The growing emphasis on sustainability in environmental health, climate change, and water usability has driven the exploration of economically and environmentally friendly approaches to enhance wastewater quality. Algae-mediated natural precipitation of minerals in wastewater, driven by these organisms' carbon utilization in photosynthesis, has emerged as a promising wastewater treatment (WWT) method due to its sustainability and cost-efficiency benefits. This study examines the impact of varying carbon content in bicarbonate forms on algae activity in mediating CaCO3 precipitation and how pH in algae-mediated solutions influences calcite precipitation. Solutions with different Ca2+ and HCO3− concentrations were prepared, and algae growth curves were established to ensure solution suitability. The experiments, conducted in two sets, employed ANOVA and t-test analyses for samples with common calcium concentration. Results indicated that increasing HCO3- concentration positively correlates with algae mediation and CaCO3 precipitation, while elevating pH from 9.8 to 11.0 negatively correlates with calcite precipitation. In conclusion, HCO3− additions were effective in enhancing algae-mediated calcite precipitation in wastewater. Recommendations include ensuring proportionate HCO3− additions to calcium content to optimize mineral precipitation without detrimental effects on algae.