguistics to modern linguistics In this paper, we present an analysis of the notion of relation at theoretical reflection of the neogrammarian Hermann Paul in comparison with the theoretical elaboration of Ferdinand de Saussure. This analysis will show how the notion of relation is treated, in Paul's reflection, in a secondary way, mainly for the understanding of change, unlike what happens in Saussurian reflection, in which it occupies a prominent place. Therefore, we will proceed with a bibliographical revision of Fundamental Principles of the History of the Language by Hermann Paul emphasizing passages in which the notion of relation is mobilized by him and, timely, we will establish a comparison with the theoretical Saussurian proposal that appears in the edition of the Course in General Linguistics . Keywords: Relation. Linguistics. Neogrammarian. Ferdinand de Saussure DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p276-295
在这项工作中，我们阅读了新语法赫尔曼·保罗的理论反思中的关系概念，并比较了索绪尔的理论阐述。这篇文章展示了在保罗的反思中，关系的概念是如何被次要地对待的，主要是作为对变化的理解的功能，不像在索绪尔的反思中，关系占据了突出的位置。修订出版。和你这么多,我们的工作基本原则的历史语言的赫尔曼•保罗强调所有通道的nocao关系和用于他,及时拟定一个比较理论与提案saussuriana如果给你编辑的普通语言学课程。重新-establishing基本关系:从历史语言学到现代语言学这篇论文中,我们现在分析的关系的概念在理论上的反映neogrammarian赫尔曼·保罗在完成与索绪尔的理论elaboration斐迪南二世。分析将会显示这样的概念关系进行热处理,在保罗的反射,在中学历史的理解,主要变化,unlike发生在Saussurian反射,其中make it occupies prominent巷。因此,我们将proceed文献修订的基本原则的历史语言的赫尔曼·保罗emphasizing段落,动员的关系是由他和概念,及时的完成,我们将establish理论Saussurian提议,出现在普通语言学课程的版。关键词:关系。语言学。Neogrammarian。费迪南德·德·索萨尔DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p276-295
{"title":"Restabelecendo as relações fundamentais: da linguística histórica à linguística moderna","authors":"A. Marques","doi":"10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P276-295","DOIUrl":"https://doi.org/10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P276-295","url":null,"abstract":"Neste trabalho, apresentamos uma leitura da nocao de relacao na reflexao teorica do neogramatico Hermann Paul em cotejo com a elaboracao teorica de Ferdinand de Saussure. Essa leitura demonstrara como a nocao de relacao e tratada, na reflexao de Paul, de maneira secundaria, principalmente, em funcao do entendimento da mudanca, diferentemente do que acontece na reflexao saussuriana, na qual ela ocupa lugar de destaque. Para tanto, procederemos com uma revisao bibliografica da obra Principios Fundamentais da Historia da Lingua de Hermann Paul, dando enfase as passagens em que a nocao de relacao e mobilizada por ele e, oportunamente, estabeleceremos uma comparacao com a proposta teorica saussuriana que se apresenta na edicao do Curso de Linguistica Geral . Re-establishing the fundamental relations: from historical linguistics to modern linguistics In this paper, we present an analysis of the notion of relation at theoretical reflection of the neogrammarian Hermann Paul in comparison with the theoretical elaboration of Ferdinand de Saussure. This analysis will show how the notion of relation is treated, in Paul's reflection, in a secondary way, mainly for the understanding of change, unlike what happens in Saussurian reflection, in which it occupies a prominent place. Therefore, we will proceed with a bibliographical revision of Fundamental Principles of the History of the Language by Hermann Paul emphasizing passages in which the notion of relation is mobilized by him and, timely, we will establish a comparison with the theoretical Saussurian proposal that appears in the edition of the Course in General Linguistics . Keywords: Relation. Linguistics. Neogrammarian. Ferdinand de Saussure DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p276-295","PeriodicalId":33154,"journal":{"name":"Leitura","volume":"1 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0,"publicationDate":"2019-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"69415065","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Pub Date : 2019-01-01DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P127-151
G. F. Oliveira
O artigo ora apresentado visa a responder as seguintes questoes: 1) Que nocoes de escrita podem ser derivadas da reflexao saussuriana sobre o objeto da Linguistica? 2) Qual e o lugar assumido pela escrita na delimitacao do objeto da ciencia da lingua no CLG? Para tanto, o estudo investiga as relacoes entre a escrita e a materia da Linguistica, a escrita e o objeto da Linguistica e o lugar da escrita na zona fronteirica entre as Linguisticas da lingua e da fala e os elementos internos e externos a lingua. A investigacao levada a cabo permite derivar, da obra fundadora da Linguistica moderna, diversas nocoes de escrita , cuja elaboracao vai a par com a das nocoes de linguagem , lingua e fala , o que possibilita compreender a escrita como um contraponto necessario ao entendimento destas e, por conseguinte, do objeto da ciencia da lingua. The place of writing in Saussurean reflection on Linguistics’ object The present article aims to answer the following questions: 1) What notions of writing can be derived from the Saussurean reflection on the object of Linguistics? 2) What is the place that writing takes in the delimitation of the object of the science of language in the Course of General Linguistics? Therefore, the study investigates the relations between writing and the matter of Linguistics, the writing and the object of Linguistics and the place of writing in the frontier zone between the Linguistics of language and the Linguistics of speech and the elements that are both internal and external to language. The undertaken research allows us to derive, from the founding work of modern Linguistics, several notions of writing, whose elaboration goes hand in hand with the notions of language, langue and parole, which therefore enable us to comprehend writing as a necessary counterpoint to the understanding of these notions and, consequently, of the object of the science of language. Keywords: Langage. Langue. Parole. Writing. Object of Linguistics DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p127-151
{"title":"O lugar da escrita na reflexão saussuriana sobre o objeto da Linguística","authors":"G. F. Oliveira","doi":"10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P127-151","DOIUrl":"https://doi.org/10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P127-151","url":null,"abstract":"O artigo ora apresentado visa a responder as seguintes questoes: 1) Que nocoes de escrita podem ser derivadas da reflexao saussuriana sobre o objeto da Linguistica? 2) Qual e o lugar assumido pela escrita na delimitacao do objeto da ciencia da lingua no CLG? Para tanto, o estudo investiga as relacoes entre a escrita e a materia da Linguistica, a escrita e o objeto da Linguistica e o lugar da escrita na zona fronteirica entre as Linguisticas da lingua e da fala e os elementos internos e externos a lingua. A investigacao levada a cabo permite derivar, da obra fundadora da Linguistica moderna, diversas nocoes de escrita , cuja elaboracao vai a par com a das nocoes de linguagem , lingua e fala , o que possibilita compreender a escrita como um contraponto necessario ao entendimento destas e, por conseguinte, do objeto da ciencia da lingua. The place of writing in Saussurean reflection on Linguistics’ object The present article aims to answer the following questions: 1) What notions of writing can be derived from the Saussurean reflection on the object of Linguistics? 2) What is the place that writing takes in the delimitation of the object of the science of language in the Course of General Linguistics? Therefore, the study investigates the relations between writing and the matter of Linguistics, the writing and the object of Linguistics and the place of writing in the frontier zone between the Linguistics of language and the Linguistics of speech and the elements that are both internal and external to language. The undertaken research allows us to derive, from the founding work of modern Linguistics, several notions of writing, whose elaboration goes hand in hand with the notions of language, langue and parole, which therefore enable us to comprehend writing as a necessary counterpoint to the understanding of these notions and, consequently, of the object of the science of language. Keywords: Langage. Langue. Parole. Writing. Object of Linguistics DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p127-151","PeriodicalId":33154,"journal":{"name":"Leitura","volume":"1 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0,"publicationDate":"2019-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"69414235","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Pub Date : 2019-01-01DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P33-51
Fernando Silva e Silva
Este trabalho aborda a ciencia saussuriana de maneira historica e filosofica, de modo a oferecer uma leitura da obra de Ferdinand de Saussure que destaca a concepcao que o autor possuia da lingua e da linguagem, atravessada por conceitos nao tao comumente enfatizados nos estudos saussurianos, em especial a analogia e o virtual. Atraves desses conceitos, o fenomeno linguistico apresenta-se de forma muito peculiar na obra do linguista, pois trata-se de um fenomeno extremamente fluido e mutavel no espaco, no tempo e nas comunidades falantes. Finalmente, mostro como boa parte do interesse de Saussure, e do desafio da atividade do linguista para ele, esta em desenvolver um instrumental conceitual –e um entendimento filosofico – que o habilite a momentaneamente capturar os fluxos da lingua fugidia e multipla para descreve-la a partir de suas caracteristicas imanentes. The Saussurean linguistics and the multiplicity of languages This work approaches saussurean science in both a historical and philosophical way so as to offer a reading of Ferdinand de Saussure’s oeuvre which highlights the conceptions of langue and language held by the author, which are informed by concepts not so often emphasized in Saussurean studies, analogy and virtual specially. Through these concepts the linguistic phenomenon presents itself in a very unique form in Saussure’s work, because it is an extremely fluid phenomenon that changes in space, in time and in the speech communities. Finally, I show how a considerable part of Saussure’s interest, and for him the challenge in the linguist’s work, lies in developing the conceptual instruments – and the philosophical understanding – which renders them capable of momentarily capturing the flowing of the fleeting and multiple langue in order to describe it from its immanent characteristics. Keywords: Ferdinand de Saussure. Linguistic theory. Analogy. Virtual. Multiplicity DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p33-51
{"title":"A linguística saussuriana e a multiplicidade das línguas","authors":"Fernando Silva e Silva","doi":"10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P33-51","DOIUrl":"https://doi.org/10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P33-51","url":null,"abstract":"Este trabalho aborda a ciencia saussuriana de maneira historica e filosofica, de modo a oferecer uma leitura da obra de Ferdinand de Saussure que destaca a concepcao que o autor possuia da lingua e da linguagem, atravessada por conceitos nao tao comumente enfatizados nos estudos saussurianos, em especial a analogia e o virtual. Atraves desses conceitos, o fenomeno linguistico apresenta-se de forma muito peculiar na obra do linguista, pois trata-se de um fenomeno extremamente fluido e mutavel no espaco, no tempo e nas comunidades falantes. Finalmente, mostro como boa parte do interesse de Saussure, e do desafio da atividade do linguista para ele, esta em desenvolver um instrumental conceitual –e um entendimento filosofico – que o habilite a momentaneamente capturar os fluxos da lingua fugidia e multipla para descreve-la a partir de suas caracteristicas imanentes. The Saussurean linguistics and the multiplicity of languages This work approaches saussurean science in both a historical and philosophical way so as to offer a reading of Ferdinand de Saussure’s oeuvre which highlights the conceptions of langue and language held by the author, which are informed by concepts not so often emphasized in Saussurean studies, analogy and virtual specially. Through these concepts the linguistic phenomenon presents itself in a very unique form in Saussure’s work, because it is an extremely fluid phenomenon that changes in space, in time and in the speech communities. Finally, I show how a considerable part of Saussure’s interest, and for him the challenge in the linguist’s work, lies in developing the conceptual instruments – and the philosophical understanding – which renders them capable of momentarily capturing the flowing of the fleeting and multiple langue in order to describe it from its immanent characteristics. Keywords: Ferdinand de Saussure. Linguistic theory. Analogy. Virtual. Multiplicity DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p33-51","PeriodicalId":33154,"journal":{"name":"Leitura","volume":"1 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0,"publicationDate":"2019-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"69414955","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Pub Date : 2019-01-01DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P191-214
A. Scherer, Maria Iraci Sousa Costa
O presente artigo desenvolve uma reflexao acerca do complexo processo de edicao dos manuscritos saussurianos. A partir do estudo comparativo das notas de Ferdinand de Saussure publicadas em edicoes diferentes, como por exemplo, as notas editadas por Robert Godel e publicadas na revista Cahiers (1954), as notas editadas por Simon Bouquet e Rudolf Engler (2002) e tambem as notas editadas por Rene Amacker (2011), sustentamos que cada edicao publicada constitui-se como um livro de areia , no sentido poetico e metaforico atribuido por Borges. Cada uma dessas publicacoes de notas manuscritas saussurianas apresenta uma ordem que lhe e propria, atribuindo ao texto uma linearidade singular. Como sabemos, apenas uma pequena parte dos manuscritos saussurianos foi editada e publicada e, mesmo essa pequena parte desdobra-se em sucessivas (re-)edicoes, cada qual dando um novo/outro (re-)arranjo, o que nos faz refletir acerca da ordem e da (im)possivel linearidade das notas saussurianas no tocante aos criterios dados pelos seus editores. The problem concerning the edition of Saussurean notes: a book with no end nor beginning, or a book of sand in the manner of Borges? The present article develops a reflection on the complex process of editing the saussurian manuscripts. From the comparative study of Ferdinand de Saussure's notes published in different editions, for example, the notes edited by Robert Godel and published in the Cahiers (1954) journal, the notes edited by Simon Bouquet and Rudolf Engler (SAUSSURE, 2002) and the notes edited by Rene Amacker (2011), we maintain that each edition published is a book of sand, in the poetic and metaphorical sense attributed by Borges. Each one of these publications of saussurian handwritten notes presents an order that is its own, assigning to the text a singular linearity. As we know, only a small part of the Saussurian manuscripts has been edited and published, and even this small part unfolds in successive (re-) editions, each giving a new/another (re-)arrangement, which makes us reflect on of the order and (im)possible linearity of the Saussurian notes in relation to the criteria given by its editors. Keywords: Book of sand. Saussurian manuscripts. Editions DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p191-214
{"title":"A problemática acerca da edição das notas saussurianas: um livro sem fim nem começo ou um livro de areia a la Borges?","authors":"A. Scherer, Maria Iraci Sousa Costa","doi":"10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P191-214","DOIUrl":"https://doi.org/10.28998/2317-9945.2019V1N62P191-214","url":null,"abstract":"O presente artigo desenvolve uma reflexao acerca do complexo processo de edicao dos manuscritos saussurianos. A partir do estudo comparativo das notas de Ferdinand de Saussure publicadas em edicoes diferentes, como por exemplo, as notas editadas por Robert Godel e publicadas na revista Cahiers (1954), as notas editadas por Simon Bouquet e Rudolf Engler (2002) e tambem as notas editadas por Rene Amacker (2011), sustentamos que cada edicao publicada constitui-se como um livro de areia , no sentido poetico e metaforico atribuido por Borges. Cada uma dessas publicacoes de notas manuscritas saussurianas apresenta uma ordem que lhe e propria, atribuindo ao texto uma linearidade singular. Como sabemos, apenas uma pequena parte dos manuscritos saussurianos foi editada e publicada e, mesmo essa pequena parte desdobra-se em sucessivas (re-)edicoes, cada qual dando um novo/outro (re-)arranjo, o que nos faz refletir acerca da ordem e da (im)possivel linearidade das notas saussurianas no tocante aos criterios dados pelos seus editores. The problem concerning the edition of Saussurean notes: a book with no end nor beginning, or a book of sand in the manner of Borges? The present article develops a reflection on the complex process of editing the saussurian manuscripts. From the comparative study of Ferdinand de Saussure's notes published in different editions, for example, the notes edited by Robert Godel and published in the Cahiers (1954) journal, the notes edited by Simon Bouquet and Rudolf Engler (SAUSSURE, 2002) and the notes edited by Rene Amacker (2011), we maintain that each edition published is a book of sand, in the poetic and metaphorical sense attributed by Borges. Each one of these publications of saussurian handwritten notes presents an order that is its own, assigning to the text a singular linearity. As we know, only a small part of the Saussurian manuscripts has been edited and published, and even this small part unfolds in successive (re-) editions, each giving a new/another (re-)arrangement, which makes us reflect on of the order and (im)possible linearity of the Saussurian notes in relation to the criteria given by its editors. Keywords: Book of sand. Saussurian manuscripts. Editions DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p191-214","PeriodicalId":33154,"journal":{"name":"Leitura","volume":"1 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0,"publicationDate":"2019-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"69414822","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
{"title":"O espírito de Saussure: recepção e herança (a herança linguística saussuriana: Paris contra Genebra)","authors":"Christian Puech","doi":"10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p364-380","DOIUrl":"https://doi.org/10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p364-380","url":null,"abstract":"The spirit of Saussure: reception and heritage (the Saussurean linguistic heritage: Paris against Genebra) DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p364-380","PeriodicalId":33154,"journal":{"name":"Leitura","volume":" ","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0,"publicationDate":"2018-12-04","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"44125705","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
Pub Date : 2018-12-04DOI: 10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p381-393
Jürgen Trabant
{"title":"O Curso em busca de autor","authors":"Jürgen Trabant","doi":"10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p381-393","DOIUrl":"https://doi.org/10.28998/2317-9945.2019v1n62p381-393","url":null,"abstract":"","PeriodicalId":33154,"journal":{"name":"Leitura","volume":"1 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0,"publicationDate":"2018-12-04","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":null,"resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":"43396369","PeriodicalName":null,"FirstCategoryId":null,"ListUrlMain":null,"RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":"","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":"","EPubDate":null,"PubModel":null,"JCR":null,"JCRName":null,"Score":null,"Total":0}
京公网安备 11010802042870号
京ICP备2023020795号-1
扫码关注我们
求助内容：
应助结果提醒方式：