Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is a crucial technique for investigating urban wind and thermal environments. However, a clear understanding of the performance of different CFD approaches for wind and buoyancy-driven conditions in urban canyons remains lacking. This study systematically evaluates the performance of various CFD approaches for a street canyon with heated walls by comparing them with wind tunnel experimental data. The CFD approaches include three Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) models: the standard – (SKE), the realizable – (RKE), and the shear stress transport – model (SST); scale-adaptive simulations (SAS) with Courant–Friedrichs–Lewy (CFL) numbers less than 1 (SAS-CFL1) and 20 (SASCFL20); and large eddy simulation (LES). CFD simulation results for velocity, air temperature, and pollutant concentration are validated against WT measurement data. The findings indicate that the LES simulation achieves the highest accuracy across all flow variables evaluated, with normalized mean square error () values of 0.15 for velocity, 0.12 for temperature, and 0.64 for pollutant concentration. Although the two SAS simulations exhibit slightly lower accuracy than LES, they maintain similar and satisfactory performance, with the SAS-CFL20 yielding values of 0.16 for velocity, 0.26 for air temperature, and 0.90 for pollutant concentration. The three RANS models, however, exhibit significant inaccuracies, with the SKE model yielding values of 0.47 for velocity, 0.41 for temperature, and 2.04 for pollutant concentration. These inaccuracies are primarily due to the overestimation of buoyancy effects near heated walls, which notably enlarges the thermal-induced vortex and subsequently altering flow directions near the pollutant emission source. Among the evaluated CFD approaches, the SAS-CFL20 is approximately 15 times faster than the LES, presenting a favorable balance between accuracy and computational efficiency. These findings highlight the potential of the SAS-CFL20 for practical applications in future urban thermal environment studies.
扫码关注我们
求助内容:
应助结果提醒方式:
